The URL can be used to link to this page

Browse Search

Home My WebLink About20153212.tiff EXHIBIT INVENTORY CONTROL SHEET Case USR15-0035 - KEVIN AND CYNTHIA SULLIVAN Exhibit Submitted By Description A. Planning Commission Resolution of Recommendation B. Planning Commission Summary of Hearing Minutes dated 9/15/2015; C . Planning Services PowerPoint Presentation D . Scott and Ann Boskovich Letter of Opposition E . Willa and Bill Hintergardt Letter of Opposition F . Pat Staples Letter of Opposition G . Shannon Fewell Letter of Opposition H . Larry and Roxanne Cook Letter of Opposition I . Bree Lukens Timeline . research , photos . petitions J . Brad and Robin Hays Letter of Opposition K. Applicant Photos L. Shannon Guerrero Letter of Opposition M . Philip Lukens Letter of Opposition , Abstract, References N . Applicant Emails . pictures, article and report O . Bree Lukens Petition and Misc docs (41 pages) P . Chris Neubauer Picture Q . Terry Birdsall Study. dated 10/21 /2015 Y R . Terry Birdsall Presentation Thumb Drive S . T. U . V. W. 2015-3212 , , 4. 1 • " r4, Pa r b efki ' Ord dl' #'rP$ ar'�1 X11 biie�►► Prc}P is �,ion and corr,m,_ aciebird 0•91 CAnintr wawar it Os Boils .� '� � .�. TI °3 CO nest intlif eit co sassA �,,yy�y� ca gals ie''a '0' all. - k , • '= * ' �^ " __- A. iii 1�ir 'lona ,l. .. i i�l �r twat aril * '� 1 I ,�,,�' tiles +'r I ••; JO �A i •� roil 4 .t �wtd4�+ { • } e • 4` , .y1+r{I 1 J�� • rte• w• cate4.47inqb171-4 LS > 4 ti • lAittµ �i� s - a.� . • 5 n ii)ti. , 6#•A iii , *woo stvi 1■ ��a 'h ass +lianesmal _ li: 74 *_Ir3; ` 3/4 y * 'Cies. - JD' ' 4,, I's . , , ri 1 . . . , , 1. ,'!' y • Z _ �._ •• - y • ^ r ' $V w. I {.. -i_ -z •. i ..� � ,�,•,,-walk ` 1` } .SIN . 7!+ Y. r 1 F • 114 r • �� . . y� L. • - • \Ili 71• s 1 Mp kA - si '� * oCr+ F �iy, ' tr� • ''t ` _ K 1 , ,r y i� z,... s1 ' +- .' 1. NI��•,M til. � L;I: 31 .r . r : ' ``'lit. �lic �j�R O14264-�� X14,, ► ''�l, "440 �.44 illiN, , 410116 7. VirillikailliC4 A f v It a « •.� J ► - :� - � ^``I a/' ' , I, 41/4 4 r .1.. lit NH. t ,� * `r�t EXHIBIT Vi '- - k IL 3-• v r, i i{r •' /l , / 11y� -It It tit '4I' '— ii a 7 II ay j a . _ F r'a AA CD —0 € �► • ISA Nil • iticeIIf r .0 ,,. ... N. r •f 11 .s . y r . ■..,..„,..,,... ....k•_ • - - . • t *-IY f+T1_ .t 'LW se j••,•.i! , �.. a - 4 I 1 • - 1 VIEW TO THE WEST FROM CR 19 ACCESS it sir ) Ail PM tik biAll 1 i441Oa Miglialle \\ ilttalgra kitVaNik alksaW &comic 144-- Wail; ififit \ iik rre• vi 41, iitfi - t is__ _ _ • _ , *40 tir 11. VIEW TO SOUTH FROM CR 124 t i _ - Ter _ t Mt s IM_' -_;imL I • IMa—mi_ -. - - - _ r a... Y ,n e r --= — -.._.- 4-0 fa- 6. ` .� llillamt • S I _ / ir .y.�� at • i - . VIEW TO THE EAST FROM CR 124/CR 19 ACCESS : - . • 1MI+I \ . _ d Y► let IIIII 1 1 -Ir I i I' I iI • 4# il: - !SS _ 1 —IlliVailliliall- 'i . . Ii-- - r_L �_ _ - _ _ tie1 •, _.-air MIr! r bit +, ! C 4 s `, - I mail -maim 1 - ;'- . - _ _.1. r-- - - - - -. a -.. Ai _ - 111 are .Y . VIEW TO SOUTH FROM CR 19 ( EAST OF TANK SITE ) 1 I • . 1111144-:-- _ t t aa. -•:- $i fi 111' a 444 $' #— S f t ti ! 7 Mr; s - . , 4 :itat t , - ' - t; A fb Or% , • L-.71,Hi a tz 4 1 VIEW TO THE WEST - TOWARD SITE FROM CR 19 SECTION LINE ' W' - •eis • per • C. ., • _ 1 I - 4sib Jib rem • • el ri II .♦ Z mac •••% • ti . .^1kies _SP 2.1 fit erds :/ if !.9 die N seselateral 001.11 St12 Tisa Juanicorena rom: Jennifer Fuller ent: Friday, October 02, 2015 9:41 AM To: CTB Subject: FW: Docket #2015 -95, KEVIN AND CYNTHIA SULLIVAN (USR15 -0035) Add to file? From : Boskovich, Dee A [mailto : Dee_Boskovich@kindermorgan .com] Sent: Friday, October 02, 2015 8:22 AM To : Mike Freeman <mfreeman@co .weld .co . us>; Julie Cozad <jcozad@co.weld .co. us>; Barbara Kirkmeyer < bkirkmeyer@co .weld .co . us>; Sean Conway <sconway@co .weld .co . us>; Steve Moreno <smoreno@co .weld .co. us>; Jennifer Fuller <jfuller@co.weld .co . us> Subject: Docket #2015-95, KEVIN AND CYNTHIA SULLIVAN ( USR15-0035) We are writing this email in objection to Sullivan Sanitation's proposed application allowing buried tanks for the purpose of holding septage and to spread this waste on parcel #020133400003 located in Carr, CO in Weld County. We are extremely concerned about various affects this will have on our quality of life as well as environmental issues that this may cause. • 1 . Due to the fact that land is permeable how long before this waste ends up in the aquafer? Will this affect our groundwater and water wells that we get our potable water from ? Is Sullivan Sanitation, LLC going to be testing our well waters annually for coliform and other bacteria? 2 . What process will be taken to prevent pathogens of bacteria, viruses and other contaminants from being transported to rodents, birds and animals which can then infect our pets or livestock and then my family? ? 3 . What will be done to alleviate the potential odors this will cause? We live less than a mile east of the site and the wind typically blows from the west. 4. What regulations are placed on the septic land spreading by the EPA and how often are they audited to be sure regulations are followed ? What will be done to assure that this septage will not end up in the creek beds to the south of the property? 5 . What will be done to keep the current wildlife from grazing on this property so they don't get disease or die? 6. What will be done about the truck traffic that this will add to the rural gravel road ? Dust abatement? 7 . Did Sullivan Sanitation, LLC pull a permit before they buried tanks on the property last year? • EXHIBIT IJ) 1 L4 2 (6 - DD Our community was not made aware that these septic tanks were being buried by our homes nor did Weld County let us know that the plan was to spread human waste in our neighborhood . And to be clear, it's our understanding that this is SOT sewage biosolids, which is what was originally on Sullivan's application . Instead it is untreated septic sewage. In eld County what is the specified minimum distance away from homes, wells and watercourses for this septage to be spread ? We sincerely hope that Weld County will NOT allow this proposed untreated septage spreading to proceed . Our family lives in Carr for the quality of life and this seems unacceptable that this would be allowed so close to homes. Thank you for your consideration on this disturbing matter. What would you do if this proposal was by your home? Scott and Dee Boskovich 61066 County Road 19 %2 Carr, CO 80612 970-215-9228 • • 2 Tisa Juanicorena From: Jennifer Fuller Sent: Tuesday, October 06, 2015 10:19 PM To: CTB Subject: FW: Docket #2015 -95, KEVIN AND CYNTHIA SULLIVAN (USR15-0035) Please add to file. From : wbhintergardt@ezlink.com [mailto:wbhintergardt@ezlink.com] Sent: Tuesday, October 06, 2015 9: 16 PM To: Mike Freeman <mfreeman@co.weld.co.us>; Julie Cozad <jcozad@co.weld.co.us>; Barbara Kirkmeyer <bkirkmeyer@co.weld.co. us>; Sean Conway <sconway@co.weld .co.us>; Steve Moreno <smoreno@co.weld.co.us>; Jennifer Fuller <jfuller@co.weld.co.us> Subject: Docket #2015-95, KEVIN AND CYNTHIA SULLIVAN ( USR15-0035) I am sending this email to object to the proposed application allowing buried tanks for the purpose of holding septage which is within a mile of our home. The tanks Mr. Sullivan buried are metal tanks that are 10 years old. He buried the tanks before the county had approved his permit. We have lived in Carr for 40 years and we know the stiff requirements for a septic system . We recently had a new system installed which required 14 dump trucks of dirt to replace our soil. The total cost to us was over $10,000. Why does Mr. Sullivan not have the same stiff requirements? We are concerned that his tanks will leak and contaminate our water supply. Mr. Sullivan bought this property for the purpose of using it for storing septage and applying it to his property. What Mr. Sullivan doesn't know is that this part of Weld county should never have been farmed. I don't believe that the land will tolerate the waste and it will become a dust bowl. The ground has very shallow top soil and many rocks. That is why there are two gravel pits in Carr. Since we live within a mile of his property, I am concerned about the smell. The prevailing wind is from the west in the winter and from the south in the summer. Either way, we will get the brunt of the smell. I am asking that you support the people in our community and deny the request. Thank you, EXHIBIT Willa and Bill Hintergardt 1 61183 County Road 19.5 Carr CO 80612 970 897-2434 2 Tisa Juanicorena From: Chris Gathman Sent: Thursday, October 08, 2015 8:53 AM To: Karla Ford; Tisa Juanicorena; Sullivan Septic Cc: Esther Gesick Subject: FW: Hearing date for Sullivan (USR15-0035) to be continued to Wednesday, October 21st at 10 PM Chris Gathman Planner III Weld County Department of Planning Services 1555 N. 17th Avenue, Greeley CO. 80631 Ph: (970)353-6100 ext. 3537 Fax: (970)304-6498 Confidentiality Notice: This electronic transmission and any attached documents or other writings are intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and a d may contain information that is privileged, confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify sender by return e-mail and destroy the communication. Any disclosure, copying, distribution or the taking of any action concerning the contents of this communication or any attachments by anyone other than the named recipient is strictly prohibited. Original Message From: Pat Staples [mailto:ptstpls@yahoo.com] Sent: Thursday, October 08, 2015 8:31 AM To: Chris Gathman Subject: RE: Hearing date for Sullivan (USR15-0035) to be continued to Wednesday, October 21st at 10 PM Good morning Chris, Thank you for the notification that the hearing is postponed until 10/21 at 10am. As a co-owner of property near the site, I am opposed to the proposed land use this hearing would be addressing. I had taken a personal vacation day off from work to drive up from Aurora to attend. I will reschedule my work, so I will be there on the 21st. Again, thank you for letting me know. EXHIBIT Regards, I Pat Staples 1 . 303-475-4642 1 Tisa Juanicorena From: Chris Gathman Sent: Tuesday, October 13, 2015 2:48 PM To: Karla Ford; Tisa Juanicorena Cc: Lauren Light; Wayne Howard; Sullivan Septic Subject: FW: Docket #2015 -95, KEVIN AND CYNTHIA SULLIVAN (USR15 -0035) Chris Gathman Planner III Weld County Department of Planning Services 1555 N. 17th Avenue, Greeley CO. 80631 Ph : (970)353-6100 ext. 3537 Fax: (970)304-6498 tai r. ! — Confidentiality Notice: This electronic transmission and any attached documents or other writings are intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify sender by return e-mail and destroy the communication . Any disclosure, copying, distribution or the taking of any action concerning the contents of this communication or any attachments by anyone other than the named recipient is strictly prohibited . From: Tom Parko Jr. Sent: Monday, October 12, 2015 5 : 23 PM To: Chris Gathman Subject: Fwd : Docket # 2015-95, KEVIN AND CYNTHIA SULLIVAN (USR15-0035) Sent from my iPhone EXHIBIT Begin forwarded message: From : Julie Cozad <jcozadco.weld.co.us> Date: October 12, 2015 at 4:52 : 16 PM MDT To: Tom Parko Jr. <tparko@co.weld.co.us> Cc: Commissioners <COMMISSIONERS@co.weld.co.us> Subject: F%%' : Docket #2015-95, KEVIN AND CYNTHIA SULLIVAN ( t1SRI5-0035) Tom, I am forwarding another email to you that we received . Thanks, Julie Julie Cozad Weld County Commissioner, District 2 1 1150 O Street P. O. Box 758 Greeley, CO 80632 Office. 970-336-7204 Cell: 970-515-2424 Fax 970-336-7233 .cozad@weldgov.com j ,g ; r � Confidentiality Notice: This electronic transmission and any attached documents or other writings are intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify sender by return e-mail and destroy the communication . Any disclosure, copying, distribution or the taking of any action concerning the contents of this communication or any attachments by anyone other than the named recipient is strictly prohibited . From: Shannon Fewell [mailto :smfewell@yahoo.com ] Sent: Monday, October 12, 2015 1 : 19 PM To: Mike Freeman <mfreeman@co.weld .co.us>; Julie Cozad <jcozad@co.weld .co.us>; Barbara Kirkmeyer <bkirkmeyer@co.weld .co.us>; Sean Conway <sconway@co.weld .co. us>; Steve Moreno <smoreno@co.weld .co. us>; Jennifer Fuller <jfuller@co.weld .co. us> Subject: Docket #2015-95, KEVIN AND CYNTHIA SULLIVAN ( USR15-0035 ) I am adamantly opposed to allowing buried tanks for the purpose of holding septage and ultimately spreading this material on parcel #020133400003 . This poses a severe threat to the water quality in this area. We are dependent on wells in this area. Please do not approve this usage! Shannon Fewell 9348 Gray Ave. Carr, CO 80612 (970) 897-2705 2 EXHIBIT From : Inrcook@ezlink.com :mailto:Inrcook@ezlink.com: Sent: Saturday, October 10, 2015 3:31 PM To: Mike Freeman <mfreeman@co.weld.co.us>; Julie Cozad <icozad@co.weld.co.us>; Barbara Kirkmeyer <bkirkmever@co.weld.co.us>; sconwav@weldcov.com; Steve Moreno <smoreno@co.weld.co.us> Subject: case #USR15-0035 septic dump site near Carr, Co. We have lived in Carr for 15 years. It is becoming more and more evident that because we live in a non governed town that what we think or say doesn't matter to any of you. Well you are so wrong. Guess what„ we pay taxes too!! Allowing this Septic Waste dump site will contaminate our land and wells not to mention the stink.Would you like to have this in your back yard?? My guess is probably not. We live here cause we enjoyed the peace and quiet and the serenity. Now all that is changing! We wake up to the smell of diesel when the new Connell-Carr pit fires up their equipment every day. Not to mention the increase in noise and truck traffic from the new transfer station. Seems to us that you all are getting a good kick back from all this and we get a kick in the teeth. Just because we chose to live away from all the crap that city life has to offer you think our lives don't matter. You allow these industries to move in regardless of how we feel, regardless of what we say. Seems like we pay your way just so you can do what ever it is you want to do just to get a few $$$$ out of it. We can't even get our town roads taken care of on a regular basis. I'm willing to bet you wouldn't think of driving on roads like ours every day. Guess what„ we pay taxes too. We pay your wage! What is it going to take to get the county to work with us and help us keep our land and wells from being destroyed and keep our water supply and livestock and food safe. Certainly allowing a septic dump site will not be the answer. There is a reason that other counties are not allowing it„ why is Weld county so cold and fail to understand what we are feeling and saying at your meetings. Seems you already have made up your minds as to what you are going to do. Just going through the legal motions so you can sleep at night! We are real people too. Work for everything we have just to have it dumped on by the high and mighty county employees that we HAD trust in. One more thing„ just wondering if anyone has bothered to check on these new industries to make sure they are following the guidelines of operations that were laid out for them. Is there going to be a schedule for monitoring the proposed sewage storing tanks that have already been placed underground, Just how do you inspect something that is buried. These tanks were never treated to prevent leakage and you know as well as I do that they will leak at some point. The towns people affected by this sewage dump sight are requesting proof of inspection. When, How ,and by whom. If that's not too much to ask. TOTALLY OBJECT TO THIS PROPOSED APPLICATION OF BURIED SEWAGE TANKS. You would too if it was in your back yard. Sincerely Larry and Roxanne Cook 9348 Paden Ave. 3 Tisa Juanicorena From: Jennifer Fuller Sent: Monday, October 19, 2015 8:32 AM To: CTB Subject: FW: Petitions set 1 of 2 From: breelukens@gmail.com [mailto:breelukens@gmail.com] Sent: Sunday, October 18, 2015 8:36 PM To: Sean Conway <sconway@co.weld.co.us>; Julie Cozad <jcozad@co.weld.co.us>; Mike Freeman <mfreeman@co.weld.co.us>; Barbara Kirkmeyer <bkirkmeyer@co.weld.co.us>; Steve Moreno <smoreno@co.weld.co.us>; Jennifer Fuller <jfuller@co.weld.co.us> Subject: Fwd : Petitions set 1 of 2 Please note that there are 207 households in Carr Colorado and there are 197 Signatures of both residents of Carr and those who visit Carr and utilize Carr's water. Loading Sent from my iPhone einle° Vkd Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 TIMELINE 2013 • Kevin and Cynthia Sullivan purchase parcel #020133400003 in Carr, CO 2014 June • Carr residents become aware of tanks . partially buried . • Mr Sullivan informs residents of plan to store and spread septage on parcel # 020133400003 . Exhibit 1 picture of tanks July • Carr resident. Willa Hintergardt sent an email to Weld County regarding her concerns about Mr. Sullivan 's proposed plan . and the quality and safety of water within the Carr community . Exhibit 2 copy of email communication 2015 September • Carr residents learn of the Sullivan 's applying for a permit from Weld County for his three. 20 , 000 gallon tanks which he already buried on parcel #020133400003 . Exhibit 3 the current picture of the area where partially buried tanks were seen in June . RESEARCH State Department of Public Health and Environment - State Department of Public Health and Environment - Water Control Commission 22 1 Scope and Purpose 2 .A. - Management Agency point b : "if the proposed facility is located in the unincorporated area of the county. The county through its commission or it designee. is requested to review and comment upon: the relationship of the treatment works to the local long range comprehensive area as it affects water quality: the proposed site location alternatives including the location with respect to the flood plain: and the capacity to serve the planned purpose. A recommendation of approval from the county is considered to be a statement that the proposal is consistent with the water quality considerations contained in its local comprehensive plan. " It is clear that under state statute the State of Colorado holds County Commissioners legally and morally responsible for maintaining water quality . The Dangers of Raw Untreated Septage on the Carr Ground and in the Colorado Water • Pathogens Page 11 9378 County Road 124 . Carr, CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 • E-Coli • Bacteria • Hazardous Waste • NITRATES -According to a study done by the State of Alabama . " Nitrate contamination has caused the abandonment of more ground water supplies nationwide than toxic waste . " Note that septage is used as fertilizer because of its nitrates and such nitrates may be good for crops but deadly to our water_ ECS Monthly Bulletin April 2013 United States v . Hurley Enterprises. Inc. d/b/a Hurley's Oilfield Services, No . 4: 13-CR-00001 ( D. N . D ) . AUSA Cameron W. Hayden and ECS Senior Trial Attorney Christopher J . Costantini . On March 22 . 2013 , Hurley Enterprises d/b/a Hurley's Oilfield Services (Hurley) pleaded guilty to a felony Clean Water Act violation ((33 U . S . C . §§ 1319 (c) (2) (A) . 1345(e) ) stemming from the dumping of sewage . The company was sentenced to pay a $50 . 000 fine and to implement an environmental compliance plan , which will be monitored over a two-year period by the North Dakota Department of Health . • Hurley is a sewage waste collection company that services oil well drilling sites in the Bakken/ Three Forks drilling operations in North Dakota . Hurley dumped domestic septage waste at various locations that resulted in the pooling of the waste as well as entry of the waste into waterways . At one dump site . toilet paper mixed with human waste was dumped down a steep embankment and into a ravine that led to Cottonwood Lake. At another site . domestic septage ran into an unnamed tributary that flowed into Epping Spring Brook Dam . This case was investigated by the United States Environmental Protection Agency Criminal Investigation Division . Please note the applicants property is very similar as he too has a steep embankment and a tributary that sits a mere 600 feet from his buried tanks. December 30 . 2014 . Preislery General Casualty Ins . CO 2014 WL 7373070 ( Dec. 30 . 2014) and Wilson State Ins . CO v. Falk . 2014 WL One case involved a septic service business that had a permit to apply septage as a fertilizer on their neighbors farmland . The neighbor's well became contaminated by runoff. killing some cattle . and they sued the septic business insurers . The Supreme Court agreed with lower courts that the septage qualified as a pollutant, so the pollution exclusion applied and the insurance Page 12 9378 County Road 124. Carr. CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 company did not have to cover the damage "Onsite InStaller. " "Wisconsin Supreme Court Finds Septage is a Pollutant in Well-Contamination . " Accessed 17 . Oct. 1015 Please note in these instances water tributaries and famers were affected by the pollutant of septage . However, as you will read a tributary is on the applicants property and a large non - Tributary closed water basin sits below Carr Colorado so not only do risk the water of surrounding farmers we risk of 100 years of clean water siting below Carr if the applicants requests are approved . Waterways and water sources as they relate to parcel applicants proposed tanks and injection site. Exhibit 4 - map of surrounding water ways Exhibit 5 - map of the non-tributary, closed water basin Exhibit 6 - map of Carr Exhibit 7-Map of Wells Tributary on applicant's property is 600 feet from buried tanks • EPA - Under the Clean Water Act Considers Tributaries "Water Ways . " In May of 2015, the EPA amended the Clean Water Act to recognize the important roll tributaries play within our water systems . "On May 27 , 2015 . the new definition expands regulation to all "tributaries to traditional navigable waters" . The article continues. "Supporting the inclusion of all the tributaries under the New Rule . the agencies state the science , as summarized in the EPA's technical report concerning the ecological and physical connectivity of tributaries . has met the burden created by the Rapanos decision to show the significant nexus regardless of duration and magnitude of their flow. " The article goes on to mention the EPA is able to regulate areas within 3/4 of a mile on either side of a tributary . "The significant nexus applies to any wetland that is not adjacent but within 100 year flood plain or within 4 . 000 feet or 3/4 of a mile of a tributary or tidal wave . " "Environmental Consultants" "EPA and the Corps Issue New Definition of the "Waters of the U S . " May 28 . 2015 . Accessed October 3. 2015 Based on the New Rule of the Clean Water Act tributaries are now considered "water ways" and should be regulated The applicant's tanks sit . 12 miles from the center of a tributary therefore considering the applicants testimony "all tanks leak" we ask the commissioners to decline USR15-0035 Page 13 9378 County Road 124 . Carr, CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 Spring Creek and Lone Tree Creek • Water resource for farmers. ranchers . and communities downstream . See exhibit 8 State of Colorado Determination of Non- Tributary Water See exhibit 9 Terrance Birdsall statement of Non -tributary water See exhibit 10 Statement of the Colorado Department of Health noted in the Quantum Water Quality Assessment See exhibit 11 NEP Letter to SEO Non- Tributary Aquifer • Weld County Planning Commission meeting . September 25 . 2015 summary : Commissioner stated . " He has some familiarity with the water system around Carr: he feels that compatibility with the land use citing Section 23-2-220 .A. 3 . the area is over the top of a huge non-tributary closed basin aquifer . He added that is also concerned with effluents to the Spring Creek and Lone Tree Creek. P 9 • The Dakota Cheyenne Aquifer according to Colorado geologicalsurvey . org does sit directly under Carr. Colorado . According to the Colorado Ground Water Commission . the Ogallala and the Dakota Cheyenne aquifers are now considered the Southern High Plains Designated Water Basin _ "On June 30 , 2009 . The Colorado Ground Water Commission accepted amended Rule 5. 2 . 3 for the Southern High Plains Designated Ground Water Basin so all the aquifers identified above can be administered as a single -hydraulic system . " ("Water Level Measurements in the Southern High Plains Designated Water District 2014 " 2014 Accessed 4 . October. 2015 . ) The South Platte River Basin water. state , co us The Evidence the Dakota -Cheyenne and Upper Laramie Aquifers that Sit Beneath Carr Colorado is Non-Tributary • According to the Office of the State Engineer State of Colorado as of Dec, 28th . 2012 state . " Staffs Initial Determination is that the groundwater in the Upper Laramie aquifer underlying the Applicant's property in northern Weld County located in Section 19 of Township 11 North Range 66 West . 6th P . M . . is NON- TRIBUTARY . as defined in section 37-90- 103 ( 10 . 5) . C . R . S" The State Engineer notes, " The Laramie -Fox Hills Aquifer (is) within the Cheyenne Basin can be up to 450 feet thick" • Evidence of the Depths and Bounds of the Aquifers that Lay Beneath Carr Colorado and ruling Aquifers are Non -Tributary • Please Note this determination from the State Engineer is on a property that is approximately 2 . 5 miles from unincorporated town of Carr and the applicant's property. The Dakota- Cheyenne Aquifer stretches through a 7 . 000 square mile area . "The Office of the State Engineer State of Colorado also notes . The Laramie-According to Page 14 9378 County Road 124 . Carr. CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 The Geology Hydrology of the Deep Bedrock Aquifers in Eastern Colorado ( Water - Resource Investigations Report 85-4240) states. " Colorado and a zone of relatively fresh water extending Fox Hills Aquifer here is similar to the Laramie Fox Hills in the administrative Denver Basin . It is a confined aquifer at Niobrara Energy Park and within the Cheyenne Basin until its outcrop on the western mountain front and on the Greeley Arch just north of the Cache la Poudre River. "( Note this means that below that applicants property sits a wealth of clean untouched confined water) • The State Engineer notes that is a "confined aquifer" According to Terreance Birdsall of Quantum . " Based on the remapping of these geological . it was determined that the Upper Laramie aquifer at the property is not in contact with the local surface water. which is part helped secure a non-tributary determination from the State of Colorado . " ( Meaning any bacteria . pathogens , and or pollutants that seep into the soil and then into the water will be damaged forever as the water sitting beneath Carr as a lake) • The Water found in the Dakota- Cheyenne aquifer and Upper Laramie Aquifer is Clean Drinkable Water that could last 100 years • One can conclude based on the State Engineers Report and the Geology Hydrology report that the "relatively fresh water" not only sits beneath the Niobrara Energy Park but if it extends 7 . 000 square feet that it too sits below the applicants property. • According to the Colorado Department of Health , " The Laboratory analysis indicates that the constituents that were analyzed are within the Maximum Contaminant Levels for drinking water according to the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment. " • Quantum Water also notes the . " aquifer life of 100 years . was used to calculate the total amount of ground water available . " meaning beneath Carr there lies 100 years worth of clean drinkable water. • Based on these finding we ask the commissioners to decline USR15-0035 in order to keep a major water source for Colorado Clean and DRINKABLE . Underground Storage Tanks See exhibit 12 Documentation of the type of tanks the applicant has buried See exhibit 13 Spec Sheet from dragon production tanks • Problems with Under Ground Storage Tanks There are many dangers when placing three 20 , 000 gallon 10 year old steel tanks underground • According to the EPA. "The greatest potential threat from leaking USTs is the contamination of drinking water. " 1015 Revised Underground Storage Tank Regulations" . Underground Storage Tanks . ( EPA, 1 July, 2015 Accessed , September 28 . 2015) . The EPA also recognizes . "Many mistakes can be made during installation . For example , the mishandling of the tank during installation can cause failure of fiberglass can cause structural failure of reinforced plastic tanks or damage to steel coatings and cathodic protection . " Beginning April of 2016 all Underground Storage Tanks. "must meet secondary containment requirements . " The EPA is recognizing Page 15 9378 County Road 124 . Carr. CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 Underground Storage tanks often leak and are proactively as of April 2016 requiring secondary containment on all new and existing tanks. • The EPA also requires the applicant certify the tanks he has already placed underground to be inspected . The EPA states . " the installation has been inspected and approved by an implementing agency " As the tanks are underground they are unable to be inspected which violates the EPA regulations . The applicants steel tanks are buried and are unable to be inspected . This violates EPA regulation and puts our water safety at greater risk . • An operation and management plan for site under the State of Colorado Sec. 14-6- 130 D 3 require "Any provisions for the storage of domestic septage at the site . including type of storage and spill containment and clean up procedure _ The above referenced Statue derived from the State of Colorado inherently implies UTS's leak and therefore such sites need to have a plan for spill containment and clean up_ • Therefore not only does the EPA recognize spill containment is important but the State of Colorado also recognizes the need to have a plan for containment when UTS's leak . The EPA has such standards of secondary containment and inspection in order to minimize the risk of drinking water contamination . We merely ask the applicant to comply with such Federal and State safety measures • Under normal circumstances we would ask the applicant for spill containment and or clean up procedures plan . According to the EPA any Underground Storage Tank is to have a secondary containment new or existing by April 2016 . However. considering the applicants tanks are steel and their life expectancy is expired . They are faulty and are putting our water at risk. The tanks have not been inspected . There is no secondary containment system They are near a water tributary They are sitting above two aquifers that at their current state contain fresh water. We ask the Commissioners to decline the application to bury already buried tanks to hold septage with the end goal to spread such septage . This property has a tributary which is recognized as a waterway by the EPA and Clean Water Act. The risk of any buried tank holding septage that close to a tributary and laying on top of a closed fresh water basin is too great of risk not only to Carr but to the State of Colorado . Existing Land Uses Weld County Chapter 23 Zoning Division 4 Sec 23-2-220.A. 3 states "USES which would be permitted will be compatible with the existing surrounding land USES" . Environmentally Sensitive Land and Wildlife • The land surrounding the applicant's property is in CRP which is "removing environmentally sensitive land from agricultural production and planting species that will improve environmental quality " There are several parcels of land surrounding the applicant's land that are in CRP . As noted earlier land qualifies to be part of the CRP program because it is "environmentally sensitive" meaning that it is fragile land in Carr's case is being restored to mostly native grasses that will hold the ground and Page l 6 9378 County Road 124 . Carr, CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 sustain our abundant antelope population . deer herds . and rabbits . • Considering that the applicant noted he is an expert in the septic industry for 21 years and also noted "all tanks leak" . It can be argued three 20 . 000 gallon tanks of leaking septage is not compatible with "existing land uses" of the surrounding "environmentally sensitive land . " If the applicants permit is approved and when septage does leak from the applicants tank what effect will it have on the these "environmentally sensitive lands" and the wildlife that is sustained from the applicants property and surrounding properties . • Sec 14-6- 1100 Operating Standards for Domestic Septage Permit K . Animals shall not be grazed on the land for thirty days after the application of domestic septage . As we know the Carr area is very unique as antelope can be seen grazing on the applicants and surrounding properties on a daily basis . Carr is a prime hunting area and such native animals have the opportunity to graze the applicant's property at any time . Such grazing on contaminated ground could have devastating effects on the wildlife and or the hunters that consume the wildlife . Thereby the applicants proposed use of the land is not compatible with current use. Long Term Use of Land Under the State Department of Public Health and Environment from the Water Control Commission 22 . 1 Scope and Purpose 2 . A. Under Managements Agency point b. States the following. • The county through its commission or its designee is requested to review and comment upon. the relationship of the treatment works to the local long range comprehensive area as it affects water quality; the prosed site location alternatives including the location with respect to the flood plain : and the capacity to serve the planned purpose. • The state delegates commissioners to evaluate the" local long range comprehensive area as it affects water quality. " If the commissioners are considering water quality when reviewing septage storage facilities we surely can argue allowing the applicant to store three 20. 000 gallon tanks of septage a mere 600 feet from a "water way" (tributary) according to the Clean Water Act is " not compatible with existing land use" . This tributary supplies water to Nunn and Peirce . If the commissioners deny the applicant's permit they will be upholding the provision and thereby ensuring the health , safety. and Weld County Department of Health Chapter 14 Se. 12-6- 140 A. 9 . States the following : • "There is adequate provision for the health . safety, and welfare of the inhabitants and the county . " The tributary on the applicants property connects to other water ways (Spring Creek and Lone Tree welfare of all those who use the water that flows from the applicants tributary . We urge the commissioners based on these matters to decline USR15-0035 . Weld County is a Right to Farm County that is why many residents in Carr have moved there and remained there. Weld County Right to Farm Act States the Following , Page 7 9378 County Road 124 . Carr, CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 "Water has been . and continues to be. the lifeline for the agricultural community . It is unrealistic to assume that ditches and reservoirs may simply be moved "out of the way" of residential development. When moving to the Country . property owners and residents must realize they cannot take water from irrigation ditches , lakes or other structures , unless they have an adjudicated right to the water. " The water siting beneath Carr is a life line to the following farmers 1 Mr. Brad and Mrs . Robin 2 . Mr. Scott and Mrs . Dee 3. Mr. Ross Mrs . Linda 4 . Mrs _ Mosness 5 Mr. Phil 6 Mr. Chuck 7 Mr. Eric 8 . Mrs . Bev 9. Mr_ Loren 10 Mrs. Vicky 11 . Mr. Bill and Mrs . Willa 12 Mr Buck 13 Mr Shadrach 14 Mr. Rusty 15 Mrs . Aubrey 16 . Mr. Gallegoes 17 . Mr. Arvin 18 . Mr. Harold 19 . Mrs . Arta 20 . Mrs . Charlene 21 . Mrs . Marilynn 22 . Mr. Mike 23 . Mr. Kenneth 24 . Mr. Dana 25 Mr. John 26 Mr. Duane and Mrs . Lynn 27 . Mr. Loren 28 _ Mr. Troy 29 Mr. Brent 30 . Mr. Steve 31 _ Mr. Kelly 32 . Mr. Justin 33 Mrs . Marsha Pagel 8 9378 County Road 124. Carr, CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 34 . Mrs . Gerturd 35 Mrs . Shannon 36 Mr. Richard 37 . Mrs . Melissa 38 Mrs . Donna 39 Mr. Kenneth 40 Mrs . Brennda 41 Mrs . Kristina 42 . Mr. Bill 43 Mr. Bo 44 Mrs . Allison 45 . Mr Harold Please note there are 207 households in Carr Colorado and of those households we gathered 174 signatures of those is opposition of the approval of USR15-0035 . The above lists are of those actively farming and using water a "lifeline" to their livelihood and way of life . Those mentioned on this list and petition to have a RIGHT TO FARM There are other options for the applicant the owner of a commercial business to dispose of untreated sepatge . The Plant located in Greeley Colorado and the plant located in Denver Colorado . There is no need to put the farmer's water in Carr at risk . We have RIGHT TO FARM please decline USR15-0035 Page j 9 9378 County Road 124 . Carr. CO 80612 . . .ik'44ii♦1r•s;oat�ir s. -. Rr1dCJ�tt1 i . ialelik --t Y• . , - - ♦. • • or ., i• - H -ImillisilMaTel%1\i' • ' jr .w s ►�1v neste ..e.. ....,:77:4„..i.104:40::::;,, . .:, ..„:7a : .0... .. a • % ' 401‘..li , i ... - : • e‘ '-,;' .* .Ill; . ' ( fit •••• ' 4.:,71.:."-.1 • y cl. • ... :. el:.t• = ' ►ter M• s l . . e.:, _ ! • ��i.r}•� , '.1 'f,• Pt fi tie4 ,fi r,.� /gel1:'k}��Rr' •; I. },� c p- 't K) • 4 I j 4�� •Or Y �Y a .>r ` '�' ';� r ISM. . e tF , �Yz t \, ',D q S ii-LI iv. �• ll�tis 1 y� � t1e'}d. iA�! • ifit :' 4 :. 1 I I - ,�j 0 n v r l /a - dye Exhibit 1 1 74.7 _ r Page 1 of 1 Exhibit 2 wbhintergardt@ezlink.com From: <webmaster(u)co.weld.co.us> Date: Wednesday, July 2, 2014 9: 12 AM To: <whhintergardt(&ezlink.com> Subject: Copy of Online Code Complaint Name of Complainant: Willa Hintergardt Address of Complainant: 61183 County Road 19.5. Can CO 806 Email Address: wbhintergardt4,ezlink.com Complainant Phone: 970-897-2434 Address of Alleged Violation: Paelflaieganall Nature of the Alleged Violation: Buried three 30.000 to 50,000 gal. tanks to fill with sewage to be spread on land. How are Your/Your Property Impacted by this Alleged Violation? Illimmmusiiisisil EIS Where is Your Property in Relation to the Alleged Violation: Less than 1 mile. Have You Discussed Your Concerns With the Property Occupant? I haven't. If Not, Please Explain Why? There is no residence on property Are You in a Subdivision Which has Covenants that Prohibit the Activity? No Have You Contacted the Homeowners Association? Select 9/ 14/2015 r Covered Tanks.jpg Page 1 or l 1\—lExhibit 3 I f ...;-...--,67 . i _ .+ y T' �c y+'_ .• i r- r � • _ . r • .eat.y tom' ti r • a • • .t. • • Iiar . .... Air ,4 11- 410t %‘: • iii,$ ' • ay• a ': f ) . �N. • . S + . Yr'` Y 1 . 6 https: "mail .google.com/ /scs/mail-static/ lis/k=gmail.main.en.xfA.12j 1 ortQ.O/m=m_i.t,i... 10/12/2015 e r WELD COUNTY Exhibit 4 in ONLINE MAPPINL Fart Cairn !ti ITO yU _. f., _ _ In Is; ` l 4.eroomheb� Illi Ci G�r- lliWISIDA .-1 it t t ,' Legend ci Parcels C _ '1 ►+S -- - - — Highway f Road \ _ - - - _ hx3l 198115 ft Rood • — Hryhway O County Boundary • retail 5138 - j _ s • 4? 4 • V �• • _ -- . 383125 ft Total: 3831 « ft • • - _ tii 5;', 1/424 Ei it IIS 4 WCk 120 ' 1: 27,459 a 120 Notes 4,576.5 0 2,288.25 4,576.5 Feet Distances to tributaries leading to two Irr:s map is a user generateJ S:at: Output rrcr• Internet mapprry },it a•x.i is tor major creeks reference only Data layers ,ha, appear 6r• " , ap may or may not be accurate, WGS_1984 Web_Mercator Auxiliary_Sphere current, or otnerwse reliable C Weld County Colorado THIS MAP IS NOT TO BE USED FOR NAVIGATION ' .s .-- . c1/44 r +y < IS vy. 3 ... _„„dillear 00,40 Exhibit 5 "clip ' ,� , tn. Nt Alt. et .P.- t: ilk I al• 1 (t14.tt .1,.. iii , I., . .4- .1 a -. l 4- 1 I' .4 Ii lin R� WS. 14 4 cal t, ... S` , • A r. i i • '� Y 4 aa ^. P ,•: ! QCS f EM ; . . .../_-.:'. ,tib+04, t i411 re a to . It . ..,. t Jr 4 w . 4. 't 4t% - Ss �k I• all t b! 4 µ )y • € a r C re 1 * 1 401 Y , N mil ft I r jer �• r, Exhibit 61 4 . • t � �_ V A 4 •••• t . / � I • - t �, t 'Z ei j ', I ' ti` a• k .7.• Ok 4,. i I as 4_, a t C ,;„ i i tire iv • (r. sire • i if 1 • -• isii - ._._ - .. : . .wo 14 I. �t .` 1 i ______. _ . ... a .. • i 1 alp • •1 • w - II 1 • Les . i L r _. t� ill M - •` -• 3 4 = 4 t c - ' ! _ fe •„.. J• I . ... . .1 I : . . , __ _ _• . s , 3 • ,... g \ 4 \ . pi . -......--...—.1 . It 4 • 4 ' li A * I 4 i Ut • , � r Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 : 00 am Exhibit 7 Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility - . , f Toila 1.14mi J i' 7-7,:1 AVE • 0 , t.s5 • mmunity C�irc11 - `4 AVE. f.'3 ; . • IAVL - - r .Y'1 •r '.!?\-1/4:�- _ Total 080 m it TOW. 0.63 mi- �tt t , - a z Teta0.12mi t _ mi `These are estimates as the submitted site plan did not offer exact coordinates, nor, appropriate measurements Weld County Online Mapping was used to generate this map- http://www co weld co. us/maps/propertyinformation/ ( no subject) - breelukensagmail.com - ( imaiI Page I of 2 Exhibit 8 Gmail .;.ir.ipost: (no subje Inbox (19) Bree l u BEFORE THE OFFICE OF THE STATE ENGINEER Starred STATE OF COLORADO Important Sent Mail IN THE MATTER OF THE NIOBRARA ENERGY PARK LLC PETITION FOR ) Drafts (29) NONTRIBUTARY GROUND WATER IN THE LARAMIE FORMATION IN ) Circles NORTHERN WELD COUNTY. COLORADO; (UNDER ) PERMIT APPLICATION ) andcqee RECEIPT NO, 3655537) IN REFERENCE TO ISSUANCE OF WELL PERMITS ) kateel PURSUANT TO SECTION 37-90-137(4), C.R.S. ) Moonwwwwwvw Notes Personal — FINAL DECISION OF THE STATE ENGINEER .rd Travel More This matter involves a petition ("Petition") submitted by Niobrara Energy Park ("Applicant") on June 4, 2012 requesting a determination of nontributary ground water for an area as further • described in the attached Initial Determination of the State Engineer's Office. The Applicant submitted the petition in accordance with the State Engineer's Policy 2010-4 and gave notice as required by the policy. 2.6 GB t11%)of The policy allows 30 days for any person to respond to the petition. The SEO received no Manacle comments from any parties. The Applicant provided clarification on the petition in subsequent correspondence. As a result of the correspondence and further discussion between the Applicant and the staff of the Hydrogeological Services branch of the Division of Water Resources ("Staff'), the Staff completed an Initial Determination on December 28. 2012. FINAL DECISION OF THE STATE ENGINEER 1. The State Engineer has reviewed the Petition submitted by the Applicant and the Initial Determination completed by the Staff. 2. The State Engineer has determined that Applicant and the Staff have acted in accordance with Policy 2010-4 and hereby adopts the Initial Determination (attached) and grants the Petition by finding that the subject ground water identified in the Initial Determination is nontributary, as that term is defined in Section 37-90-103(10.5). Dated this 28°i day of December, 2012 ick Wolfe. Di r/State Engineer BEFORE THE OFFICE OF THE STATE ENGINEER STATE OF COLORADO INITIAL DETERMINATION OF THE NONTRIBUTARY NATURE OF GROUND WATER PURSUANT TO STATE ENGINEER'S POUCY 2010-4 IN THE MATTER OF THE NIOBRARA ENERGY PARK LLC PETITION FOR NONTRIBUTARY GROUND WATER IN THE LARAMIE FORMATION IN NORTHERN WELD COUNTY, COLORADO; (UNDER PERMIT APPLICATION RECEIPT NO. 3655537) IN REFERENCE TO ISSUANCE OF WELL PERMITS PURSUANT TO SECTION 37-90-137(4), C.R.S. Background https:/ 'm all .google.com/m atI/u/0/:'tab=wm 10/ 14/2OI5 ( no subject) - breelukens'a gmail .com - Gmail Page 2 of 2 BEFORE THE OFFICE. OF THE STATE ENGINEER STATE OF COLORADO IN THE MATTER OF THE NIOBRARA ENERGY PARK LLC PETITION FOR NONTRIBUTARY GROUND WATER IN THE LARAMIE FORMATION IN NORTHERN WELD COUNTY, COLORADO; (UNDER ) PERMIT APPLICATION RECEIPT NO. 3655537) IN REFERENCE TO ISSUANCE OF WELL PERMITS PURSUANT TO SECTION 37-90-137(4), C.R.S. FINAL DECISION OF THE STATE ENGINEER This matter involves a petition ("Petition") submitted by Niobrara Energy Park ("Applicant") on June 4, 2012 requesting a determination of nontributary ground water for an area as further described in the attached Initial Determination of the State Engineer's Office. The Applicant submitted the petition in accordance with the State Engineer's Policy 2010-4 and gave notice as required by the policy The policy allows 30 days for any person to respond to the petition. The SEO received no comments from any parties. The Applicant provided clarification on the petition in subsequent correspondence As a result of the correspondence and further discussion between the Applicant and the staff of the Hydrogeological Services branch of the Division of Water Resources ("Staff'), the Staff completed an Initial Determination on December 28. 2012. FINAL DECISION OF THE STATE ENGINEER 1 the State Engineer has reviewed the Petition submitted by the Applicant and the Initial Determination completed by the Staff. 2. The State Engineer has determined that Applicant and the Staff have acted in accordance with Policy 2010-4 and hereby adopts the Initial Determination (attached! and grants the Petition by finding that the subject ground water identified in the Initial Determination is nontributary. as that term is defined in Section 37-90-103( 10.5).2' O Dated this 28th day of December, 2012 ick Wolfe. Dire r State Engineer BEFORE THE OFFICE OF THE STATE ENGINEER STATE OF COLORADO INITIAL DETERMINATION OF THE NONTRIBUTARY NATURE OF GROUND WATER PURSUANT TO STATE ENGINEER'S POUCY 2010-4 IN THE MATTER OF THE NIOBRARA ENERGY PARK LLC PETITION FOR NONTRIBUTARY GROUND WATER IN THE LARAMIE FORMATION IN NORTHERN WELD COUNTY, COLORADO; (UNDER PERMIT APPLICATION RECEIPT NO. 3655537) IN REFERENCE TO ISSUANCE OF WELL PERMITS PURSUANT TO SECTION 37-90-137(4), C.R.S. Background https://mail .google.com/mail/u/0/:'tab=wm 10/ I 4/201 5 Abstract: THE IMPORTANCE OF ACCURATE GEOLOGIC MAPPING FOR AQUIFE. .. Page 1 of 2 rn------ Exhibit 9 25th Ailllll'c'i"scll y Annual Meeting & Expo f, c,.: < „ ' t river, Colorado USA ME ., a ' 'l • .1: :• 2OI , ,2; ICA` It• C' . > , •- . a _ 'c. � ' . _ ; • S amit Start I Author Index I View Uploaded Presentations I Meeting Information P.:1(:*' N.: I.i Presentation Time. 10:30 AM THE IMPORTANCE OF ACCURATE GEOLOGIC MAPPING FOR AQUIFER DELINEATION AND CALCULATED SURFACE WATER DEPLETIONS, NORTHERN WELD COUNTY, COLORADO BIRDSALL, Terrance R., Quantum Water Consulting, Lakewood, CO 80235, terrance©quantumwaterco.com Based on geologic mapping circa 1978, it was determined that significant discrepancies existed between the geologic descriptions and known aquifer boundaries at a property located in north central Colorado. The geology of the area was refined using surface mapping. a review of more recent literature, analysis of subsurface geophysical logs. analysis of water well lithology logs. and discussions with regulatory geologists. Published geologic mapping of the area indicates Laramie Formation is located at the surface of the majority of the site. However, it was determined that the White River Group exists at the surface and extends several miles beyond the southern boundary of the Property. significantly further than the 1978 mapping suggested. A large paleo-stream channel deposit. the 'natural fort' often pondered by geologist passing between Wellington, Colorado and Cheyenne. Wyoming along Interstate 25, was also mapped through the area as the Chadron Formation. The remainder of the White River Group. predominately tuffaceous claystone and siltstone, is reinterpreted as the Brule Formation member. The White River Group formations have been determined to be regional aquicludes, and perched water from the Ogallala Formation is easily observed in outcrop. Based on the remapping of these geologic formations, it was determined that the Upper Laramie aquifer at the property is not in contact with the local surface water. which in part helped secure a nontributary groundwater determination from the State of Colorado. Session No. 9 T42. Current Groundwater Challenges in the Rocky Mountain Region Sunday 27 October 2013 8.00 AM- 12.00 PM Room 207 (Colorado Convention Center) Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs. Vol. 45. No. 7, p.45 © Copyright 2013 The Geological Society of America (GSA), all rights reserved. Permission is hereby granted to the author(s) of this abstract to reproduce and distribute it freely. for noncommercial purposes. Permission is hereby granted to any individual scientist to download a single copy of this electronic file and reproduce up to 20 paper copies for noncommercial purposes advancing science and education. including classroom use. providing all reproductions include the complete content shown here, including the author information. All other forms of reproduction and/or transmittal are prohibited without written permission from GSA Copyright Permissions. See more of: Current Groundwater Challenges in the Rocky Mountain Region See more of Topical Sessions « Previous Abstract I Next Abstract » 2013 The Geological Soaely of America https://gsa.conlex.com/gsa/20 I 3A M/webprouram/Paper232207.htm I I 0/ 14/2015 Abstract: THE IMPORTANCE OF ACCURATE GEOLOGIC MAPPING FOR AQUIFE... Page 2 of 2 https://gsa.confex.com/gsa/2013AM/webprogram/Paper232207.html 10/ 14/2015 • Fwd: Storage Tank - breelukensgmail.com - Gmail Page I of 2 - Exhibit 10 Gmail COMPOSE Fwd Stol Quantum Water Consulting Inbox (19) Jackie I 3500 S Wadsworth Blvd., Suite 408 Starred Lakewood, Colorado 80235 Important (720) 524-4294 QUANTUM Sent Mail w A ' t 2 Drafts (29) From E Circles Date It Subject andcqee To Jack kateel CC' Willi Moonwww wwwww July 2, 1012 Notes Personal Good / Mr. Craig Harrison Harrison Resources Travel Attache More 2725 Rocky Mountain Avenue #400 which c Loveland, CO 80538 I hope RE: Water Quality Analysis, Niobrara Energy Park, Test Hole Water Sample Emily crliM111. Dear Craig: m:14091i As requested, the following narrative discusses the results of the laboratory analytical analysis of the From: J. ground water collected during the test hole drilling. The water sample was collected on May 12. 2012 Sent: Tt and submitted to Accutest Analytical Laboratory in Wheat Ridge, Colorado. The analytical laboratory Subject results are attached and Table 1 is a summary of the results Hells The water sample was analyzed for inorganic parameters and general chemistry. The test hole was drilled using a polymer gel and a surfactant, both petroleum based distillates These additives did not affect the analytical results since they are organic based constituents. The Material Safety Data Sheets I IN e. for these additives are also attached to this letter An analysis of the analytical laboratory results indicates that the sample is of water that is naturally occurring and is derived from silicate igneous rock minerals such as feldspars, micas and amphiboles. The laboratory analysis indicates that the constituents that were analyzed are within the Maximum Contaminant Levels (MCLs) for drinking water according to the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment (CDPHE) as indicated on Table 1. Please let me know if you have any other questions. Sincerely, QUANTUM WATER CONSULTING • Theresa Jehn-Dellaport President attachments www quantumwaterco.corn Table 1 - Summary of Water Quality Analysis for NEP Test Hole Sample Date 5/11/2012 Metals Analysis Units Results Maximum Contaminant Level Alume um rngf 0 631 Antn,nety rng/I <0.03 '"1 CO; Arsenic mgrl <0.025 a 01 Barium mg/I 0-117 Beryiwn mg/I <0.01 1 0>L4: Cadmwrn mgrl <0.01 7 (105 Calown mg/I 19.3 Chrornnrn mg/ <0.01 Copper mg/ c0.01 Lead mg/I <0.05 Magnesium mgA 4.52 - https://mail.google.cum/mail/u/0/?tab=win I0/ 14/20I 5 Fwd : Storage Tank - breelukens"Jgmail .com - Gmail Page 2 of 2 Quantum Water Consulting 3500 S Wadsworth Blvd., Suite 408 Lakewood, Colorado 80235 (720) 524-4294 QUANTUM w . • t . July 2, 1012 Mr Craig Harrison Harrison Resources 2725 Rocky Mountain Avenue #400 Loveland, CO 80538 RE. Water Quality Analysis, Niobrara Energy Park, Test Hole Water Sample Dear Craig: As requested, the following narrative discusses the results of the laboratory analytical analysis of the ground water collected during the test hole drilling. The water sample was collected on May 12. 2012 and submitted to Accutest Analytical Laboratory in Wheat Ridge, Colorado. The analytical laboratory results are attached and Table 1 is a summary of the results. • The water sample was analyzed for inorganic parameters and general chemistry. The test hole was drilled using a polymer gel and a surfactant, both petroleum based distillates These additives did not affect the analytical results since they are organic based constituents. The Material Safety Data Sheets for these additives are also attached to this letter An analysis of the analytical laboratory results indicates that the sample is of water that is naturally occurring and is derived from silicate igneous rock minerals such as feldspars, micas and amphiboles. The laboratory analysis indicates that the constituents that were analyzed are within the Maximum Contaminant Levels (MCLs) for drinking water according to the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment (CDPHE) as indicated on Table 1. Please let me know if you have any other questions. Sincerely, QUANTUM WATER CONSULTING Theresa Jehn-Dellaport President attachments wives quarttumwarerro.com Table I - Summary of Water Quality Analysis for NEP Test Hofe Sample Data. 5/11/2012 Metals Analysis Units Results Maximum Contaminant Level Aluminum mgA 0.631 - ✓lntxnony mg+l <0.03 0.006 Arsecuc mg/ c0.025 0 01 Bairn mgll 0.117 2 Berybum r119/1 <0.01 0.004 Cadmium mg/ c0-01 0.005 Calcium mgt 19 3 Ceromium mQA <0.01 0.1 Copper mg/ <0.01 Lead mg/ <0.05 Magnesium rrgI 4.52 - https://mail .google.com/mail/u/0/?tab=wm 10/ 14/2015 Exhibit 11 Quantum Water Consulting 3500 S Wadsworth Blvd., Suite 408 Lakewood, Colorado 80235 (720) 524-4294 QUANTUM WATER September 18, 2012 Mr. Matt Sares Office of the State Engineer 1313 Sherman Street, Room 818 Denver, CO 80203 RE: Additional Information in Support of the Niobrara Energy Park, LLC Petition for Nontributary Ground Water in Northern Weld County, Colorado (Receipt No. 3655537) Dear Matt: This letter is a follow-up to the Professional Report submitted to the Office of the State Engineer (SEO) dated June 1, 2012, and a response to your comments dated August 22, 2012. In support of Division 1 Water Court Case 11CW275, Quantum Water prepared and submitted to the SEO on September 11, 2012 an Expert Report (Report), including a North-South hydrogeologic cross- section to determine the thickness and lateral extent of the aquifers beneath the Terry Grazing Property in northern Weld County. The Terry Grazing Property, generally located in the northern two-thirds of Township 11 North, Range 67 West and the southern half of Township 12 North, Range 67 West is immediately adjacent to the proposed Niobrara Energy Park (NEP), located at Section 19, Township 11 North, Range 66 West. The data complied to draft this hydrogeologic cross-section and the associated Report have been released to Harrison Resources, the developer of the Niobrara Energy Park, for the purpose of supporting the petition to the SEO for a nontributary ground water determination. In agreement with your August 22nd comments, the production interval from 1,400 to 1,800 feet below ground surface (bgs) has been reinterpreted as the Fox Hills Sandstone. This corresponds well with the geophysical logs of nearby oil and gas wells, and the completion reports of nearby water wells. The geophysical logs, as shown on Plate 1 in the Report, indicate that the thick ( 1,300+ feet) Laramie Formation and the Fox Hills sandstone are one contiguous, saturated interval. This interval has been identified as the Laramie-Fox Hills (L-FH ) aquifer. The static water level of the NEP Test Hole 50626-MH, 143 feet bgs (measured April 15, 2012), is 70 feet below the contact with the overlying White River Group, and shows the L-FH aquifer to be unconfined. The hydrogeologic cross-section (Report, Plate 1) was extended approximately 35 miles to the south, past the nearest perennial stream to NEP, the Cache la Poudre River. The data from oil and gas geophysical logs, water well completion reports, and surface geologic mapping show that the rocks of the L-FH aquifer crop out north of the axis of the Greeley Arch, are not in direct connection with the Cache la Poudre River, and are separated from the river by the Pierre Shale. The NEP Test Hole 50626- MH is also included on the cross-section (Report, Plate 1). After 100 years of continuous withdrawal, a well completed on the Property into the L-FH aquifer will not deplete the Cache la Poudre River, or any other natural stream, at an annual rate greater than one- www.quantumwaterco.com Mr. Sores September 18, 2012 tenth of one percent of the annual rate of withdrawal. As defined by C.R.S. § 37-90-103( 10.5), all ground water withdrawn from wells completed into the L-FH aquifer at the location of NEP is nontributary. As there are no connected stream segments to model to, aquifer modeling was deemed inappropriate. Sixteen-inch short normal resistivity values from three oil and gas geophysical logs (Amoco Champlain 279, Lone Tree State #1-14, and Solar Petroleum No. 2) and one water well (DWR Permit Number 96966) were used to estimate the saturated thickness of the L-FH aquifer. Using a conservative "shale line" value of 8 ohm.m2/m, as outlined in the Report, the estimated saturated thickness of the L-FH aquifer below NEP is 1,130 feet. This saturated thickness, along with a specific yield of 15% (based on the Denver Basin rules), the 644-acre NEP property, and an aquifer life of 100 years, was used to calculate the total amount of ground water available (Table 1, below): Table 1 - Estimate of amount of ground water availability beneath 644 acres Saturated Thickness Acres (ft) Specific Yield Acre Feet Acre Feet/Year 644 1, 130 0. 15 109,158 1,091.6 With these conditions, there are approximately 1,091.6 acre feet per year of nontributary ground water available from the L-FH aquifer beneath the Niobrara Energy Park. We would be happy to further discuss with you our findings if you like. In the meantime, please contact us with any questions at your convenience. Sincerely, QUANTUM WATER CONSULTING teteti1/44,— l/f�ai.c Theresa Je -Dellaport President cc: Craig Harrison, Niobrara Energy Park, LLC Skip Kelly, Select Energy Page 12 Fwd : Storage Tank - bred ukens&gmail .com - Gmail Page I of 2 < Exhibit 12 Gmail ivy -„X•XN,•s Fwd: Stol - Production Tanks I Inbox (19) API API 12F Starred Jackie I Important Sent Mail _____ is i4 •. ... . • Drafts (29) From E _ . • Circles lir- Datet •lit ��,yT'� '•�, - andcgee T eCl � jam_ / - A I, " kateet CC' W lk 'S MoonHrvhrnwvwtwwvw - �• Notes titer Personal Good F Travel �p> _- Attach( _ More which c • +1t• hope _ _ Emily " Fry 1112212 <, -.•. From: Ji DESIGN I PRESSURE APPROXIMATE OUTSIDE Sent: Ti. NOMINAL OZ PER SO IN WORKING DIAMETER HEIGH. Subject CAPACITY PRESS. VACUUM CAPACITY 88L FT -IN 1 t 90 16 1/2 72 7-11 10 Hell( Apt 100 18 12 79 9-6 8 150 18 1/2 129 9-6 12 200 16 12 166 12-0 10 I k m. ,• - - -- 7 210 16 112 200 10-0 15 • '-..'',e,.. 250 16 1Q 224 11-0 15 I 300 16 12 266 12-0 15 1 400 16 1Q 368 12-0 20 s- - --Or .. -- 500 16 1 Q 468 12.0 25 ! 'f� 500 8 1/2 479 15-6 18 it- r 750 8 12 746 15.6 24 SPECIFICATIONS: ADD-ONS AVAILABLE: • Built to API 12F specifications monogrammed • API Manways • Threaded Fittings and non-monogrammed • Stairs and Walkways • 3/16 or 1/4 inch steel plate construction • Gravel bands • Dike walks • Steel shot blasting prior to direct to metal • Decelerators • Cable Level Gauges industrial coating paint • Fill Lines • Thief Hatches • Internal lining available • Knuckle Boom Truck Delivery QV fj iI You Tube Ot`I � sales@modernusa.com • www.dragonproductsltd.com • 800-231-8198 ��i•. U.S. owned and operated for over 50 years. C Cop}nart 2014 Modtin Clop Inc.AllngM;'ese/xt Production Tanks API 12F N a .01 L. M4RIA.T COe•CTns N' c sr cutieYT DO.tftsiw � Quse TYf C-) in noun 1 ril ED C-e CW[CtID1 R ® I Y \ I ElE\_Mang/ COfYCLrilDlt _741 t I i ~MI la .aTQet) \,/ r ' I \,j I �1rrL Ova-ILOY MER_.W1i A CD0at Ube CCTo ( ) C�WtCIDO r=_ https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?tab=wm 1 0/ 14/201 5 Fwd: Storage Tank - breelukens /i umail .com - Gmail Page 2 of 2 47 DRAGON Production Tanks API 12F * _ -liar'i;.` � e t ,•f Via' .,1 , �i� -- ,ffrima r DESIGN t PRESSURE APPRWAPPROXIMATE OUTSIDE NOMINAL 02 PER SQ IN WONG DUNE TERCAPACITY PRESS. VACUUM CAPACITY BBL F T IN.laa t:2 7.11 10 ... i100 18 112 79 94 8 150 18 112 129 04 12 200 18 112 186 12-0 10 210 18 112 200 10-0 15 250 18 112 224 11-0 15 T 300 16 112 266 12-0 15 400 16 112 366 12-0 20 500 IS 112 486 12-0 25 500 8 112 470 164 16 750 8 112 746 154 24 SPECIFICATIONS: ADD-ONS AVAILABLE: • Built to API 12F specifications monogrammed • API Manways • Threaded Fittings and non-monogrammed • Stairs and Walkways • 3/16 or 1/4 inch steel plate construction • Gravel bands • Dike walks • Steel shot blasting prior to direct to metal , Decelerators • Cable Level Gauges industrial coating paint • Fill lines • Thief Hatches • Internal lining available • Knuckle Boom Truck Delivery gibsL 1 -%11;)44 1] V You Tube .........•Ina •S)is 4 r sales@modernusa.com • www.dragonproductsltd.com • 800-231-8198 � - U.S. owned and operated for over 50 years. c __. . .-- 2(44 Modern(, c., .. .__ Production Tanks API 12F .... � CO.[C�OI N' I DE O.(AW. con � Mi. C-f Q ip/t I rCE1 CI InlQis CM awn It 1 I -\.— - "7- - CD I.K \ Iit } Sr l14 O.O.. \e / 1 I r �✓ ��-wL evakeaewL�rra11 OWIF-rUN (h ...e`�rts https://mail .gooule.com/mail/u/0/:'tab=wm 10/ 14/2015 II Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 :00 am Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided that the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household � ( Jr ( ) under 18 c�.1 . \J.\ kt tr TULVNL r V; � 4 �_ ( over 18 / 27// f Er 2. 7 ( ) under 18 i . oci:1/4.1 3hitilic, Atretki45 t'V� 1 -�. Abrit _ ( Ll- over 18 7/22 /.S.r ( ) under 18 • L \NIt1c,l(hil ` u 1 bid_ _ ( ) over 18 CI-- - I 4. 04a ; ( ) under 18 A �/ *et•. 37 pfere-ea ( .4-over 18 Y4054-- 5.5v) 'T'"' �7 ( ) under 18 a Y AA �)' ;�`` �'V1 L ') 1 ti , I ( ) over 18 / / ( ) under 18 6. �,�h /a aG }-gyp j� Zew...4 /� $ ''►-� 41 /, CgrrA _ backg 4La, 6:40 (>4 Zrt q a /I- //� /44 _ (/ / ( ) 7- 4r m.cam. I._ (t , 1/ 4 k> % i&t `j 5/ L4' cR 1 att En—rover 18 7-9/..5-- ( ) under 18 larecit, l IPA 7/4 ;I X //t ( ) over 18 97.Z7'/.r �!J ( ) under 18 9 <c,t,tejzG� nTG� ✓v �`t`�i ado owe- c- , tidy- ( ) over 18 -0477-7-c -...._ i ( ) under 18 r - 1:lenhi .��-uki S 1 44 � �1� `�1 +�I 1��'�� 1� 1, � �G , L � , �� ` �nL� i;(� �,�Pi�t,l ( er1 l �� / `..J rr ( ) under 18 TaL.� '�i GIJkIr4 '-tAgi L ,11 9 i (,L�Jt ;1 bt,c I . ( r 18 CL-. 7 -LS 198 . ( ( ) under 18jr2trke I � �� ) -�`.7l / _ ^ �1�7�I `t `s f�/� (Air ( 16ver 18 1 -,9.7 --6 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan, Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 : 00 am Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility ^' • ) under 18 '' t'44 ( ) over 18 14. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 15. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 16. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 17. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 18. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 19. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 20. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 21 . ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 22. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 23. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 24. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 25. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 26. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 27. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 28. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 29. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 30. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 I NJiDvAgie,_ Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 : 00 dm . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household li 1 . CIll 1 7)is. Le, 1 ) OA* / GD _o 'it) e, lit) equixe ( ) under 18 _. I(h./tied tgaLlarn ( fry-over 18 Dail- V ( ) under 18 il l I • , {J // 1 /) / ` / J r f I `\ ti� 1 _ice i 1, t I 4.i l r . 1. ti\ i/ 4l ,• 1't ;/ �{ �/ ) 1_, l /� 1 a 0 J . ' i I �' `• l f ►► [� [ C• , ► ( ) over 18 I l ( ) under 18 # `1 ci'� l- C 4 �.\\ 1/4 ��. , �` (� _ ` 1� C ' / C s + + �� A nr� 1r 1. �' (3+ k.> .• � • (_`i )7, ( ►,- ) over 18 i _.-_-V -`.a 4. �- - S 3 t1 2 I ( ) under 18 � e. 6,cCr ‘C ` b , .. 1/4= 6 + -Lle 1 G) (A A - ( ( ) over 18 5: IL I �33 C, Z<o% ( ) under 18 - �C r. ,1 �v� L..- .� a_ ' A- LA�km ( n Kai I D- i ') ("�k V`? 6' e I n L. c" . ( f✓-) over 18 IC - I - I ño (\cL l 6. \e_ l \L ; - ( ) under18 r_i_ �a , _ p \ .. v r - 1. \� i-\\- ' • 't. ' 4 "1 ` ( ) over 18 t , " '� --, f \ 7. a-` iG C J L -- 1l_ r a ( ) under 18 �� E� ��,�11 Kti� 1 �-c& a_ r. ru ( . ver18 /t 1 .1c 8 / v•E �_ ` '% _. M/c X ,%S .G,/i/We- n, Ve.-ir; c 'cv- ( ) under 18 -- /�1 ( �r�'-/ - _ c' 4 rG rl�C; f 2 ( over 18 ,(lam 1 4 / 9 _-- -. / -ti ,,, 1r„ ;4,4- . f ( ) under 18 ' _ �" _ LA' ` 3C'6 t�' rtG i`i ,ti -�4 CY '�► (�� over 18 jo/L r'5 10. C ; Li ; >-" cG /swk ( ) under 18 f .eycoels CC, 6., (.. L� �� .'1(Crtn�rjk � 1S c) nc,.1 (0 -` ( ?`) over 18 1 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/14/2015 at 10 :00 a . m . Approval foi Underground Septage Storage Facility 11 . t �L` j i'�-a!e tin .: x '' \44. j., � ( .),A ( ) under 18 I t &iris ' +. G'IZ�`7 _._.„0„ w_. - y t/ t'" ._ ( , 2) \ 1 li'r ' 1' s _ ) ( 0 over 18 1tp- .%' 6 12. 1 \ ckc r ( ) under 18 0-(Ma k r LLLLL0U (All (-:7 33Jc 1 Ll"4- 3.- 1 Prier, . EuSL ( vrover 18 1c , (1l5 � ( ) under 18 13.y e f " CA) N � ) y7C 7C Cr/C/(\ > > NJ� i �G��f� (k ) over 18 /�, `:�-�'� 14. 1'`�E-.t �1 �..2 'kei I- RI ( ) under 18 Cct �r r r brat-ear,' fir; (( )en `(.s ) over 18 r ,r')4- v 15. C' A t M / U)e R ( ) under 18 V r c c . .r �' l O,S nnxJ -k_e-r, C' �(1,•7(A� ' /� ,/ Kl n r fp s //�►� cf 'tOn.\ ( over 18 1 '-f- �*—`r b S 1 St` �fv-,r /1 ( ) under 18 �� V'- 17.16. �1��"-�cec.1c �,�3"-? c - � . Z 4 �a 0 k (O-va 2'�, c:.a-t (v)V� 18/L''r/ (iC //C ( ) under 18 4/) j C r.1 I il` C (- r r r!� /( frEZ L L� &'-: ' /)1 . ( ver 18 /`' yo v� E/14(IT�k / cH/6 —GG -' �� j i► ,y / ( ) under 18 1 :� ,,,G � c:„ , ,c„ I , evdarkff d C2 // fl • L. ( A over 18 it . /6, _/ S- 19. l LI ��- U ?CL/Z ( ) under18". ii/ C 1 '- ei t .s`'L.77 /Z// %5 (, ) over 18 /cA/ 20. � �� '� (pee 3 L a l 1e ( ) under 18 VZ;L�'atx7�),S•41 CLe ice •NCIZ N h d w* C it 1/1. , Cp ireh(0 / 2_ Se ' L R boy traj. CA, ( ) over18 .1 j j 1 �-J 4-t`) ( ) under 18 21 �!f /1 �/ ,I ✓ c�� '' ( ) over 18 ckLi Nyter ci ' F�, 11X-4 Lift {�" ''rJ C C l� C L) .) U2 \ - under 18 22.(/ ill lat /' A,( `r A-� t-s-2.1-‹/S-- ( ) over 18 n 32� 7 11v it / .5 _ ( ) u er18 r � r 23. r - -iteT C!j'?L�I f -- _ k�,/r, �,U E� s; f ) '_ Ko w a� e _ c Too_ i I . con,,,(,,,( tr1 8 / J24. 3- —' , , 18 �. `' � (-_,) v1�1- k= C = E��! ��--,.L c•-, j.1 f 1. 4 de .cc , ( ) over 18 /t L, . ) --- / 25 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 26 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 1 5)17 ,..i- 4.1.,c Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 : 00 a . m . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household An r 4 i'e�c5' ( / ) under 18 /%05._ 1 �f,,l f/• (r ,/ 4 ./ /474/8-€2/ �1//7, CO.'' cer6 Vs A er ii f e zi. ',7 A. c cfr i (2) over 18 2 ( Z ) under 18 ►t IJ5EI1 4 7_ 1�, csce ff,►,,i �e JS_ ≤3 e y c . ( t ) over 18 /p 710,5- ( 1 ) under 18 3. - C (-I- ,� '` _Y `� 2 �" 14\131 v $ C r€ 2 ( �) over 18 J�� • 715- , t � 7 1 �r,c`tz S y___ �' //60 3`; C AL 10 Z ( ) under 18 - 4. f/2 rAt.x, • / , ► Cv v ! c�� < < • ( v-) over 18 er 5. ''r'�. 1, ;, ( eh ? ,s. C (, ) under 18 i � 47,t 6, 1 tate; 6 ( ) over 18 /�� , r, 6.—r2h br/c/ J 6. U I s_. c - 1 2�t !�'-� - ‘ 1 Lt h h C' '4 C'4 4,e4r ( ?e) over 18 l/ -Aix- 7. 'le s ; Xi— lit- /2 / lc (x) under 18 / ''Os. .e.4%;-- - /Aeird- fr" --. A/ •;41a0%.°A./ en tri 6 ( ) over 18 13 3It taut tog ( i ) under 18 Arils 8.e , ;..... 0 611 G JO k.N >v, Colo To of s' ( A ) over 18 g C C i > > 6H �e ,� � � 4 �n'I ( ) under 18 Lat i Alk A a ir\ )1\ ' `� ►b aown /l; b ( Z,) over 18 0 , \� L e rt ue 0d J ( 4 ) under 18 • O,(f► £ Uotr 4Z -te------ it';i it& ect , t'/V ( v over 18 !LF/ - 15 1 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan, Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 :00 am Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility r.,,t, Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided that the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0. 5 miles south of CR 124 and 0. 5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household ^ � - m ( ) under 18 1 .,J4 j�%� l* � � � 5 r .1 / 7ee ' cs e4 46k)4eEisoovitv'k dm ( / ) overl8 /0/7//5 - 2 • 1 I 1� n _ ( under 18 . j I CILI cj j ' iro I f i S 384 -4 Cie <� ( -v r �' �k_ rC, i,1L rC4) '—1 in I ( in ( Q) over 18 S ( ) under 18 3. K e ,v u Ginettes 2?IAA4k3J1LAAO S 7 3 `'C l .. .o/c 21 ( dm' It ( ( ) over 18 /Li 7- ( 5 ( ) under 18 4.26 iLt. G v^. ( > 1,/k. cw�.✓. S- 73g g -O Let ii: 3. ' (est vZ ( i ) over 18 /0 - 7 - / 5- 5 ( � ) under 18 fC- ar VYI.PLIalt- 1 5L 1 C.C E. D( awr 1 , ,_1 `Cc�, ((%' �vokyo..� ��Hilt '��►'' 1 �l � `�' � � �, � � �( 1 ) over 18 lr=) .1- ! S i ( ( ) under 18 6. ��, �‘t: ►` C►� C 5(49441 . C'G� ,1 ! ��: ( i ) over 18 /Cr - 145- 7 r `/' / _ ( ) under 18 o�Pn CiDrnherd / C �• 7 ? l ("ire < 42I ( 'i�fl ( ) over 18 ( O - 7 - _ ( ) under 18 s. ill u 1 C hot �?c ► / 4' (a 5ci k t A ( " i ( ) over 18 �0 - NS-- 1 0•'�,( ) under 18 � ;arY! ' �? - , S j2 `t ` !"tilt Co "[ 6-�Gta1 k Y(!u, l ( ) Zr:t /0_ ']- / r 10r-� ( ) Ala r17c �1/2 Ay ,4l.E,... .42 ( ) over 18 0.-7 - / y ) 7)- 2_,--.- :isles- L�� /� it Iry r 11 ( ) under 18 .s uV Cbne-u_ �� S4 tacit, b,1 eat 21 Cbq- ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 12. :- ‘t n h RC) SSPa- --....AI31 LR 1 I O 4_'-t i- r Cc ( ) over 18 - 7--)5- Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 : 00 am Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility I -) 13. / 0 ( a l w Cr- 10 Cec .-v Y �.� ( ) under 18 L� � � X2,:,5 5 �2� � s s r ( 3 Q k c`, � /a ( --,) over 18 1 Io C 14. �( � ` _ _ j- ( ) under 18 4= 6 'S - 'fi— 7f T i till fi-►C �('.. �1 ' co 1"1 S'�ci2 it( 9M A, Co.r- Ud over 18 15. ,Kit, t 2 ( ) under 18 /� ret fZ 71 7-9 a 9, ,4,c 2/O,zy •'r J (a ) over 18 /6-7-/S- ,16 U &)WifeA1 ( f) under 18 t� diathitialleidet 514,3.E e •2. 1 iA)i �-Aiel ?��, e i n ( / ) over 18 /D - 7-/S 17 7 j I ( ) under 18 j. Cs—, ' tic? .) �7 S' Gv (�C /2V CAR c. %, "1-7/ (. fi C .i K:-f' 5 leD y t h^ - d 1. <- o.-r( ) over 18 It - C19"- 'c 18. ' ( ) under 18 ^__ n w /le's,/ 7 ex) i ti A?t r tb �.��A.-in C//r� - 4-ice / PS- 04- ?? ( ) over 18 /O c- jeT 1 gK- j l� ( ) under 18 1,44, , , I ,- 'ire ;_4 tHert7yc , 'iJoi (E. cHoc- to C it e ( ) over 18 /c.__ 7-i 20 ( ) under 18 f11 \ct. r: ill iitle - 4kt-Lietr-- (2. CO 1)6" (QI( g 1 ( S ( ) overl8 / O • 7 - 7. _ 21 . ( i ) under 18 .. .1 z C, wvAR. c ��.,�.�,,, .ywrst.- x`13 (:,.. h.,� A U �- ( 3 ) over 18 lc - 1- 1 5 - 22. ( i ) under 18 Aevi'le Ili CianTN -1 .1.Attet 9y.3J? Csa-rier Itcrc_ ( 3) over 18 /c 7-1r 18 23. ' (1 tit (._ tL C it LiCic • i)—{,:ertiest. _56,44.Z.10,-- 41 f.,---S / tC-W.- / 7 ) over erl8 /0 L 24. .17 .4A-e- O N h'7� l3, v c k /Tilt (Z ric h ti l of lot 0 t ( H41 gel 17 ( ) o eerr18 25 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 26 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 27. ( ) under 18 ~ ( ) over 18 28 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 29. ( ) under 18 _ ( ) over 18 30. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 :00 a . m . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household 1 . q611 ic'�`6-i6 '‘/CT ANA:'NA:' ( ) under 18 6rAmtek, L ) --- , PC SRO 1Z ( C over 18 EC 2. I c7c 1c' cfNr) 4vc ( ) under 18 et. itasidev 1It i "Viat 'las ' 0 0 MO 2, h Ad14 14 . ho GIP At kt �,1 titre Erb-\( X over 18 / 1/51/2-. 3 l :4 h^� 5 c{ , l x ( ) under 18 ry �� / r •7 e/�'r"Alt a . Zil+=�eill LCD'' rL�.0 t ' ! ‘'city‘ l l ,1 r � U J C c' c:Cf� r , / 6 �'c e' / 2. ( (4 over 18 /C - / 5 45- r :S4% is c• . 4. t k L_\C - { ) under 18 �$,��v�:.� La_ ��.,kv' ,.r- ^ , C �t { ) over 18 5. 6 f CI-Ac.S' C C__ 42 5 ( ) under 18 U ' ��Y/ r _ > , L1 I ( ) over 18 ..___,-- ,> icA__?..._' (r / / r ( ) under 18 -/ /�/L c�C �.: /Qoverla '��/ S /� p r 7. i� l r `'�(� �,� i ' '' �, , •'�/-j?n,� Vii; � � C. � I � �-' ( ) under 18 , ,� .1 , - `� �"` '�'" Y � ) - ) 2 ( ) over 18 1 S l L� 1 �,� �t' tl ( _ k f- 8 `}•�lovc'� C_•:2 Z-( ( ) under 18 4hArcci-t‘‘ I� re ( C ( _ (f ,'Y (.L: �Z (k , over 18 (L' ( 5 (S '� c /` 4- e> CrZI !( ) under 18 h / / g 5�p 6/ Z ()4 ) over 18 10fipS '-b ' O C g- Z-T (L-4-crt1'der 18 . ,7v mU,r fir,,,, L )7) �� C r��: —rr Ch g`d" ef i a ( ) over 18 O Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 :00 a . m . Appro . for Underground Septage Storage Facility 11 . i ,� ` 1`� iJ �' ( . , , •. 1 ` 1 ( ) under 18 .. r t� - (C .-► ./ ( L. z r ( ) over 18 r �__ -- 7 ` f L. , Av c ( ) under 18 12,_ /r/fkL fr'' ) SLY L.Cit) J AN _ `r' t .sL Ine.7, - ., r l__(_ ILL, ; 1 ( ) over 18 13. "� 11 )K,*, ` CI 3,i: -) `,.. L r2.,. 1 Zy ( ) under 18 71)%A. lr-\-e.% % `• ,1, O tt-t. i. al. no :- ( -over 18 9 / c _3 co"' t.- 4,/ 1- 14/ eg / /V '7 <� • �� f� ( ) under 18 r- y) 4€ . r /4? l 6--a..5�, 4' ( ) over 18 15 r J 2g "rr y/71 ( ) under 18 - 1 1 - �i7i . s X71/4: /1( lL- i, ' f 72,, t' - t! ,/. , ; ,' ' ( < ) ever 18 16. r -� - r / '_ 3 -j Ct '"'c` R /,'c; ( ) under 18 // J , / � / hit) * IitC;i L4�� / tiaeill f 3L [4'44, tr , 4� 4 .Yei v.7 ( el-over 18 / C - 14- -i5' 17. ( 2 ) 5 c' (,,.> c fz. 12{,,- ( ) under 18 -) iJ h , C r U,• C} • k '�(.l.(.t f/ ; � r r' C C S t, 1 2. ( ) over 18 18. . i '51 8` i C f .. I az L, ( ) under 18 chit) ruciuz f1 , ` It 4_)---y - c - e- Cu 8&L1 ( v ) over 18 /0 IC) ($ 19.k i z- 6� C C ''C� C J� r� / ( ) under 18 ^YnC tin K£v.cc: -4 A ' -� o,: ( d o 56 G..) /2 ( • '-aver 18 20art ;�_ -- ( ) under 18 �' + it ' plot . I_ r! i ' r ' (-f ,� 1.c) % . ( mover 18 21 . 1 tit% 0 �' E . C •C lt/ ( ) under 18 011.E _ v ik let—, �� f •„.r C k nh nt t 0 ( reA,L Lr � Ltc� r Cu _ ou, i ( ) over 18 • c y sce ( ) under 18 22. X 51,,, L . y jc� � �, • , r, :, •,-- rb-;-% je,? _w C ir/. / 1 C' _, c:_, c.c i ( -over c �r-, 18 A /r 23. abliZI / C.! i t fiL 7 ' " { ) under 18 11li �. ' ', `, `s l� � ,,,,,,( 1".4t ' over 18 2 1 C e � + t. ( ) nder18 S) /15(4, 5.7 L k--� et Mb R (Z. l 5 tt frl C cu or Co ,S-0‘,( ? l ac ' loci 6 L A' ki ye. .i,( el• over 18 + ' �' /,7�. (( `X / /C) ,PP 1 c , ., under 18 25(� /i-�i%C"t /L Ili/ / r� "Of� i 14. k--16wej ' ' c '`- %`:�f�1' ( ) over 18 26. / r' I ` vii 1,\) li 7 ' ; ! ' 94 ( ) under 18 ////// over 18 J Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 :00 a . m . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use , or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. • Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household ‘347 (4& $ , ( .) ) under 18 1 edsm €416:J {-n^� e' i , lam ( a ) over 18 141 '1115 �CX�� {�c..l�61✓ �GvLv) 1�,�,C.�r�� t�e� �'`'� GD �3� T �'w ' `' /ire G. W41) 4 ( Z) under 18 2. DPing ( w o c 3 { 1, '-aq, .. �l ? . en , ( over 18 ld _,7 _ (s.bl t.J Q �ti re j c4 r 3 l�t✓' 1f�;Tc • ILoL/ loin-Mir // / � � / ( � ) under18 c.ch 6 tojr�Sor- Co `fo5st0 �► ( % 7,0 e�-ti TM„1/ Cep ( L) over 18 /O -/7/5— if 35 3`I' il•ec ( 2) under 18 4. A � 1-� c t5PeALC-{ et, LltAt, , Lo to3y ai ens o cit. 1 col „ A.; 1 . con,, ( L) over 18 to - 1'?- 15 b3S 3q314 Ave ( a ) under 18 5.(24 .1It° es Greeley, CO go(93,/ ua��ee �g��rncti corn (a ) over 18 /O17 /C akeul lei & 3O % - ,.\Qt- be .� ( ) under 18 6 ( Cigyny, f_At, r` Co soL t S+ 4\ c.tea\S b V L� L"' 5 MAN . C04. . ( over 18 00,17-rS 7 _ 117 c Se NrIeSecs t"- ( ) under 18 S a Aten Qe Ceti1��1'l kiklA ika 7°_\-°^tea g6tse- Sri�P cCe�v ei -LA C9 �� •C�+•- l( , )' over 18 !a ? - IS ( ) under 18 8. ( ) over 18 9 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 10. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan, Docket # 2015-9510/14/2015 10 :00 am Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided that the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0. 5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household 1 i . ,Aveekerrird,,,gtagiaet- roc 0 wear- ( it ( I 6)--;0L9 i tail ( ) under 18 q,--- "(rs ��,,// J � r_1-r cl ( ) over 18 2. tkt11 £t i t qr ,frn TWO Thvc4 I 1 ea / 7etJ (9 4.1� C °al ( ) under 18 c' � tii if- Cal,fry / ( ) over 18 n^i lk.E Milt"--��' `t,Q�,'tJw � � ,.- - . ( ) under 18 3. --- J ( p ) over 18 / rl-s- -7 4 ( ) under 18 A![��"trwi �� /�l/e- 71/ki, ,e"— , th- 1 %'D we_ !t / ( i ( K ) over18 9 ai 5. h ( ) under 18 J tJi4 ,I �,n ` c/ #008/9 /��574 C�C l ( ) over 18 i g Vk ' ! ( ) under 18 ( ,) c_ 1 t ts c. e b itL&3rv\ U&Ym ) over 18 y S .- L) kfr4e 1,7. o1 p it.(, 7� f_s v 3-/Ca- ik V) ILl i' / rb 7 ) over 18 9- -cc +l� £ A ' i I ) under 18 8. ' " n11 11 G Jt'\aJot- gint, 1�y tr. . 800 WCR L5 0t;rc ) over 18 1/243- , ' " pp" II � eike-At _ r` •1-1c y ( ) under 18 9 l�,' 9.44k4, VlcytVL-- ( t-9 . f 3.4:- Ty ("1C 7 ,,xtcv. v7641:t LA: e Z li ta✓. C Gins ( ) over 18 'y/ :.( . is C k f r �i 10. N�C,1 ` G, �' � ( JckJ ( ) under 18 1 � l\ � �� 7 7� � � � '`�'� 1�� ( �( ) over 18 �/p �) `05- 11 . khcrkizslin 5 /51302 C ,.-/- ( ) under 18?tr-O-7_VtaA �S�j� /2 7C� ( ) over 18 `f/ r /� 9 � 1 12. -" ( ) under 18 ?firN4,• ,,L r e 2cc S W. k..t _ 5 ‘' 2c1' (' 4 '�- ( ) over 18 %//2f 7" 1 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan, Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 : 00 am Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility 13. ._5-64) :41C) - ft , /c/Li" ; N �y er.,�� : ( ) under 18 /.c. v1 `�-� �� , C cop,. a 3 g Jo 17 A. J-i3O.-*s -9- Tin. ;�_ ; b R `_> s Li 7 - c n i a I \ ( ) over 18 14. `� l -5-99c- �;„ ( ) underl8 �� - 9� 74"`"-- L� i'/1 / ) /t II/1 C �' ��c '�k ' \ \c_�I C�,.. E t l \"\,\: cc_ ‘y\ ( ) Over 18 ITT, ( ) under 18 : L / 7 - ---Qr4.j � -art //�' ))h-lt ( (�l.' 6^,.1 0\' PaJ true Cr nri_ ( ) over 18 / ( ) under 18 16. 47/ S2 900 ( C C C l" 1 ``�� ( ) over 18 1 J - , ( ) under 18 7 l/ ~' l� 4c5/44.. !,i /cmt- et It lk$ cc kt k (%L) over 18 18 / ( ) under 18 tst': t, �t 141Z-0« & / / e .3 <L K. /9 s , (V ii/y r7 / Se, i t►e( t u hit i frL l-E ►"f �-i* .c":6 cc , J. Ptk . �cm (:..Z ) over 18 / ' J ( ) under 18 19. ( ) over 18 20. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 21 . ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 22. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 23 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 24 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 25. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 26. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 27. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 28 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 29. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 30. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10: 00 am -4' 1 Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Yrbtait Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided that the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system . We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table . Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household 1 ? 47 ._.1. ..2 9 C> t - '311t/ -2 / ( ) under 18 r , r .7/1/- i < .r� ��. . , / �� 5 �. �� --� /Vi d .-7 .n. �,; 1s �)L >✓� / c l 7 . C /. / c c over 18 A_ 2r--aese-' giAler �1 ( --tom ), toy, v} r`.-,cr , 4.- � , ,o �4 ` ' I ( ) under 18 1 &n a (" L , y * . vx0v -c . ( £ 3L,- K uci krNsyte cio .p � rl t Ft ' < < CY. ( >a over 18 ( Obits-- , 3. D`:�2"..3 i 1-11944 '64; ( t{ ) under 18 v �� _ - ti r _ 1'] si v-& [ ,'v1 v ) over 18 10/7//h 4. l `nZ� •`t.� !yc-.�[ (4 ) under 18 /C"✓/ c eS err Co O‘1 /�L =%� &/cw , z- /, e -' (4;3r over 18 /L - 7-15 fbG7 e jc /5 under 18 5 OM /(erIL ) c ledyad ! . � , /�—e i' le ( af -r5- � � Mk, �- Cc&6 ? f1�� //' i E��t. �r� over l8 4756 57 Hk ( ) under 18 6. � r W aoe tlu; LiAkt2 a".La_ _ //1► $O(2 l l l over 18 indill CAA �� Ltr� �� F Pc�(tn�c 5 +� v1c�� . �� i ,n ( i j 7. _ • , ,_ !C_ h r - ! - -; ,4 ( ) under 18 i 1tl�_, -r .,, t:..- . r -i- �. �� + . Lk. . l�ii - ', , ( ) over 18 i.' i 4 J 5 8. . , ri o ! Gr,CR / oze (1f,�+ h c , WA f cf L:-r n , 1 " ( ) under 18 file/Carr I i M e �� Hz!' Sj--tvc ` ` arr , co 'o !P /2-- Lf • eau G ) over 18 y 9 < 'I under 18 1 C' ri. i o • • C ) over 18 ' 10. ruin, /• r , ( ) under 18 ( ri ) over 18 11 . 1 c ( ) under 18 . ` A _~ J;`Z...� 'l Lc) over 18 12 i ( ) under 18 . . i (-)O over 18 1 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 : 00 am A Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility 13. ( ) under 18 • L.l y" } ( ) over 18 14. ( ) under 18 _ :' � ( ) over 18 , 15. rx i f. ( ) under 18 r " - .* ( ) over 18 16. F Zy .. i j.r` c' le t D. 'est L,/ #c;tilt n f'Ye45 �'�`� ! IG , / " ( ) under 18 I tit / �. ,f `f _ �� f� �(•{ � c ,��L l.� C� r!'> (x ) over 18 �`� f.� 17. - " IC LJ , . V //�' ( ) under 18 over 18 18. f ) under 18 ( ) over 18 19 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 20 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 21 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 22 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 23 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 24 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 25 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 26 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 27 ( ) under 18 — _ — ( ) over 18 28 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 29. - ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 30. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 1 CA' Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 : 00 a . m . PP` Al Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household . Y -: :` L. C'- y Arc ( ) under 18 -t 1 / I (x 'i i /.S c« ` fr,X.il� ' g;- `-- Es c r ? k -� 1r' ( ) over 18 / - A c; t c _ c93;1 W C IL P` z 3 ( 3 ) under 18 2. - ( ) over 18 .-' 3. r $34-2)2, 1 Vve V`Z 'Z r C'C t'1 t ( ) under 18 lC/ 12- 1L�c y (��1.i (off '� ti l� C , ("Li- Cc ��`�- 2 bec.Lit-�-txy t Y. 1> O=�Alrtit (2.) over 18 /1 4. - 1 - 6 (I3 Lu t Z ?j ( J ) under 18 19/ l )6 4-t c t .y! C -t , , �,.� c.- I i k a `Z 7 3 et i v4 ( over 18 / 5. / • ; e d `f 53 Gv e3 ( j) under 18 �AC - ( •._ 1 LUi ijL 2t Cl.I . Cdoui4' Ca cc),D �e,4L\ €;)jerylue, . e, ( _�-). over 18 /1245 >t/ 5 v.� L 42 ( ) under 18 c �. ,,. 1 a - ` c' ( ) over 18 .� II 6. I , f A v, 0 f 01 -71 .�-L.-\1/4.) , ) 1�k..�� \- f ' �. (i,f r.-' 1 lc.�, i1. k3' / _ cJ' „ . ►Y, 7. ;f� � �, ' S c 7� "�- L r 23 �� G, C �_ / .4... .... i ( ) under 18 i Si -s`T /` `?' ( ) over 18 47 — „! e _ _ s-- -L)4c1, I L � -• � ) ( ) under18 �. V CA C,: �l r f, ) L. .4 . f : . -h..� a 1r k �1 (4,„ c,.�� 1 > coy , ,A ( ) over 1 / L (lz is ( ) under 18 9 7 ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 10. ( ) over 18 If USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 is passed by Weld County Commissioners Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Intention to Inject Domestic Waste Water (Septage) Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business) Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens of the safety of such practice. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our shallow water table. We have soil which has a high percolation rate with low filtration. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. We are opposed to the injection of domestic waste water (septage) because our water already is high in nitrates, and there is a high potential of run off affecting streams and other properties. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date ll Household �, 7Gi nth ll -t� ( under 18 SrCcce ZE k u�� r •� ,, �v� ' it SAN r & cirri "a /O) 71g- 1 ' � c � L . _t,, , ( ) over 18 2. r. c r, 17 '57 � / q •S .._j /,vn ,c at M� Co . 3"D6IL U/cn CA z-6109/q/160. ( ) under 18 f8 4 �IA J - er 18 ��''' 3. i loPio/ G.Q L.5 " 3 P-"sr .,Ich, 0 el-_C (1' - 9 � Quit �j ( ) der 18 (� l /47197214LaxciaCtenguepote /t �Q,b . kre.�, L1�9,�/ (4) over 18 M l41&r i CJ U `ca !'J II__ LL ✓ ( ) under18 J D-4. (. hiv b yBe- lzdaciniri) ot.d-/003.40,(4 ( trover 18 /743 G •5. ,> l / l •29 paden e,,,,, ( ) under 18 /� tcJv. � , b bins ,-%,. , �l'� r ll0Jie yd//^// ////// (prover 18 i 1 clialtetdel AtAs'1 isella!'0.Qi �� y 4-7----, ( ) under 18 J! �� 1 a , �, , l Z ( ver 18 ! ! 7'' ').7 6, 44e dofr" _11:::re- - (2- . ..-te Cc rr 4 tdr eo 4/2_ ids i a a ge. azAtine i any ( c.--yover 18 /rt./5- 9'31a a, c ( ) under 18 8.� / 34-/ / Fajen. Ave_ ( ) under 18 • rty ^^�� ] �,� �r G'a d �7 z v �� t r"' ( �-over 18 s � g31 9 - � 10- z-�� rC.G14 ( ) under 18 �a Z Qy - rnM0ti•4: r'ka �elS -tiSc��..�cata- ( (`� 16 '1 J t�?ti1 t c C MM. ) C $ tN �c l 0.-over 1 B _ 4.5 C cnv- 10. ,� c ttli R Inner dv ,, csea.- ( ) under 18 __ ( rover 18 l O-`I - k r If USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 is passed by Weld County Commissioners Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Intention to Inject Domestic Waste Water (Septage) 11sne53-seetisod 9444, )7., pda, ?PM McGuire Ave ( ) under 18 r� Co ≤I ,din. . nsoh,r►1Ce me/. 9<) over 18 /0/0/745- 12. A €,O altocti\Ocit/ctiJl 3� , OcCuit-C*isr& tt_ . ( ) under18 (I)Adt Lc . LLC ( over18 101`ZI1S 13.2.1 ( ) under 18 ,� iJALJ Ocx,c* . Qo r a-- Np over 18 14.I n/) c ` _ ) under 18 1/Y((I�`Cl� ?/j� au Ca(" l (X) r over 18 /O/4/, ile ( ) under18 !/"lcirk Jku ytfl 67 ,�A t: ..c_ Cekrr :::c.) C )4 ( '} over 18 /� 9 /,f�— r yam J� n A) ( ) under 18 16. in _ �14S426.5 r Co &0 b l c9 S K iiO e1Vr1c 0 -.7144.4O. C ( over 18 104/ 17. 5 �Q�1Sdr ) under 18 �'`� rfait C� Q 8'0,2- 18. over 18whites_ N4ui.-iA SLi .-re- Co_ n(�G�i�Pc ) under18 201.012. ( ) over 18 19.�� `734S C� �lwa t CA,,,v�= �FEt�.1 E LriJYn ( ) under 18 i ji�Jn5pA1 e`-t- &% -r � Ov(v 12- t'C-� �ll`l (�) over 18 mills- 20. R 351 C 5Tin,1� C'.+al, ( ) under 18 ,�( I . C 80 Co e_ Q - fl-. ( Ni,) over 18 `,,ii I 21 . ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 22. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 23. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 24. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 25. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 26. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 If USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 is passed by Weld County Commissioners Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Intention to Inject Domestic Waste Water (Septage) Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business) Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens of the safety of such practice. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our shallow water table. We have soil which has a high percolation rate with low filtration. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. We are opposed to the injection of domestic waste water (septage) because our water already is high in nitrates, and there is a high potential of run off affecting streams and other properties. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household Jd ° loft ANC, ( a ) under 18 1 . JI-Its in at t wi ce e %vw1 090--LP/! 6nrc C,ti, W gbils3Lf rum\ elf&Jevwt@ rail i nim ( a ) over 18 t z4 7Jl 2 / 3a . j410-49 /c / (,$,Lunder 18 .1 r S 444.4.., &fttem. over 18 76-17 - 3 � � //Ash / / / / ( v ) under 18 �ob . (,J (nJ5 e--- Co o %o5.5-0 3akeSegh ell 1,14. { 1, co' ( L ) over 18 /0-11" /5- 4. ��,,� L�cL V 3 5 3°l" h.,c ( Z4 under 18 et &rettet , Co So LA 3'4 Q t MSOGt. 1. @jn- oci 1 . con. ( L) over 18 5. Itn id Lee �Rr ( ) under 18 Grp/e CO 3%3Y u fee /SOl�9 ( a over 18 /� .12-4P r { ?�' sc �er� Ot ,4 rt ( ) under 18 ¶ oJcux\ R&uioiv I \ �Sb ` 1 S' 7 v e ice r4, 4 en a g ryk,ik ed,�,� (/rover 18 l p�� ?-�a� ' in SG S*. bit-J... t ( ) under 18 7. 016W-A Q M4-tip , L'.43cvY., CO Sd0 61, Ca AU & 4 G l7 (O 23 a MM, , t cam,. { P - " er 18 !O-i ? du - 8. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 9 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 10. ( ) over 18 Tisa Juanicorena From: Jennifer Fuller Sent: Monday, October 19, 2015 9:03 AM To: CTB Subject: FW: Docket#2015 -95, Kevin and Cynthia Sullivan For the file. From: Robin Hays [mailto : robinh@brain-spine.com ] Sent: Monday, October 19, 2015 9 :00 AM To: Mike Freeman <mfreeman@co.weld .co . us>; Julie Cozad <jcozad@co .weld .co . us>; Barbara Kirkmeyer < bkirkmeyer@co.weld .co . us>; Sean Conway <sconway@co .weld .co. us>; Steve Moreno <smoreno@co .weld .co .us>; Jennifer Fuller <jfuller@co .weld .co . us> Subject: FW: Docket#2015-95, Kevin and Cynthia Sullivan From: Robin Hays Sent: Monday, October 19, 2015 8:57 AM To: 'Shannon Guerrero' Subject: Docket#2015-95, Kevin and Cynthia Sullivan By allowing buried tanks for the purpose of holding septage you are putting human and livestock lives at risk. We have lived in Can for 25 years and there have been several attempts to damage or destroy water and land in our area because we are small in numbers. We may only be a community of a few hundred people but our drinking water should be as important to you as drinking water is for your own homes and community. We ask that you would please veto this proposed use of the ground, if this proposal is to be approved our number one concern is for our health and our livestock's health due to contaminated water, along with air quality concerns, re-sale of the property that has been our home and a portion of our livilhood for the past 25 years. There is a reason people want to live in the country — being 20-30 minutes from jobs and "shopping" isn't for everyone, but those few that enjoy and appreciate and have a love for the land should not be targeted for this or any other type of destruction of the land, water and quality of life. If there are truly no dangers of seepage then my suggestion would be to move this field of tanks closer to Ault and you can enjoy all the benefits of these proposed tanks. EXHIBIT Thank you, • I J Brad and Robin Hays I S te, * **CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE* * * The documents accompanying this telecopy transmission contain confidential information belonging to the sender that is legally privileged. This information is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any disclosure, copying, distribution, or action taken in reliance on the contents of these documents is strictly prohibited. If you have received this telecopy in error, please notify the sender immediately to arrange for return of these documents. i Tisa Juanicorena From: Chris Gathman Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2015 1:41 PM To: Tisa Juanicorena; Karla Ford Cc: Wayne Howard; Lauren Light Subject: FW: FW: USR 15-0035 Attachments: Signature Med Small.jpg; img - 151020120834.pdf Chris Gathman Planner III Weld County Department of Planning Services 1555 N. 17th Avenue, Greeley CO. 80631 Ph: (970)353-6100 ext. 3537 Fax: (970)304-6498 Confidentiality Notice: This electronic transmission and any attached documents or other writings are intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify sender by return e-mail and destroy the communication. Any disclosure, copying, distribution or the taking of any action concerning the contents of this communication or any attachments by anyone other than the named recipient is strictly prohibited. Original Message From: Sullivan Septic [mailto:sullseptic@aol.com] Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2015 1:20 PM To: Chris Gathman Subject: Re: FW: USR 15-0035 Hi Chris I have made changes to the following pages attached. I highlighted in "yellow" the changes made. I am also attaching my response in the Greeley Tribune, per previous articles written about this issue. I felt the article was a good way to explain to you the misinformation that Carr residents have been relaying through the paper and letters, and our response for the right to farm . I am going to forward some pictures in regards to our property and dry land farms around our farm, in a separate email. Also I will be forwarding pictures of the City of Fort Collins Bio-solid Facility that is approximately 2 - 2 1/2 miles from Carr on CR 124. Please confirm you have received the emails. Thank you Cindy EXHIBIT 1 K On 10/20/2015 12:08 PM, Chris Gathman wrote: 1 a . ?CI up wltll the t1Ne ( 0 Alt THE T` RUNE: NATE A.MILLER,section editor R (91C11392-4L45 aneill,Pelt►eKtt*tinrforn PERMIT REQUEST Misconceptions abound regardthg pennits I am Cindy the only. This is a common farm owner Sullivan,u the prop- resident, in the same injection and permitting. practice in Weld on Pe ng• • erty south of the small, �'y' article in The Greeley The response from the land farming for fertilizer Tribune that the sign for official in charge stated unincorporated town of in "the right-to-farm the hearing was posted on this is a very common Carr. We have been in the county"I a back road people "rarely paper lately, due to the p P y practice in Weld and wastewater storage tanks would like (i� travel" and they almost approximately 180-200 and injection. to state Sullivan missed the hearing. permits are issued each I am writing in re- the area GUEST I want to thank Mary year for the same purpose spouse to the articles and around COLUMNIST for this statement because of wastewater injecting on numerous to this is our exact point: dry-land farms for fertil- the numerous I letters sent to Ca is Where our farm is located izer. This brings me back dress the misinformation and mostly anches.made We filed of rfor isolate is a d area.. The emote d to t the Welc. 35-3.5-102 that has been given from the permit for the tempo- sign statute. Sec. 35-3.5-102 some of the residents in was placed exactly where CR S states, along with Carr. I would like to clar- w yare storage wastewaters te o post county 1 sip required truck traffic on gravel ify we are permitting for injection on our dry-land is a half-mile sign, mlthe ana g ifcu rural op, "that temporary storage tanks farm. There is a re la- oour f_ an agricultural operation and injecting of wastewa- tion in place from Weld 1 mile from Carr. This d shall not private e found nuisance be a ter, which is like fertilizer County that we have to public or meth- and is also regulated be 500 feet from any rarely traveled road is when employing through Weld County residents or well. Accord- bringing ameourd we will be ods of practices that are Environmental Health. ing to the Weld County �� °n' commonly or reasonably This is not hazardous Planning not through the town of associated with an agri- waste, like some of the we are3g O feet, which, Can. a cultural production." residents in Carr would if you do the math, is six article in in Greeley Ili- some clarificatievious I hope this on on any like everyone to believe. times what we have to We own 240 acres and legally be. with the the reporter County spoke misinformed residents. y we are only permitting It also was stated by Weld Environmental 160 acres for the injection Mary K Fenwich, a Carr regards to the wastewater CINDY SULLIVAN, Can-land- r owner and farm owner Environmental Health Comments: tanks must he buried to meet definition of a vault. Secondary containment and alarm shall be addressed. Odor shall be addressed. A dust abatement plan was not included. more detail shall be included in description of request so people understand exactly what is being re uested. q A high water alarm will be a red flag level indicator on each tank. Dust abatement will he a water trailer when needed, for dust control . Odor control will he taken care of by tanks being sealed and charcoal vents installed to control odor. Tanker will he unloaded into storage tanks with leak proof cam-lock fittings (OPW) on hoses. We are requesting a permit to install temporary storage tanks for domestic septage waste water on our farm, thr farming purposes. Upon submittal of a complete application — the application fee of $2,500.00 shall be submitted. SITE SPECIFIC DEVELOPMENT PLAN AND USE BY SPECIAL REVIEW (USR) APPLICATION FOR PLANNING DEPARTMENT USE RECEIPT # /AMOUNT # DATE RECEIVED: APPLICATION RECEIVED BY /$ CASE # ASSIGNED: PLANNER ASSIGNED: Parcel Number f J C , _ 3 3 _ y _ 0 Q _ I-\ 0 Z (12 digit number - found on Tax I D. information, obtainable at the Weld County Assessor's Office, or www.co weld co us) Legal Description S\ I Z PC �h SE t / c f tl Z b� 33, Township North, Ran r , Secti n 11ge(p�'West &- 1/H Zone District:_a_, Total Acreage: ` �Q , Flood Plain: Pill Geological Hazard: N JA Airport Overlay District: FEE OWNER(S) OF THE PROPERTY Name: V Y ' C, Van Work Phone # Home Phone # 3�3 W-cl Address:pLl F,o Email C� � Address: City/State/Zip Code p� Name: Work Phone # Home Phone # Address: Email Address: City/State/Zip Code — Name: Work Phone # Home Phone # Address: Email Address: City/State/Zip Code • APPLICANT OR AUTHORIZED AGENT (See Below: Authorization must accompany applications signed by Authorized Agent) 9 ) Name: Li 1 (L \k ,k. n Work Phon Home Phone # Address: U G� - Email a V Address: City/State/Zip Code ED US : • CaM-4Cdel Lal (AS 12_, Me; O-Cr In YeC1 I (We) hereby depose and state under penalties of perjury that all statements, proposals, and/or plans with or contained within the application are true and correct to the best of my (our)knowledge. Signatures of tall fee owners of property must sign this application. If an Authorized Agent signs, a letter of authorization fee owners must be included with the application. If a corporation is the fee owner, notarized eviidence m st be l nuded i icating, t th , natory has to legal authority to sign for the corpor tibn. i ure: Owner or Authorized Agent Da a Zawre. Owner or Authorized Agent Date Tisa Juanicorena From: Chris Gathman Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2015 1:46 PM To: Tisa Juanicorena; Karla Ford Cc: Wayne Howard; Lauren Light Subject: FW: Our property outside of Carr Attachments: IMG_0398.JPG; Attached Message Part; IMG_0399.JPG; Attached Message Part; IMG_ 0400.JPG; Attached Message Part; IMG_0401.JPG; Attached Message Part; IMG_ 0402.JPG; Attached Message Part Chris Gathman Planner Ill Weld County Department of Planning Services 1555 N . 17th Avenue, Greeley CO. 80631 Ph: (970)353-6100 ext. 3537 Fax: (970)304-6498 Confidentiality Notice: This electronic transmission and any attached documents or other writings are intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify sender by return e-mail and destroy the communication. Any disclosure, copying, distribution or the taking of any action concerning the contents of this communication or any attachments by anyone other than the named recipient is strictly prohibited. Original Message From : Sullivan Septic [mailto:sullseptic@aol.com] Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2015 1:22 PM To: Chris Gathman Subject: Fwd : Our property outside of Carr Hi Chris Attached is the pictures of our property outside of Carr. Thank you Cindy Forwarded Message Subject: Our property outside of Carr Date: Sun, 18 Oct 2015 13:57: 18 -0600 From: Cynthia Sullivan <sullseptic@aol.com> <mailto :sullseptic@aol.com> To: Cynthia Sullivan <sullseptic@aol.com> <mailto:sullseptic@aol.com> 1 ,f • - .Ill 1 -.� .• •i 11 r'1 k �AMA: � 'T Ph • 9 y f�: JIB �(,1 1 --. 1 .. * I I - • r '1 r - it. 4• '.}j/rYY//r (a itt Qi, ./. • w ...X.j r..on , -r' • r,Ir '•rte 'a. r•,y _ - lr,,,'1 . . -�', �h.�.•I ll!. lr+.r47r1 ir��7/4 4rf1 1 .,' I lr i. ✓ r�:I ` - - " 15 �'- .� � 'r`� ., ,.. ,_1: .1 �. � ii(I .� Jt- �. -`''YY�rr''• /�� SI ! tt` �t• T,so'`,"2 _ �.l ,�_ 411�.:f)('11.f `1 - - .r , Y .� J- n n.13 r I^ •4� . • . _ 11 .,,a1,• 0 ``1r ` ..• i% •• ,• `1.'114l • ' .. N9' . 6-1 "I' : I, 1CY-_,,II ' _4raf' ijf. . � :.""1,'---41-41! "1;"i.4 !!-. • I _ a -•re-I_;-}•p'- .)ft, '1.. •• ,M C• I I5: r11 ,}.I, . rf iii /. • /` 11.. /"11 ..•. r . .9' _ R _ • P� i' r Imo' .J' , _ter r . • It "C� f" -• rllr' y r I.N.• .- oilt_14-,.,-...-_ _ I . , 1 ,^'1 1 r - — i1 - ?r. . 1• � s .. Ps �--f • ! y mil• •r.. �. • r r� ._ : "V-r ,a 1,r'�,♦y • r • S "11_I 1 I'+`- • '4 �yy��,,ti' �.7'I Jam, - t" • 1. � rl�.r�. - • -1 r 1 ' y ♦4 r } ♦Y04.13 '7 � . t 13: ',__ '4N tom!-•-_•-• a'''. t 't', 1 r •1 ' 1 _ 'r.: 1• I =�-/. r - - 1 • '. — — 4,.-rk*1/4k'I — ra♦ 1 r! ` r et•n• .. • /'4• 1I • .:— . ~ _� • _ . I .'1 r y + J, n-•,- "• 1(Z{'1 t. . - r� - J��41 a - • ♦, "h.r 1 Ir I --"" Ii. I r • • �- - • • 1 f 1 "11 . • •• 1 - . K x:11 r . • r1 a -1. -r • - le. s i‘.").• • 0-.., Yr • . 113. 1. II 1r1 { r !. ' li .`♦; II•li'd• r I `'r ff fir{` •1r• a Ala I' , }. i /I 1,' .1 Ir •., 11 1� • rI� /1♦� 1 ' 1 ' V ,' , Zit •... _ • ' • • • 11 � r � .t 1 1� �. .r - '. .JV' • ♦ 1 Il a .•"' , I ' f S ♦ �f 1i . +(• . • -, ��'i' rte• 1 ♦yam IN T) 1. IL)",.�. 4`^• . y . .r I r 1 l y`�. ..-r I I. .n ..yr. 4 if . '.. +.ft a M 0 t 'tt„ f. - ;.t st II'1 -114 JO 4,, NV r li 416 • ,. ( , 4. ' di 1 sr i 1 \S. , . L t . -NI + • r•1 I '•G' ^C� , _• gr e, 4k•' -! ♦s 1 1 !'r 1 4W 1 , .1 .1 ,. .�1 :1 a • I ISite sit 4-t a ilril 0 ',, t•'•. .�� IA Ir r. 1 .Pik ::1%4 4l, II' 1 •d1. r• r y♦ L r • ` t • ' rC f • • • : L • • • + . i' r • PPA • • �..� • - _ - z - •_- a. GN ipg 17.7 I. .- } Y - k f e, ., • 1 , a - 3- _..._ -2p - • e • j �. ' 11�s ;-^. • �• l X11) , �• SI • -. t ` r -1 'f,- •R. .Y - -. / =- + - 4-.1.21111; ISf is are -id's R 1 ' : ' : i ' Pr _ +. i •� h it . . .4-- I. fa ry +� __ilir_ll Imo, JC _ .r , '� +� ' �Ly ` rc _ Irs i• .-'�i •. _ f j . f•• -`• ♦ 1 • .,Cif ^. +. ' r P 1.� i :t • _ •r. 1' n..� � a 4 i , itii .,. .1s 71 1 'f -r f_ r II �/}�. y � . �• , { � • Yom' rat . . , r sig—,, _ . —4 2 e.r * `WA AT -et it . •••• t Gra.' - '. 4 A --. oft i '-'ir"V er " . et; Ai- - 11 „ } • i - -. • O- %.t • 14 l _ p . - I i j -• _l a •�•" r •IF 1 R 3 t .. ` «r 4„.. . r `� jar . ;�„ 5 yi �. ii ter * a'4 it j +r. r . • , `r w .., 1 sR < _ tau. • ..y • '� - -et At 1 • r J • i ,.;- i 7. .- • it, . till- . . , i. dr Ale:: 4AL, 01h. s t pr " �* s * " t • i ' — ii + çà • * sap c� � • }. • , • • + a , * R . •t . .biz.. ` • Atc . `r eie s let I , � , ,' r '.y"' j r H at y f !144“4 1 '� ..•stir • Q F J • • 11 • f a ••T •� { JAY : f' A. ^ r _it se t t T- '4 ••4.It II a`+ i s ./^ \. 11 II ' .. •�. � + e' L r ,[ ty• $ r • • iA` :.'' . • I L 1 taw- 111;1.- • if r 1 4r lam,- yy. - rt. t I. - . _ =s t 8 t _ . yS �I- CrY � _ lbw R Tisa Juanicorena From: Chris Gathman Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2015 1:46 PM To: Karla Ford; Tisa Juanicorena Cc: Lauren Light; Wayne Howard Subject: FW: City of ft Collins Attachments: IMG_0277.JPG; Attached Message Part; IMG_0279.JPG; Attached Message Part; IMG_ 0278.JPG; Attached Message Part Chris Gathman Planner III Weld County Department of Planning Services 1555 N. 17th Avenue, Greeley CO. 80631 Ph: (970)353-6100 ext. 3537 Fax: (970)304-6498 Confidentiality Notice: This electronic transmission and any attached documents or other writings are intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify sender by return e-mail and destroy the communication. Any disclosure, copying, distribution or the taking of any action concerning the contents of this communication or any attachments by anyone other than the named recipient is strictly prohibited . Original Message From : Sullivan Septic [mailto:sullseptic@aol.com] Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2015 1:23 PM To: Chris Gathman Subject: Fwd : City of ft Collins Hi Chris Attached is the pictures of the City of Fort Collins Bio-Solids Facility located approximately 2 - 2 1/2 miles west of Carr on CR 124. Thank you Cindy Forwarded Message Subject: City of ft Collins Date: Tue, 20 Oct 2015 13 :20: 15 -0600 From: Cynthia Sullivan <sullseptic@aol.com> <mailto:sullseptic@aol.com> To: Cynthia Sullivan <sullseptic@aol.com> <mailto:sullseptic@aol .com> 1 �b - z . .•• •5 .I X. •a .OP - ` P c • ,, , , sa Pr: ._ • _ _ . i: -maydrf, • + 1 ly _ t - 1 lir itiast • r Ivor • • OW x :.." �, •y CITE OF FORT COLLINS r_? BIOSOLLOS FACILITY 2 . 2 MILES . . _ . f1 vow 1 ' t ;''': , � �•" Lam, i; e�� ._ . � -• - •• •• r" - L:. .”-'--" - . ! so.,/,14. Att.!, ' IIIIEMMMMIIIIIIIMMMIIIMMII ..,.. -. • irk-t:,.e..-.4131..--. .`" . 1 cictfY.• , -.5. . is- t, I 0 4 1. • - - • _ • • , la, • • • r • • • . • 6 V i la • t. • r I1 .. : t C le • fr. .' xi : J., ;Flay>. le 't r ... /Pi - riii r �,�r r _ - .. , .a: ) P if777' • f 1. • • r 51 i r pa F. Y C ry aOft aI • w mT UF OR1 coffiNS i ...: itsoLios FACILITY . _ . _ , . .... IPP a iiira T r MILES't` 2. 2 '-ice .,-• r _ � � . . y. ., , . ,. . Aittio . iiiillalliallinallite Fr: 5 ; 'i ? , - ��:-- car" :sE I. - r w -vs ali rah4 -. - •-•• i z � _ ' A \ I. ti f .r i ""` Y aii .41 4 r is El ' ' ..4' t. 0 ^ - 4 fr-4 - • , '_ - _ .J *�, M 1fr tf- ,•�ir'1 •-c , I : -j - 'i ate '1' 11::: 1� 1 /r ! , • ler �,I AS � �, I :r L• r / Ad+ .ate • y.so • . , • Oa • -4 i. i• fif iI:P Ir"• +irti .. 4_, r -. - t ,.'r •L 1 . F ,Y r' 'a fIf �1 TiI1 k$:t1 M TE:j .w•'' - Tisa Juanicorena From: Chris Gathman Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2015 1:47 PM To: Tisa Juanicorena; Karla Ford Cc: Lauren Light; Wayne Howard Subject: FW: Tank Attachments: IMG_0393.JPG; Attached Message Part Chris Gathman Planner III Weld County Department of Planning Services 1555 N. 17th Avenue, Greeley CO. 80631 Ph: (970)353-6100 ext. 3537 Fax: (970)304-6498 Confidentiality Notice: This electronic transmission and any attached documents or other writings are intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify sender by return e-mail and destroy the communication. Any disclosure, copying, distribution or the taking of any action concerning the contents of this communication or any attachments by anyone other than the named recipient is strictly prohibited. Original Message From: Sullivan Septic [mailto:sullseptic@aol.com] Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2015 1:25 PM To: Chris Gathman Subject: Fwd : Tank Hi Chris Attached is the picture of the storage tank, which does not have a lid attached at this point because we stopped anymore work on the tanks until we received the permit. Thank you Cindy Forwarded Message Subject: Tank Date: Tue, 20 Oct 2015 13 :21:53 -0600 From: Cynthia Sullivan <sullseptic@aol.com> <mailto :sullseptic@aol.com> To: Cynthia Sullivan <sullseptic@aol.com> <mailto:sullseptic@aol.com> 1 r . it . nii-9 _ _ ;,,y 11 • . • t r t t - _ .. . . s 4 II 1 1 IIIL: .Viik V - Illfrilla ... ifs is: "tPli ."- , i _ Arta fsi4 +� `OVAL mil i . _ -11. S. - is ;•A+ i ----a 1.41. .44: 4 ir le il et*40. ip lli II 1 • - flit 141-11- fillii-e .' • - allh 1. Ilk '11.. it *kalillEaC7II 1. . le s. •_ , . rIctdik oast • AI sits AI 4 •-•ip •4001/4 41.el4Z641 a ICA t Arak, .8., % vs, -40-11( , 4 Adb ape., ,......, 1 al de a SS ID . VIOL ji‘y dill•• • ell?,r i R . i silTom' • . • .• • a IL lit _ .` ` r`s �ft Tisa Juanicorena From: Jennifer Fuller Sent: Monday. October 19, 2015 2:50 PM To: CTB Subject: FW: Docket#2015 -95, Kevin and Cynthia Sullivan From: Shannon Guerrero [mailto :sguerrero9521@gmail .com ] Sent: Monday, October 19, 2015 2 :46 PM To: Mike Freeman <mfreeman@co.weld .co. us>; Julie Cozad <jcozad@co .weld .co . us>; Barbara Kirkmeyer < bkirkmeyer@co .weld .co . us>; Sean Conway <sconway@co .weld .co. us>; Steve Moreno <smoreno@co .weld .co. us>; Jennifer Fuller <jfuller@co .weld .co. us> Subject: Docket#2015-95, Kevin and Cynthia Sullivan Dear Commissioners, I would like to respectfully request that you strongly consider denying the request to put raw sewage and buried tanks on pastureland in Carr. My family moved to Carr 25 years ago, and still live right across the road from the property this sewage is to be stored on. We have always taken some of our livelihood from the land through livestock, and we all still eat the meat produced there. With the addition of these sewage containers and raw sewage on the land I am very concerned about the air quality and water quality. Carr sits on a large water table, so it seems this has the potential to affect more than the residents of Car. I understand the owners of this land where the sewage is proposed to be stored don't live anywhere nearby. Before you make your decision about allowing the sewage to be stored there, I would challenge you to consider that if there are no environmental impacts to be made with this, why would the owners not put it near their own home or business? The people of Carr matter too. They have built and maintained their properties the same as anyone else and they deserve to have their air and water quality protected just as the owners of this land are doing for themselves. I know the small population of Carr may lead some to believe that the impact will not be as great as it would be elsewhere, but the people of Carr have stopped many organizations from doing destructive things to the land over the years and they will continue to fight this. The people of Carr respect the land they live on and love. This plan undermines the hard work they have done to protect and preserve what they have. If this sewage needs to be stored somewhere, I urge the commissioners to find suitable storage that does not negatively impact a group of people who will not benefit from it. Respectfully, EXHIBIT Shannon Guerrero vt-c70C. 1Cc '0 1 Chris Gathman Planner III Weld County Department of Planning Services 1555 N . 17th Avenue, Greeley CO. 80631 Ph: (970)353-6100 ext. 3537 Fax: (970)304-6498 Confidentiality Notice: This electronic transmission and any attached documents or other writings are intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify sender by return e-mail and destroy the communication. Any disclosure, copying, distribution or the taking of any action concerning the contents of this communication or any attachments by anyone other than the named recipient is strictly prohibited. Original Message From : Tom Parko Jr. Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2015 7:05 AM To: Chris Gathman Subject: FW: USR 15-0035 Tom Parko, M .A. EXHIBIT Director of Planning Services 171 Weld County Dept. of Planning Services 1555 N. 17th Avenue AirGreeley, CO. 80631 Office: 970-353-6100, ext 3572 Mobile: 970-302-5333 Confidentiality Notice: This electronic transmission and any attached documents or other writings are intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify sender by return e-mail and destroy the communication. Any disclosure, copying, distribution or the taking of any action concerning the contents of this communication or any attachments by anyone other than the named recipient is strictly prohibited. Original Message From : Philip Lukens [mailto:philiplukens@gmail .com] Sent: Monday, October 19, 2015 11 :08 PM To: Barbara Kirkmeyer; Bree Lukens; Julie Cozad; Mike Freeman; Philip Lukens; Sean Conway; Steve Moreno Cc: Esther Gesick; Tom Parko Jr. Subject: USR 15-0035 Please attach my letter in opposition to USR 15-0035 to the official record. I look forward to meeting with you folks and discussing the contents of my letter. 2 Preserve North Weld County Agriculture Philip D Lukens Lukens Farms 9378 County Road 124, Carr CO 80612 October 10. 2015 Running Head : Preserve North Weld County Agriculture Lukens, Philip Lukens Farms — 9378 County Road 124, Carr, CO 80612 October 10, 2015 Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Abstract 2 Body 3 Personal Biography 3 My Farm Operations 3 My Farm Biology 3 L.G . Everist 4 The Floods & Weld County's Response 5 Toadflax 5 USR 15-0035 5 Tanks 6 Spreading Sludge Weld County Code 14-6-120 7 This Cost of This Proposal to Me 8 The Septic Tank & Leech Field Difference 8 Wolf in Sheep Clothing 8 Compromise 9 Conclusion 10 References. 11 Abstract In this paper I will explain the reasons why the proposal under USR 15-0035 is detrimental to my farming operation and property. Under USR 15-0035, the Sullivan's have proposed to bury three steel tanks in the ground and store septage inside of them . Once they have full tanks and the climate is right, they propose to spread the toxic waste on their property which is adjacent to mine. Albeit the Weld County Attorney stated the issue is only the tanks, the proposal includes both the storage and application and I will discuss both. This proposal will create problems in my farming operation in several ways. My soil will be destroyed and unusable to grow feed. My livestock will be exposed to several pathogens, diseases, viruses, medication and nitrates. This will pollute my milk and will devastate the operation cash flow. Further livestock mortality will be inevitable. Between the two, I will not be able to produce in this location any longer and will be forced to sell. Selling will be devastation due to diminished property values as a result of the toxic waste being dumped on the property adjacent. 2 Running Head : Preserve North Weld County Agriculture Lukens, Philip Lukens Farms — 9378 County Road 124, Carr, CO 80612 October 10, 2015 Keywords: Septage . Sewage . Water. Pollution , Bio-Hazard . Erosion , Flooding . Aquifer, Farming . Dairy . Agriculture . Dumping Body Personal Biography I am a third generation Colorado farmer and I have been farming several years . I was born and raised in northeastern Colorado . I have a wife and four young girls . We work very hard to make a living . Everything we have has been earned through hard work. I 'm not an imposter. I 'm a farmer down to the roots . My Farm Operations I raise and hatch several hundred birds every year. This includes , chickens . geese, ducks . turkeys . and peacocks People purchase our birds all over Colorado, Wyoming and Nebraska . Eggs are comprised mostly of water. Water and proper nutrition are essential in successfully hatching poultry . This is especially because of the dry climate and high elevation . We also raise goats for both meat and milk. Water is an essential component in the goat's milk. Further we rely on the vegetation which our goats graze in order to get a premium for milk . Our unique terrain is wonderful goat feed . and young goats grow very well on the land. This makes the goat enterprise profitable . The grazing land and water we get are essential for our farm to produce. Further we enjoy raising a lot of our own foods in our garden which we preserve for ongoing use . Again our soil and water are essential for the food success. My Farm Biology Carr can be in somewhat of a hostile clime . It averages 15 inches annual precipitation' . The snow never comes down straight as it is on a ridge which is constantly influenced by wind . The Weld County Soil Conservation District is very active in the area . Due to the windy extremes . most farm ground has been placed into the C . R . P. " program through the U . S . D .A. This program was designed to specifically reduce soil erosion like the dust bowl and recharge water sources. Carr's unique location does entail extreme thunderstorms in the summertime . This often results in flash flooding . The soil is mostly sandy which does not hold water very well . The 3 Running Head : Preserve North Weld County Agriculture Lukens, Philip Lukens Farms — 9378 County Road 124, Carr, CO 80612 October 10, 2015 terrain is very hilly with rock formations throughout. The ground has volatility after slight disturbance of wind or precipitation . This contributes to significant erosion from irresponsible caretaker practices . The water on our farm is in four forms : precipitation . domestic well , surface flow and the aquifer. When it rains we get water. Water collects in watering holes throughout our pastures for livestock to drink from . These watering holes are fed by dry stream beds from our property and other properties. The water flows from our property into other tributaries providing water to the communities of Nunn and Pierce. Our well is in the Aquifer. Our farm supports. antelope , deer, rabbits ground squirrels . reptiles, badgers . fox . coyotes . mice and more . These animals don 't simply stay on our property , but travel throughout the region . Most of the grass is native grasses with some brome grasses which have been introduced through the C . R . P . program . The soil is high in nitrates naturally and is very sensitive when contrasted with soils 30 miles away Worms play a significant role in the eco system throughout our property . L.G. Everist L. G . Everist is the land owner to the east of our farm . They mined this property for approximately 20 years. About two years ago they transitioned the property to become a huge crude oil terminal . I was told this expansion was worth $ 1 . 5 billion . L . G . Everist approached us to sell three acres of our land which contained a railroad spur they were using . We could not initially negotiate until they threatened adverse possession . We sought legal advice with a very small budget and were advised we simply could not afford to fight them . We agreed to give the land to L. G . Everist in exchange for $ 10. 000 . In order for the transaction to occur we had to have our property surveyed . and refinanced . We ended up being required by Weld County to put in a new septic system which has cost us almost $20 . 000 . This was a nice slap in the face from our county who has $ 100 million in reserves due to the oil industry. Every truck in northern Colorado. western Nebraska . and southeastern Wyoming is bringing crude to this terminal and this is big money for the county. What a nice donation we gave the county . Not to mention the 24/7 truck traffic we now put up with in quiet Carr, CO. It only gets better that the trucks park all night long shining their headlights directly out our house. It is brutal to try and sleep. The constant traffic is difficult for the livestock and is really stressful if they get out. It worse when a road is closed temporarily and they drive down County Road 21 right through our farm . That has been our gift to the county and all the people profiting from us. 4 Running Head : Preserve North Weld County Agriculture Lukens, Philip Lukens Farms — 9378 County Road 124, Carr, CO 80612 October 10, 2015 The Floods & Weld County's Response In 2014 we saw a road grader about once or twice a year. Typically the driver was found in the area playing on his cell phone or taking a nap . A severe thunderstorm came through dropping a couple of inches of rain in a few minutes . The hills (which the sullivans own ) created rivers , which came rushing right at our home . Our basement was filled water. We spent a day pumping it dry and mucking it out. Yes I know first hand what the ground does in the area and how it erodes . I made small berms around our house. The second day it hit us again and we flooded again . This time I made huge berms around the house out to the unmaintained ditch . Once again it flooded and washed out the county road . That's the amount of water which can wash from the Sullivan 's to our house. The scariest part of this was the priceless belongings and the horror our kids went through as we put them in the basement to prepare for a tornado and they nearly drowned . We lost so much from this . In looking at the aftermath . it was clear the county had not maintained a ditch along the property or cleaned the culverts which would have diverted the water from our home . The county denied there were culverts . Weld County denied any responsibility . We hired an attorney. We spent thousands of dollars only to learn all the attorneys are conflicted and could not represent us because they all belong to a pool which represents Weld County. Talk about corruption . One attorney who gladly took our money discovered this was all covered under the Colorado Governmental Immunity Act and we could not seek restitution . The public works director offered to make it right by installing a culvert if we paid for it. Our church gave us a culvert. Weld County came to install it and dug up our old culverts which they denied existed . Nothing was said . I find it so upsetting to control the rage inside . The negligence of your county almost killed my kids . Yet you boast of your reserves and responsibility . Quit lying to yourselves . You are pathetic. Toadflax Every year I get my notice to take care of the toadflax. Weld County has people specifically hired to monitor this noxious weed . yet it is perfectly acceptable for me to allow toxic waste beside my property because that's fertilizer. Where will it be safe for my kids to play? What kind of management puts a weed over human safety? USR 15 -0035 5 Running Head : Preserve North Weld County Agriculture Lukens, Philip Lukens Farms — 9378 County Road 124, Carr, CO 80612 October 10, 2015 I can 't believe , an application states tank storage and wastewater injection . yet your county attorney would not allow us to comment on the disbursement at the Planning Commission meeting . This application should not have even gone forward for several reasons . ' Stormwater impacts to this sight are insignificant" . ' Need I say more? Noxious weeds are to be controlled . There is dalmation toadflax and he has never sprayed or mitigated . Historical flow patterns are to be maintained . All liquid and solid wastes are to be stored in a manner to protect groundwater contamination . The County won 't allow me to have a metal septic tank because of the acids . They say it will cause it to leak , but they will approve three 20 . 000 gallon metal tanks to leak That's 60 times the size of my tank. but I have to follow a different set of rules? Tanks and Vaults are required to have manufacture stamping with specifics allowing such use ' section 30-9- 10 of the Weld County Code . This applies in this case too as these are described as vaults . The same set of rules . With this in mind . though the engineer performed the vacuum test. the manufacturer did not design this tank for septage storage and therefore it can 't be used according to Weld County Code . It's use is likely to contaminate groundwater storage. Colorado C . R . S . 30-20- 100 . 5 ' requires adequate disposal and treatment of waste water. This septage has to be treated and then disposed of. It can 't be stored in unapproved tanks or tanks which were not designed for this application . Let alone the dirt cover on top of the tank and so forth . The requirement further requires adherence to state and federal law. Hurley Waste Collection was fined S50 . 000 for violating federal code title 33 U . S . C . §§ 1319 (c)(2)(A) , 1345(e)" This was from improper septage disposal . Do we want this black eye in Weld County? Of the 207 homes in the Carr zip code . 197 signed a petition requesting this application be denied . How is that for hearing from your people? Tanks The applicant has described the tanks as used tanks which are about 10 years old . How he was able to get an engineer to sign a used metal tank which is not designed for septage could be buried , with inlets in the ground is incompressible . The engineer findings are clearly suspect. A tank of this magnitude will have more than 10 p. s . i . The E . P . A. recognizes several risks associated with the burying of tanks This is why they require secondary containment. These tanks at a minimum have to be unearthed to make appropriate changes for compliance with secondary containment ." These tanks were buried prior to approval . They are not approved septage vaults as they are not in compliance with manufacturer regulations . These specific tanks were designed 6 Running Head : Preserve North Weld County Agriculture Lukens, Philip Lukens Farms — 9378 County Road 124, Carr, CO 80612 October 10, 2015 to be upright above the surface. x They have openings which are exposed inside the ground for discharge . At a minimum these tanks are being used in an application contrary to their manufacture design and they will discharge into the ground . This is contrary to the Weld County ordinance . With this knowledge . Weld County will be held accountable at the federal and state level for discharge . The applicant admitted in the Planning Commission meeting , "all tanks leak" . He was less than honest when he stated the tanks were partially buried . Evidence has been shown proving the tanks are completely buried . He also was not forthcoming with the amount of septage being hauled to the site on an ongoing basis On a side note I do find it funny. there are so many regulations around the port a potty on the site in the applicationx, but nothing about the hygiene as it relates to filling and utilizing the tanks . Isn 't it the same stuff? What a complete sign of ignorance. Spreading Sludge Weld County Code 14-6- 120xi The spreading of sludge is alarming for the following reasons : • High nitrates — this will burn up the vegetation . Kevin clearly has no idea how much he can even apply to an acre . He has no experience injecting this in the Carr area soil which is significantly different than southern Weld County. • Smell - I simply do not want to smell human crap everyday . • Fertilizer - Septage is not the same as fertilizer. If it was the Weld County Ordinance would not have special regulations pertaining to its use to stay in compliance with health regulations . • Septage — Weld County Code 14-6- 120( E) requires it not to be allowed to cause pooling , overloading a field with nutrients and so forth . If Kevin knew what he was doing , he would not be attempting to apply this to ground on nothing but hillside . It will pool and will be a nuisance . • Subsection (H) food crops can 't be harvested for 14 months after application . This is if it is above the surface . • Subsection ( I ) food crops below the surface can 't be harvested for 38 months after application . • Subsection (K) animals shall not be grazed on the ground for 30 days after the application _ — What happens to the run off if it rains within 30 days and ends up in my fields? My animals have to be taken off from the pasture? This is a severe adverse effect. Septage is not clean . The blood . and all other bodily fluids are still inside . In fact, the parasites, bacteria . viruses . pathogens, medications and disease are all still inside. It is extremely toxic and dangerous. x" 7 Running Head : Preserve North Weld County Agriculture Lukens, Philip Lukens Farms — 9378 County Road 124, Carr, CO 80612 October 10, 2015 This Cost of This Proposal to Me Its so sad to live in a County where I constantly find myself fighting for my land . don 't understand why everyone around me is allowed to influence my property on a continual basis to my detriment. We have spent countless hours organizing meetings and interviewing people . and researching concerns . Hours have been spent informing others about the issue and gaining their support. We researched the absolute best geologist in the State of Colorado who specifically has worked within the Carr region . Terrance Birdsall is the author of maps and formations recognized by the state of Colorado He has helped by researching the area and can accurately prove our water will be affected . Specifically my well will be ruined in a matter of time . This entire process has cost me thousands of dollars and hours upon hours of my time. Not to mention the cost it will have on me should my water be ruined . I will lose my farm . I have already taken so many hard blows for the benefit of the masses in the county. I 'm asking you to consider the price I have paid The Septic Tank & Leech Field Difference One of the points brought up at the planning commission was the fact that residents have their own septic systems . This is absolutely true , but this needs to be brought into perspective . On average most septic tanks need to be pumped every 5 years . ' With 200 homes in the Carr zip code which spans 23 miles by 5 miles roughly. there are 115 square miles or 73 . 600 acres for natural breakdowns and bacteria to dissolve septage. If the average household has a 1 . 500 gallon tank . this would be 300. 000 gallons of build up over 5 years which would need to be pumped This is 60 . 000 gallons of build up per year or approximately 1 23 gallons of septage per acre to be distributed . Sullivan 's application proposes bringing 2 . 000 gallons of pumped septage per day to the site . This totals 730. 000 gallons of septage in one year. This is applied to 1/4 of a square mile area or 4 . 562 gallons of septage per acre. The ratio alone is so staggering , this is why we don 't want this getting into our water The ground will not be able to keep up with appropriately breaking down the bacteria and everything else . Wolf in Sheep Clothing According to Dun and Bradstreet , Sullivan Septic has annual revenue of approximately 5120. 000 : They do not have a Better Business Bureau rating X This business on the surface 8 Running Head : Preserve North Weld County Agriculture Lukens, Philip Lukens Farms — 9378 County Road 124, Carr, CO 80612 October 10, 2015 does not appear to have the financial ability to take on the risk of contaminating surrounding land without bankruptcy. This is extremely alarming when they have a leak and my farm is affected , they will not have the ability to make the loss right without the likelihood of bankruptcy . This would cause me to go bankrupt as well _ It appears to me, this company wants to be more profitable . It is quite expensive to dump septage at approved facilities _ With a fee of $. 30 per gallon °' with 2000 gallons per day. it would amount to $600 per day. 300 days of pumping would cost about 8180 . 000. If you bought farm land in the middle of nowhere . and dumped that septage in tanks which leak . you may only have to inject once per year . The septage leeches into the ground and only a few people could be affected . It would be hard to trace where it comes from . In the meantime you save $ 180 . 000 a year. This is big money . There is no need to be a farmer here . This looks like a money laundering scheme . Don 't be fooled . Compromise I understand full well . all the facts can be laid before you and you will still vote based on your best interest. Based on my history with Weld County , I and most of the people around have absolutely no faith in you folks making a good decision or keeping our best interest in mind . With a $ 120 . 000 annual salary . I ' m sure it's more important to protect yourself instead of your people . This is evidenced by what you have done for us in the past. After having said this. I really hope you will reject this proposal . However, if you feel it is in the best interest of Weld County. the least I can ask for are some safeguards . These safe guards are as follows: 1 Escrow — Profit loss reimbursement. Its not as simple as just having them pay for hay if I have to bring my animals off from the pasture . I can no longer get the premium for pasture raised milk . Therefore there will be a 30 day loss of milk revenues . This is worth about $300 per day at a minimum . They should be required to have $ 10. 000 in escrow in any event my land is affected and can 't be grazed . 2 . Escrow — Profit loss reimbursement. An additional $60 . 000 should be in escrow for any water contamination to my domestic well or to my pasture watering holes to replace livestock mortality . 3 Weekly Water Test — My water sources are tested weekly at the Sullivan 's expense with no inconvenience to me _ 4 . Weekly Milk Tests — The Sullivan 's will pay for weekly milk tests to monitor bacteria . medications . and heavy metals. 5 . Weekly Soil Tests — The Sullivan 's will pay for weekly soil tests along property boundaries every 100 feet. specifically in the bottoms of the stream beds. 9 Running Head : Preserve North Weld County Agriculture Lukens, Philip Lukens Farms — 9378 County Road 124, Carr, CO 80612 October 10, 2015 6 Liability Insurance — The Sullivan 's must have a $ 10 million insurance policy specifically covering perils related to all business operations associated with septage . This shall be paid annually and proof of payment and insurance will be provided to surrounding landowners 7 . The tanks will be unearthed and a secondary containment system shall be installed . 8 . New approved and specifically manufactured concrete tanks shall be installed . 9 . Leak detection systems shall be placed with triple redundancy . 10 . The septage shall be treated for pathogens prior to being stored in the tanks _ 11 . Secure fencing shall be installed to prevent livestock and wildlife from accessing the property and spreading pathogens to surrounding properties . 12 The injection setback requirements must be 100 feet from the property line . 13 . No disbursement shall be on land with a grade of more than 2% throughout the property . 14 . Detention requirements for the dry creek beds Conclusion Our northern Colorado agricultural community recognizes our risk. The community is highly frustrated with the elected officials as they handle land use applications in the northern part of the county . We have united and are going to fight this to the bitter end to include electing better representatives as need be. Consider what we have accomplished . As time goes on . we only get stronger. Please consider our concerns . Weld County is a Right To Farm County . so start considering your farmers instead of big business . I can 't keep taking it on the chin by this county. Something has to change . God forbid one of my family members ends up getting sick or killed from the carelessness and lack of due dilligence . I expect the best from my elected officials _ Show us your best. The whole county is watching With all due respect please decline this application noting all of the above concerns and the lack of compatibility with surrounding land owners under Weld County Ordinance 23-2- 220(A) (3)' 10 Running Head : Preserve North Weld County Agriculture Lukens, Philip Lukens Farms — 9378 County Road 124, Carr, CO 80612 October 10, 2015 References: ' http://www.worldweatheronline.com/v2/weather-averages.aspx?q=80612 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conservation Reserve Program "' http://tourgrasslands.weebly.com/about-the-grassland.html '" http://www.co.weld.co.us/assets/A6D1a87C3055cC4823CA.pdf "https://www.municode.com/library/co/weld county/codes/charter and county code?nodeld=CH30WECODEPU HEENTEWATRSYRE ARTIXDECROM S30-9-20SETA "' http://www.lexisnexis.com/hottopics/Colorado/ v" http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/USCODE-2011-title33/pdf/USCODE-2011-title33-chap26-subchaplll-sec1319.pdf ""' http://www2.epa.gov/ust/revisinfz-underground-storage-tank-regulations-revisions-existing-requirements-and- new#rule-summary 'x http://dragonproductsltd.com/wp-content/uploads/bsk-pdf-manager/70 PRODUCTION TANKS API 12F.PDF x http://www.co.weld.co.us/assets/A6D1a87C3055cC4823CA.pdf x'https://www.municode.com/library/co/weld county/codes/charter and county code?nodeld=CH14HEAN ART VIDOSE DIV2DOSERE S14-6-110INAPDOSERE x" http://inspectapedia.com/septic/Sewage Contaminants.php x"' http://septic.umn.edu/prod/groups/cfans/@pub/@cfans/@ostp/documents/asset/cfans asset 126408.pdf x'" http://listings.findthecompany.com/I/19794234/Sullivan-Septic-in-Longmont-CO x" http://www.bbb.oradenver/business-reviews/septic-tanks-and-systems-contractors-and-dealers/sullivan- septic-i n-longmont-co-45000268 x"' http://www.garfield-county.com/landfill/fees.aspx x""https://www.municode.com/library/co/weld county/codes/charter and county code?nodeld=CH23ZO ARTIIP RPE DIV1AMZOMA S23-2-20DUDEPLSE 11 FW: Weld County Complaint of Storage Tanks Used to Potentially S... Subject: FW : Weld County Complaint of Storage Tanks Used to Potentially Store Septic Waste From : Lauren Light < Ilight@co .weld . co . us> Date: 10/1/2015 7 :56 AM To : "sullseptic@aol . com " <sullseptic@aol . com > fyi Lauren Light, M.B.S. Program Manager/Environmental Planner, Environmental Health Services Weld County Department of Public Health & Environment 1555 N. 17th Ave. Greeley, CO 80631 Ilightco.weld.co.us 970-304-6415 Ext. 2211 (office) 970-304-6411 (fax) PThink Green - Not every email needs to be printed KM le SKI ► / r • 11 r 1 Confidentiality Notice: This electronic transmission and any attached documents or other writings are intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain information that is privileged, confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify sender by return e-mail and destroy the communication. Any disclosure, copying, distribution or the taking of any action concerning the contents of this communication or any attachments by anyone other than the named recipient is strictly prohibited . From: Kurz - CDPHE, David [mailto:david.kurz@state .co.us] Sent: Wednesday, September 30, 2015 5 :54 PM To: Stasinos - CDPHE, Greg Cc: Kelly Jacques - CDPHE; Edward Smith - CDPHE; Caren Johannes - CDPHE; Rob Beierle - CDPHE; Kathryn Stewart - CDPHE; David Foster - CDPHE; Trevor Jiricek; James Taloumis; Lauren Light; Ben Frissell; Erik Gessert - CDLE; Michelle Howard - CDLE; Kelley, Tim; Nedrow Ann Subject: Re: Weld County Complaint of Storage Tanks Used to Potentially Store Septic Waste WQCD previously received similar contact from another party . I have spoken with Lauren Light from Weld eld County . Septage pumped from individual septic tanks can be land incorporated consistent with local county and federal regulations . There are requirements on how much septage can be applied to land and monitoring required . Sometimes holding tanks can be appropriate before land incorporation . For example , a highway- rated truck may bring the septage but it is placed in a tank rated into the soil using farm equipment rather than a highway EXHIBIT of 3 / \) '� I IC- 6.O3 10/1 /2015 9:28 AM I FW: Weld County Complaint of Storage Tanks Used to Potentially S... vehicle . In this example, the setae may be held for a short period of time until it can be P � septage incorporated into the soil . The issue in the Weld County case is the tanks that will temporarily hold septage ( removed from various septic tanks ) prior to incorporation into the soil are large tanks . It is my understanding the land available for incorporation of the septage is also very large (over 100 acres) . The question is one of scale . Regarding Water Quality Control Division requirements , if the tanks are temporarily holding the septage we would not consider the tanks a domestic wastewater treatment works provided there is no treatment , neutralization , or stabilization being implemented . We are advising the caller we had to work within the local process as the proposal does not appear to violate a WQCD regulation . David . David Kurz , P. E . Lead Wastewater Engineer Engineering Section 4 CDPHE COLORADO CO - t.vatcr Quality Coro rnl T)ivisior • P 303 . 692 . 3552 I F 303 . 782 . 0390 4300 Cherry Creek Drive South , Denver, CO 80246 david . kurz@state . co . us I www. colorado . gov / cdphe / wqcd cep -Lia Olsen 's Agricultural Laboratory, Inc , 210 East 1st / PO Box 370 / McCook, Nebraska 69001 Office: 308-345-3670 / FAX 308-3457880 www olsenlab.corn Septage Wastewater Report AGFINITY INC Account Number 20900 360 3RD ST PO BOX 627 Date Sampled MEAD CO 80542 Date Received 02/26/2014 Date Reported 03%10/2014 Name KEVIN SULLIVAN Sample ID CARR CO Lab Number 22038 Constituent Analyzed Results Moisture Method Solids 99 05 % 105 C 5HR 0.95 % 105 C 5HR PH Dissolved Oxygen s u SM 1500 B SOD 5-day mg/L SM 5210 6/4500 G c-BOD 5-day mg/L SM 5210 8/4500 G COD mg/L SM 5210 B/4500 G Total Solids mg/L SM 5220 B Total Volatile Solids mg/L SM 2540 G Total Suspended Solids mg/L SM 2540 G Total Dissolved Solids mg/L SM 2540 D Volatile Fatty Acids mg/l. SM 2540 C Fecal Coliform mg/L SM 5560 C Total Nitrogen colonies per 100 ml SM 9222 O 327 6 mg/L SM 4500 A Organic-N 257 7 mg/L Ammonium-PJ TN-NH4-NO3 Nitrate-t1 64.2L SM 4500 H Alkalinity (CaCO3) 5 7 mg/L SM 4500 F Aluminum (Al) mg/L SM 2320 B Arsenic (As) mg/kg SM 3120 8 Barium (Ba 3 81 mg/kg EPA 206.2 ) Cadmium (Cd) mg/kg SM 3120 8 Chromium (Cr) 0.03 mg/kg SM 3120 B Cobalt (Co) mg/kg SM 3120 8 Copper (Cu) mg/kg SM 3120 6 Lead (Pb) 3 14 mg/kg SM 3120 8 Mercury (Hg) 5 52 mg/kg SM 3120 8 Molybdenum (Mo) 0 01 mg/kg EPA 245 2 Nickel (Ni) 0.40 mg/kg SM 3120 8 Selenium (Se) 0 56 mg/kg SM 3120 B Silver (Ag) 1 09 mg/kg EPA 270.2 Zinc (Zn) mg/kg SM 3120 B 6 29 mg/kg SM 3120 8 Vanadium (V) mg/kg SM 3120 6 BY. nr - , -- -rar. • • 4- , .♦.. t .LTG'Jr( - P • - V -41,,,r- -.• - . : • s„9 ` V. • .-i ., ., 1> .a - . I . I. A -r: S �'-10'10►' :",..; ' ` _ . a a y.1*f; . ease . F. ! r _ _.. .-. l 4 :, { ' ,. r ,_ Crt� �FFORT COLt1N - . 0 FACILITY 1 „, - ',Ls. ',Ls. *tcw. . -,:, — • ,.3 • i, 2.2 NILES 44 "fi R- J 1 t '. R J y . 441.1- II. SilwinillISIONsipillopospw_ . . :i• Yet ;, . ; -..i- • • 4-4 :, . , _ r.• - - 1. •�= �� - < . :file's. I it: tili - P- d 9 i` t. f �i • ji 1 ' � it - - r ` a �: - ` - i � .. .or 1.'' r - i Q t_ 7" jr -� IA f �a �.- i r,♦ t +• r x. s • _ � f'• +• -= �� - I{ I /- .i ".:R ; �c:• ' Ilk f ~ ,� r - r + ! - a j, i too( 1‘..4.- I:, ,Y� ".I ic At.. .' 4, 2•i l . ,� .` .,` � y`.ldr�:.. �J ' �' ' ` •' _ _ •y ^.rr3' � ! L rr- - ! ep •o— + . �' ` _ ; ♦♦♦ ',A - i • t i n .I -. - ` T , '.r. r �' • � a i. +� .`. I . - r•.►ab� _ f . ,,� _ er i - • z' V '' t t't • at; fl} i�' .. Aril:. ,� _ - ', ,d' ,y '�!t' .,�� t �r .� . ,Pr,� r ,L, r-t a t .-r . - .1— �.,i ti' ''p ' r - . - J _ - r J f _ T'• y � .•I. Kr c. fr ...7L iI e Jic c ay1 .j t a1�� R"f �� <► yr �r� -tom s. �(fi�'^�7�-iir, t T ti y 4,,,, ,., .• .4, , S '• P it ..� ►. 5]}f 4 �^ a:• �`� ' t ai dr ! I ,''F" 44: li f'_F, rt ` .�}, rill. sing I. S J •� _rr. f *- i ' ; r - ... fit. } - . 'I•r . t ill . . - . 4:. tvi t. 7 #, 7 . ,n ” ,t I LEM S up with theII t we think NATE A.MILLER,sect ion « , 3 ..,' :.32 -• .-.3 ,‘ '}ntitn►eeteYttibtxeCbM THE TRIBUNE PERMIT REQUEST Misconceptions abound regarding was wa rpe rml s I , I am Cindy Sullivan, the only. This is a common resident, the same injection The response froming. practice in Weld on dry- article in The y the farm owner athof the the all, land farming for fertilizer Tribune that the sign for official in charge stated erty south small, unincorporated town of in "the right-to-farm the hearing was posted on this is a very common a back road people "rarely practice in Weld and Can. We have been in the county:" travel" and they almost approximately 180-200 paper lately, due to the Also, I permits are issued each wastewater storage tanks would like Cindy missed the hearing. . year for the same purpose and injection. to state Sullivan I want to thank Mary I am writing re- the area GUEST for this statement because of wastewater injecting on in COLUMNIST this is our exact point: dry-land farms for fertil- sponse to the articles and around Where our farm is located izer. This brings me back numerous letters sent to Can is to the Weld right-to-farm the county. I want to ad- mostly made up of farms is a very remote and statute. Sec. 35-3.5-102-toa dress the misinformation and ranches.for the filed�for isolatedl � sign re CR S states, along with that has been given from the permitP° was required truck traffic on gravel some of the residents in rary storage tanks while the county q or Carr. "that I would like to clar- we are doing wastewater to post the sign, which the'hu cultural operation ify we are permitting for injection on our dry-land is a half-mile m or storage tanks farm. There is a regula- entrance of our farm m Carr. and shall public or be found nuisance and urjec�ting of wastewa- tion in place fwreohaWe� ra mile fr�veled road is hen employing meth- ter, which is like fertilizer County the same road we will be ods of practices that are and is also regulated be 500 feet from any commonly or reasonably throour trucks on, Environmental Weld l He County residents t e WeldllCo County bringing o through the town of associated with an Environmental Health. g Carz, cultural production:' agri- This is not hazardous Planning Department, Lastly, in a previous I hope this article gives waste, like some of the we are 3,OOo feet, which, _ residents in Carr would if you do the math, is six article h The spoke e misinformed residents. Y like everyone to believe. times what we have to bune, p We own 240 acres and legally be. with the Weld County a a we are only permitting It also VMS stated by Environmental Health in COY Su1.T , d 160 acres for the injection Mary K Fenwich, a Carr regards to the wastewater owner farm oCarr land ai m SPECIFICATIONS 544 BBL Round Skid Tank1 • Shell: 1/4" PL • Heads: 1 /4" PL. flanged and dished • Base beams: 16" x 45 lb beam with . . (5)16" x 45 lb crossmembers • Pull pipe: 4" SCH 160 pipe each end with caps • Supports: (5) saddles with 3/8" PL reinforcement pad YIP • T • Top hatch: (3) 20" x 20" hatch with locking lid, one each end at ladder, one at tank Ill _ center • ;n i t • Drain/fill: 8" manifold with hammer unions and caps. (4) 4" pipe couplings, elbow turn down to floor inside. 8" valve, 6" manifold with hammer unions and caps. (4) 4" '""" ' �� • �" couplings. 6" valve. 4" bottom suction on ' Al.- - , each end with valve, 6" jet line with (4) 3" • discharges with 1 1 /2" swedge nipples, jet ' MIS line thru each head . • —• with 6" valve on manifold end and 4" valve • a on clean out end. MAX LENGTH' 40'-7" , ♦ resissie. • Manway: 21 " manway clean out on end MAX WIDTH:' 10'-6" • Ladder: One each end outside. one inside MAX HEIGHT' 111-R" at center hatch • Finish: Interior steel grit blasted. coated with 100% solids epoxy chemical resistant lining ( 10 mil dft), exterior steel grit blasted. coated with epoxy primer. top coated with polyurethane color • Hydrotesting: Full capacity static test • Dimensions: Overall; 40'-7" long, 10'-6" x-. REAR , -"_- wide. 11 '-8" high shell; 10'-6" dia. 31 '-8" rI' FRONT head seam to head seam. 500 barrel / 'N capacity 0, r t • . ., ..... . i• i -I; -obi NOTE: TANK IS LOCATED 8"FROM GROUND LEVEL 7-Th. REAR FRONT I ` / rajia .. \ , . : \ .•L......•. 01 S t i •i ' , \ \'i CELL LINE k • Cr -•L • % \ SECTION A-A ��Z a ,-r.. s .r; may,; • :i.:. n --- r r • . . n#roductions ,,, PowerPoint ., Presenters: Slides = Kim Seipp •,.N - '- Natia twr.ulAssocla of W? :..,•,-• Tethrntfan -. • Agenda High Plains Sanitation Svcs. Manual Welcome to t 6 • Cote Publishing • Warren Brown Cell phones Tri County Health - ' Colorado . AWT Restrooms Department Evaluations Installer 1 Overvie . . • Test • alwommiopipir How does NAWT Certification THANKS ! ! ! & Recertification Work ? • Cole Publishing Certification • NAWT • Class Training • Examination • CPOW • Good for 2-years — Installer currently does not have a recertification requirement Recertification • Need 8-hours of OWTS Training • Must be at least 6-months after Cert/Recert Class • Can Recertify up to 6-months after Cert Expires : iminmsammuillir- - Goals Ethics for Septic Professionals Keys for Installing , Doing what is nest for: systems • Customer 1/4. • Environment - • Cannot cover piesa r everything Good Contractor • _ ,„ « t•` -/ ..„.... .... _ Cannot fixrit - - - inspectors `�. „ �' • 'GoodSew P. • SystethEtd - •i ^a•.'.43% r Calculating Tank Capaci y Materials • Tank INSIDE dimensions • Operating depth is measured to the INVERT of the OUTLET ----„a • REMEMBER: 1"= 0.083 Ft, 1 cubic foot = 7.5 gallons , Concrete • Volume = Length X Width X Depth -• . Plastic • 4' x 7' x 60"/12"/ft = 140 cubic ft (ft3) 140 ft3 X 7.5 gallons/ft3 = 1050 gallons Fiberglass 0 0 Metal, A 60" g• r IIIIIIIIIIIIMIMIllliiel Compartments Concrete Thoughts Single Weight / , 1 ¢ - kair• Small Dosing Tanks - • Delivery �"`„ may` • First tanks in series - Placement . ' ` . `T�'*=� 7`' • Two _ Watertightness - 4 4v- • Typical Construction . . , .'` Septic tanks -- - _ • Poured inplace . � � r• - " • Three • Separation from . . . saturated soil - - •r• •- • For dosing from ~ " — t; 7 •�'� 3 Comp i en:Ma y .I . to 14# elivery of the an • . � .. • How? i .• Additional _ 4: t•. c= EA iril- Can determine .w • Fa' Top tam ,: :`ti ' ' ' ; the tank material • _ _ '. -- --- - ••_ w_. se-,; r Choice .. r�. k- ' .01410011 - - --4 f"' ..,''*::'-‘,,t w+r 4-- I. ,etR' a.. I EXHIBIT Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 : 00 am IC Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility 5 -Go3 Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided that the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map i or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 , 000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number In Date Household j� �� ) tl f(" ( ) under 18 Al 'iL pct L U�VNV tik.. ' ;vim1 iit-c. / � ( over 18 / 27 / 's' ( ) under 18 eickel r' 11k 4 lQ. / R Gtir ( mover 18 crb s — ( ) under 18 • K.4A41 ) NJ xi, . ( ) over 18 ot-- - �j a f� ( ) under 18 4. Q44NJj �C� � ( y-over 18 th7/zr ( ) under 18- 1 1 a t °I) M6sr e . cliKcimsr, V\I1 ~ 6 / vLR )c - ( ) over 18 ( ). under 18 6.6,Qh J g at/�P, asi_%_._,4 /e637 c 4 /02rY' b h., k�4c �5 �pQ , (>4 over 18 /2 y/5- 7 ( ) under 18 .-i'k- L ( c, )/ xtty .k i' 3 (2 / Lock_ 1c.e0 ('-"rover 18 -47 /S~ 8.ffairi ' ` ( ) under 18 �/ ji% ,i>f� �� ( ) over 18 9 ( ) under 18 71/4 Cxttve C'cc itrc-t „M , % 47`f35 cretzY i'rvC i caw ( ) over 18 7 -•477-/c II_ too i 1j ( ) under 8 eet �n .G} S .� ui i 3 din Au,' C (�OLt� ! 0D k,61.),“ ( er 18 Ci -O71 9c-ha4 -2 QM Parcle44w opor, ( ver 18 9.-07 '7r ( ) under 18 Pike-QC/64A6CAA A S 9;37C1M deA44611r ( %liver 18 9 .7dC Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 : 00 am Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility ( ) under 18 13.tinV l JD" gri< XQg -Q &CM ( L— over 18 14. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 15. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 16. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18---1 17. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 18. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 19. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 4- 20 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 21 . ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 22 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 23. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 24. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 25. ( ) over 18 26. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 1 ( ) under 18 27. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 28 ( ) over 18 29. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 30. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 : 00 am f-te?'_\ Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Ars FJ • . tee Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided that the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location : 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 . 000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number In Date Household (, ( ; uonvdeerr 181 . C `� �� ,� ,� � S � W see / e 411 64elisi0 ab v k , &4 ( f 18 /0/745 -- �2� 18 I 2AIl C;LI D i /Vs 53-84 Cie at Cyr r e r tJ rQ rna$ /I ccfl ( a Oveef 18 17()/n5- ( ) under 18 3. KRvkttk se 1u v\ Golfs 74l S 73 ca.✓t al ( 4g n. ( i ) over 18 jv _ 7. 1 r C 0 ( ) under 18 4 / /Z,t ( il?t1-v1,5 262C Ai cwt s" 73‘4, take ✓L ( ( ) over 18 /0- 7 - / 5. Hne-sc c&1 'f ( 6( S(ti toot D( r- ,7, 4\a,_1(0 kcybaj.ra'Jot188 k)n- i5- ( ) under 18 6. `kh r ✓1'`- 5t0s1 q "-I lnoA4AK ( a ) over 18 /0 -7-C 7 j II -- I ( ) under 18 LO rPet 010rr1 `jour -- /� ≤ 67V / (Aire( .7 ) (At,. . ( ) over 18 l D - 7 -/ f ! 8. ,na � � Chat/461i) � �� / 1" �. 4 �? o ` 5- (oh4 ( AJCa- A (Cotr( ( ) over 18( ) under 18 lU - 7VS Cpat-,( ) under 18 9 /ROA) ��irtil Y" �! \1 Z Li Cagy alpt6) kr g!'�t l , ( ) over 18 9_7- / Cr 10. ( ) under 18 r .� c) 10tifiratar l ��/ ss les a 'c& i/ car/ter ( ) over 18 /O_7 - /:( 1 ( ) under 18 �cA0arat- __. S4 (etin 1462 21 £v ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 12. 1—Ain im go .35 N::::).....„ tOt3I CR HOc.c& rrCc's ( ) over 18 Jb' 7J . Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10:00 am Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility 13. Dctii;,�,� (/0,, / 0 ( a ( w ca to c c ry 3 Q yk koo, tom. ( ) under 18 /0 7, SS �' SS tS ( -.) over 18 14. ( ) under 18 G( 6 � _ T : Mil ll over 18 � �U `7 I W C � �d 3 rl � IZ�Gt2-ice 9ML�-�L � CONS- liere-/C ��/G /-2- ,4,_..) iindpr 1.8 /� - V6P All°/c Z��i (z ) over 18 `l1-�j/s 1 ( f) under 18 led�i 5 !o e m 2 eh&7'0104044 Nt4 (dofft ( / ) over 18 /0 - 7-!s 1 ( ) under 18 �' t- 1a e. � L`�' 2 �3 '7S� I�IG�2 12 co Lakes€ irit.,, l. C 0re7( ) over18 1b - Or- i≤ r 18 �, ( ) under 18 �.2 �. // `., 7 e.. 6 .4. /'� � - l 6 wet-.3 4.)ce / P 1- Cde ( ) over 18 7o .. a-{e-"- 17 22 � ( ) under 18 u` t r A- : 1,0 ntoit, .Kcpoti 9 / 0c, ( ¢_i C e ( l ? ( ) over 18 /(L- 7-/ ( ) under 18 20.N\iruf,.i o( I. _ I .1\t tLt.tz & '? I °& wC2 Il e ( ) over 18 / 0 -_ 7 _!4_ / under 18 21 . . ( ) �v.y h o k,.,,vkere.t" ). I9 n G coy AU 2 ( 3 ) over 18 ) 0 -. 2- 6 22 v� ( i ) under 18 Arrinef GIuAtte fits,.rK � 4')±Lt o9y309 Gw✓4 / )tic ( 3) over 18 !0 -7-15--- ( ) under 18 21 (.4 t-it (k Lauticic (3.1. otua- 753 i 1t42- 174over 18 /0 (J 24. ,? VC �� 17 ( ) under 18 itali. T W gilop .schey� gel o I ( wiry y R ( ) over 18 25 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 26 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 27. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 28 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 29. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 30. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 : 00 am Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided that the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location : 0. 5 miles south of CR 124 and 0. 5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 , 000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date j� f Household 1 . l" �,itt ` �'L tkC 4 O W4' ( 1{ = s�(. ( ct i l 'cn ( ) under 18 4 ,--)---r-T5 / J GOB- r ( ) over 18 2. ttth "t i' tom- ,, cnta !T/G/L / (Y e c,/, /e / (9 ,4s/, C asi ( ) under 18 q G arGi „ CO / ( ) over 18 M 3. 4(9,6 0 ��/ (5. ( ) under 18 I t �Kk �! i✓ ( ( ) over 18 f-),S -71-- 4 ( ) under 18 / Qro-/V 1 I/e- 717 10 wait 1 ( ? ( K ) over 18 y.- — ts-- 5 ( ) under 18 ci *et r fOS7"J CiL ( t ) over 18 y/V /a ki � ( ) under 18 6. I (1S- Ectr &WD1I\ c , ► V4 6 lac t 3 C/sCs Q _)\ p rYaA 1 ' ' ( ) over 18 under 18 7. 01 kkke't&c4/dI '73&' -c� r A (() ittT- � t-00-) over 18 ?a-on-re 8 ( ) under 18 k I � L/ � 5 oar: ( ) over 18 � � G � 8 �Ic Z, rr 11 eik&Ou4_ ) under 18 9 ‘ �ti ,,� V, V ," �y -LA / SIAQ ?c7(/ ee 7i ea, thiene e,7 ti petJ C pri. � (K ) over 18 atIts2 C\ � Cal ( ( ) under 18 10. Q,�` S c\G d\ 1n4 (ictAuls) 7 3� C vnli 1� �7T _ ( < ) over 18 l e1/15- ( ) under 18 ei 11 . i≥4rkje/) / 6fl4 ' 5 ?5i;cj2lccr ( over 18 7/747 > (12. ) under 18 C -E-bR2�Lr s •a c , l 1� ( ) over 18 2 ) Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan, Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 :00 am Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility 13. 66aani Q ( _ A7 it N. cct.55, +( ) under 18 ,1Th ts _.t_s- C evuL CD e aeo V _ k 1 b cc s s qh 1 m a , \ ( ) over 18 14. y \ - ( ) under 18 _it._ ��e-aa5(--19c; / 4-4- M 49 7 -- J ) :4) / /C Li_l L L a yiCkk `C\C Q3 e.?A 1 \lk•CG ( ) over 18 1 r� , arate-c;, r /� / � � Q ( �VhC� � P� ( � • ( ) under 18 ` h cc over 18 / ( ) under 18 16. (.20 S2yoo ( A ,2 ) Tra. c 3 J4f'-i- ( ) over 18 6 l i Qc lFi 7 `� ( ) under 18 17.6 ` l c`S ( �� 1,� R �f w �O t nt"�1-� 0.r f� ez f y r�6(� co wt (�) over 18 18. ( ) under 18 G{J t,C�v arc (� / �'`3 l4, ,5 C!J �/4 � nf� r ► 7` w/o / ii+e r Q ►til-6)ec . J�nk.ccm (ai ) over 18 ( ) under 18 19. ( ) over 18 20. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 21 . ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 22. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 23. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 24. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 25. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 26 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 27. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 28. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 29. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 30. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 : 00 a . m . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use , or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural ) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0. 5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried ) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system . We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household 1347 ( (31-4 i4ve - ( i ) under 18 1 . \kV\n (,c,( E., / �G�.v-) 9A. sat &re of _ma (,D caa3 Li' Ted vIn et Si wee jWvu, t , lam ( a ) over 18 1411115 /1 zow 4 ( Z ) under 18 2. D l'f•fira D ehPh4 6 •- 4.y Cm f'o c t C. nitl�.+cr Q re ( z.) over 18 ld _/7 ,lst:t C.{ ( ) under 18 3. �� I toSC,�� over 18 �D - / 43S 3`1 ' �c ( 2) under18 4. nchj Lt.( ;43Attet< iec,e,1 � tA) (1)(03 (1 0.+ MsocklFrkC4- ) . c,oM ( .. ) over 18 ! o - tl - 15 635- 3e44 , ( O1 ) under 18 5. IC i Lee / tee /810M3maI [ coon ( ) over 18 /O '(P-/6 1110 5ot-k\et= * c- 2 ( ) under 18 6. �� \,, ,, Co Ltr Oi , 4. `4„6,2` 5 0 "1" C (jma \ - cows- ( over 18 /Oil 7.n- 7 i3? < c c-c-� lc- ( ) under 18 \ a ‘il ‘il e n G etCc V << _t-o ..<_`_0 gbi, tr slue cy,,,0 `-i C LA O YkA k .cow. ( /1/4,2_ over 18 /0 t 1 . 1S- ( �) under 18 $ ( ) over 18 9 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 10. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 : 00 a . m . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use , or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned , are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried ) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system . We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household Ai7SP— 4i047Sc? ( / ) under 18 ic0A4,s 1 . m . iiS r i�S /) (� a // l vi/r'� cc cs U' `�c /`5 J/� �! rJ � C G"��"� ( ) over 18 24 ( Z ) under 18 L ii_ 5CALCE� /7, W ce /' 4JJ W44' tie 4s_. ≤3 6' 1/4-rtec , opt ( t ) over 18 /O 7.706 ( f ) under 18 3. - ; I-�w A C h 2- ( �) over 18 �`� -7-3-- ( ( l- fir, So^ , �� - 57 Z S( j �r,cc( Z // i, 3`j /� 2 ) under 18 /0 . , _/.6- 4. ; ` /< / !� � ( v4) over 18 r r- ` IV - . 1 i `- Ca C t1 () f/ k, (tJ ,1 C�' _G AG�� - c _ Altai- 5O l. ,, � �// 1 ," L ( a ) under 18 c�1706 go- ( ) over 18 /-,1 '- ,7- 41.2q /2poscce / f av`c6:rat) ;--- / 7 / ( ) under 18 Qeason, it ii\ over 18 7• , '16Z VS- �e�Z / 2' 06under 18 l G yLu�,;f 1` ? , /1/ c-�.�-.J err:" �/ e ( ) over 18 r33q( c.lc-it to ( 3 ) under 18 Jo -7 - t s 8. J ra 4 6y to7 Al k.N N, Colo go c,ti ( A ) over 18 / I �, 4 �ce r I /� n'l ( ) under 18 9D--021/2-. A 3 h , j1Jwtu ��kio '5 i L Mavn 04, - Ai,1.4.) t; F0L I i ( 2) over 18 )-, n, \' -) r I$ 1 aIi :'xi Mi ( (,, ) under 18 10. ',R U rite.‘ (--7ea - ./1/in12 ed , l' 5 ( t) over 18 1O'% - /5 i lDk°-r c Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 :00 . m . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility I Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use , or a 1 background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0. 5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned , are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried ) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system . We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household �( /� ( ) under 18 1 . arrl 1 ScLiej ) s4441009 t is C'`_ l Cc "'ar/ e siztiLdfivc1W C @ciL ' ( mover 18 qaDmis- 2. ff ;,/� A11 n n ( ) under 18 ��I f , �44 ii L G�" h/ ) e.dit ≤Qf2cb CKo� 7 t'" a 51dWelIt. C ? I nL , / Oin ( L ) over 18 G� � 3� �1 j(e\ LO1/4 " ( ) under 18 3. 1\OR04- . 2VU, 3An'S Cie 27 (arcG.) LA fin Ofry (63 L l ` ,C A_, 0) ) ( it. ) over 18 -is 5- 1 I \ c_ Q. t 7 ( ) under 18 4. o\ C L.) 2\ b , 06 1 "L LoH ® o\ . LQ½ ( ) over 18 [ a A 0 550 13433 C'�iQto�AQ ( ) under 18 -Art-+: WE 00 -c3 G Q (D �� i �- Wc,�I5 � Y1k.. C',orw !/)" ( over 18 (f) - is 1 " � �^ 7 7 ( ) under 18 6. \___f \, Y. i U - 4%-\\ „- ,.- v " a L-:cki .4 � 44c 1/4 ;-\ ( ) over 18 \ c 1 7 t♦ aS 0 C IPLL t Z) 2 /, ( ) under 18 t<tok?--tteUtAVA �n , Cm sd O& �)a'�'�/ ( c_+-over 18 /0 -1 - e. —� /2wp /1/C7( 44 vis 6--"14/79/e- €ems/nici cm, '1* ( ) under 18 86(.7,9 ��G — XV- __ _r4rY-- ro 96rt ( over 18 074(3 '.-52.Z/5 5A n Al crc 0 ! ( ) under 18 9 50$ 1<r Yfi S 60 i06 .! r\t/5j 2 17, ci ,,., 4 , ( , cb- '-‘' (X over 18 /0,705 10 . i ��,Q,h'1 IUCI�et' �✓ ; 50 �1K� ccG AIR . � ( ) under 18 cc_� 0 Tams C b S U ZG ,o 1Q°Yt\rj Q. S �'n ( ) over 18 in Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/14/2015 at 10 :00 a . m . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility \N, Cle-afetAelz -- Y1 , COW\ ( ) under 18 11 . � �` K� Le m 1IY it " 3 L c_s1 Nat en ( over 18 '� /� airo_ , 1 r er. - ( ) under 18 12. Q_Ctrai 1 ULke( Lositiractir 3310 tat 5i ece a jp5, ( r-"over 18 ( 0 , L. / 5 ��11 �DS L ( ) under 18 13.% e f V, / (ibm, D 972 7 /c 3 3 Pi4v/4g (x ) over 18 10 `y-/5 14. 'x'1 l - \\ cei-f--1'a - ( ) under 18 Pi all tt.O ivy t `QC) ius _ C ctrzr)Co ca � ► r Q j abco Ott `(..j ) over 18 16 � 15 Se we R _ L ( ) under 18 yI S M a� � PS:5� CU,C • � o r1� ( ) over under 18 t 0 � 15. S Q 'CO 110SVSS � rY /C° o��a 4' S3 / stisajni ( ) under 18 j / // � Tr 16. Zifiedz-2-4C6c/c_ C41-1 roar c an 4 / cock 18 15 OC !lO ( ) under 18 17. /2Salt A _. de a C6l ( ✓1ver 18 4 /� 'c 5 �,� �i /tI under 18 1 . cio( 7a7hcer- ge-I6C _ � �� air o got,'/Z €✓darbt# -- C2// I � . (,I ( ✓) over 18 /U+IU +I S Ca co C«r e.i 2 9o,�1L ( ) under 18 ?IF1 44C/dig ``.: sz7/7 �/ fS (A ) over 18 /d /4, AI (P q 3 � et 110 ( ) under18 20. dz-n ELSA/C LCR PA ct, v+1 `Ctlini 1 C Q gaG, / Z SE t' C_A W 13oy PLrya, C'�l� ( ) over 18 C-f�- I / under 18 21 .Lncla NY,,tutallicetQairc ei) o Lli 1 a ( ) over 18 under 18 221• () ' / het a 1.�1�-:-� ( ) over 18 5,Lt/ 7 rvJCR / S ( ) u er 18 23. C., f 8aC212 — Sekte 1 , �- -( over 18 � � � � � under 18 24. Pc f v t GOrckl� C4 to c 3 Cat b \ 2- c•.t �`-ci4-OC_ ,<<0h, ( ) over 18 ICS ,6 .. r ( ) under 18 25. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 26. ( ) over 18 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10: 00 am -4? Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility ytbvtlt Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided that the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location : 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system. We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household 4 / O2291 Co u,^ /a _2 / ( ) under 18 1 ,�/(.�. 7 Ay() n n o & 0 V red-9;4 & % ( V--} over 18 /:),V6 l PULA i4- maY I'e"-" td ( ) under 182. 1 I Oriya £ M -Wer ' 1. iv- �� ( v SDC3 «;O \o��' levsncelorctd0 � y4- • cC} ( ver18 i0b /I3-"-- 3. 90g"`3 RS I-I W k-i SS r ( -' ) under 18 Xrlq&ECteS cayito �?LQ thsV —MEXjvin . co ,T ) over 18 1017 /6 S sz5 '- .5 Nunder 18 4. : 1'164 6e_� çes //7.2,- err- 60 06. Altle-eS.- ��g ,, i� deny ( +j over 18 /�/-' ��/�, bPo 1 under 18 5. OM *6103 `'/a �', e ! li t 1 t, �` '' �/ �' s�l, ' /�'fc-�`' < < 0 ( over 18 te "8'�� io56 5`j 1 W ( ) under 18 6. W ade bacmo ks �UL, CO Bob la to f'� e c c ,ni c} ( 5ri ‘ oc.chn ( over 18 I S_.9or e ( ) under 18 f / �sM L7. ,c . ,-� - i�C �:� �.� `x , 11G ( ) I� \ ( � � ( V) G • ? G ei ( r gip c over 18 1 8. k& qkigrrtc_ k1A hc , " /Ng , ( ) under18 Ar w • u ( . )7(%ywtr over 18 9 '1'ti 1 ( G � � ( 0 Li( �L_' i ) 1 SA) ( L111 ( ) under 18 IN.4.4,\.D l i1Y)1115ki 6/ Crte► Io ( �, f� ,� .. V ) over 18 1u 'f_ I ( ) under 18 10. (`i 111'x. Lescksoit-j L.: 1c V ) over 18 ( ) under 18 11 . C.\c, 1 ( + ., c 5ice ,-,A ) over18 12. ( ) under 18 j C boy\G\ (DI) over 18 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 : 00 am A Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility ) under 18 5 _ 13. (23uyit).-.)� • 11 4 ) c. , a') • Oil/ ( ) over 18 14. C'/?'L ( ) under 18 / ,' //22 d.;, i+t' '1 '� L��' �✓ l i�fC �i / � / J��c' l� �� ,, f• L �-. ,• l/�i� � L: L 77 , c . � over 18 /1•4 7.12, n �r ( ) under 18 15. i t :? �'� ` � � C, ` ( ,, ) over 18 1. rr a ACAke r `� C�,, , Y ` L f, r 16. Rini ,' J ,�,�'��Z1 L�F/-� t� ,1O � Se 1��'1�-C/i -t"YE��j56 .2-64i / 10J ( ) under 18 0 _' � 73 • i' S It c 4.- ✓ r / ( ) under 18 17./� y�c ��< <•� � '� f�� a xiZ `. !/ ( -.hover 18 /7l - ) under 18 18. ( ) over 18 19. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 20. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 21 . ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 22. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 23. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 24. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 25. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 26. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 27 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 28. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 29. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 30 . ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 0 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 :00 a . m . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system . We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in Date Household • 6 7j- 7 6--, C44, '�Cv!•/j_� CA- .S-S c,/ tad • /, ( ) under 18 /41).../ 07, 1 . r 1 ,,,,,2_aut,er 61 j Co,,r, (79 estb /2 441 >1 ( Jr) over180 7, 7 r yka a h�. ( ) under 18 u- r E ,C c tc.�r 46,beftixdf/ �n7 4„, 00 �b/>- ' elrieJ (ihy) f , m (�/S over 18 �.7v ice/ it 3.6 1 • •• , a' I l: • 1 t . 1+ �.,� ,41.-'>• � ueV' no . Coin / r - j �f • N � � ( ) under 18 D•� ?• o� f ' 9 & /14 (c ) over 18 a 4. �C (l �'� 1 % t lt 60 C� r ( ) under18 O1 ( . /5 Q7rV' K J i e/ y (x) over 18 -20/s._ C704 la Jl///Gi� ' / ( ) under 18 0 -. )----) k , di sr )L.� t►�1 I t� 31 1 �� LA-EtL.J/ JCzi< t� L �E� cw d 17 ')( ) over 18 , 6. 3 4 . • ,� cd5 , 'Dri r5 �= ( ) under 18 /( ;- ) l 1(5/66/1 )1'S�1--4 �'l( , ) �v1 C� tU ��ti.c.� � t 1/ 1 0Gr1 1� ` ) over 18 „ j . tkl (Ili/6.2-.71(a 1351194 4\1(Se WG+I eU t ( under 18 L . t 7. C"_. . , ((/ CO 2_ v ( V) over 18 15 �► i1 ,,j�,� rear"der 18 / - 7--- ,� 8. Car) y % ' t9 %" , , .t G Cc r, , a We (, CO $6009 ( ^') over 18 I - giltsSZyL ( ) under 18 •. a• - • a - . t ._ ' �_• . . .• ., - . es. ( Y. over 18 /�-f 73� s.,- ;� ( ) under 18 i `1� _v-v- L c . U t Z_ c l ( 4.0E f'� ( ) over 18 1 ff Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 :00 a . m . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system . We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number In Date Household 1 . v 3-7 50 L:- C' ( ) under 18 O �,�- /tom4cii ? ` �'`_ `7� t_�- `6(n ( ) over 18 / 2__ A v ts 2. C9379 w c R. Z 3 ( 3 ) under 18 CarZ a to et-via r / (.'1 - ( a ) over 18 /O - 12../ 3. �jec� -1-Q (off, 5 3Z"1 V�fC �3 Q,, , corn ( 3 ) under 18 Jpf1t/, sy `lytkCam- r co got, t 2 bey-�-ay lbr 5 e �rn ( ,) over 18 4.--r 4-ty ,l ',u it 3 (3 ) under 18 1ei ) wy ct 0_, f r c> &Aga ` s !�, GI 7 3 (al over 18 / a/15 .---- G ) c3 Z3 ( 3) under 18 10/ TtQ1LJL / eJU0 JLN v`-' P , r (a TeAE3 Q C%� , 6.____ (al over 18 /1245 5 34 elf 3 - 6 2 �� \ ( ) under 18 / C/� 1O,\Skt f 1R o,� tO ( �, o.\- r� LAtLy@ / LYE 4 ) over 18 ,rs' d c ,�' y Co� �� i� 7. Sit /� s @ ci o l- Cam.' ( ) under 18 C '` te Askticcic d 1"� over 18 8. 4 3 -4 CD l c R_ al 3 ( ) under 18 char c` lAt 0 �,� e, �. cJ T ( ) over 18 ti �� Ct.) �.� r C IBS" 9 1 ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 10. ( ) under 18 ( ) over 18 f. Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 : 00 a . m . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use , or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0. 5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned , are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried ) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with e no current secondary containment system . We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. ii Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number in 1 Date Household f i ,, ' ' ( ) under 18 1 . . \ (0 e 1 `��U u 9i�'� 554 �1�v N g „veil �a' ( x) over 18 1 4 j,( r G ( ) under 18 Id� 2. - thu‘que, A 1 ,' I rt _J 1 S -6ns� Au qO Cikst �licr'4 a7c , I • (O, ( /0 over 18 4 / -- /7 ; ( ) under 18 ,c, l�(P5 - l St,f1 �5e✓1 43oc4o 3Qiro,�l i it— Z7 707 rL i/ f,� av ( ) over 18 !i ( ) under 18 (3`--N kilt l I 1 -7AitF . .c..) over 18 /2>667/i * a . ( ) under 18 5. q h L Q_ CO / c) Cr ( ) over 18 3 f " (v ) 630 `,yhj i&D Its— - (s ) under 18 6. 1► ► `t e_ 3,;( I ( r km OiuYr , 6) lz 0 / 00 jetke ,��"? (x ) over 18 / 0 16 Is•-... 7. 6 / 63o ci /e-Li- ( ) under 18 Z(.k71,&vt1(eI" ' 27 _-. Y I` 4-0 ) 6. 17“ r V t rcec o/oS ; ae w ( X) over 18 /O --/6`-,i.S— ..,/-T / -r Y et_ de#._ ( ) under 18 8‘93\--ARN V Z" Y " ' over 18 S'-t� - 1r tnlii � . �.= ��- � �j ,,) :i ' � elf 4 v.�Z I'hGn << ��* `�O � n i S �-�� ( ) under 18 C oil i e 4 D n I S e- , _1 ,� C �N �. C� over 18 , . 9 y ( c 0c -. / j I ( )c, ) r 7 15 under 18 qz5? 5KIA-v4son Apit 6104evrcee>) ‘ ( )ICK- }e 10. 1k 4.. 1 (.�,/ 7( -i ! / F f(r �f�'� over 18 ��/ -, � 1 C ' � z l 'o `y /7_ C� C t t 4 L » 1 Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 : 00 a . m . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility ( cjyS3 cock If'/ 2- ( ) under 18 (a 1 y G ; �^ � f C'��' cc; � ��rc� c� v�� C�t \ , C' d �t�. - ) ��ll� C'`\ \ { \� -J(1.\\ 1 \ L nkt \�C �� 1 �l� �G�1, C OUR- over 18 5 '� ( ) under 18 12. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 13. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 14. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 15. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 16. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 17. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 18. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 19. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 20. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 21 . ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 22• ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 23. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 24. ( ) over 18 ( ) under 18 25. ( ) over 1 $ ( ) under 18 26. ( ) over 18 J Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 :00 a . m . Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Petition summary and A Site Specific Development Plan and Use by Special Review Permit for a Use permitted as a Use by Right, an Accessory Use, or a background Use by Special Review in the Commercial or Industrial Zone Districts (transportation and storage of domestic septage associated with a commercial business), provided the property is not a lot in an approved or recorded subdivision plat or lots parts of a map or plan filed prior to adoption of any regulations controlling subdivisions in the A (Agricultural) Zone District. Location: 0.5 miles south of CR 124 and 0.5 miles east of CR 17. Action petitioned for We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to deny the approval of such a storage facility. The proposed facility will consist of 3 underground (buried) 500 barrel/ 21 ,000 gallon metal skid mounted wastewater storage tanks with no current secondary containment system . We are concerned with the safety and potential health risks if the underground tanks were to start leaking and/or leaching into our water table. Please see the attached map of waste storage tanks in relation to domestic well locations. Printed Name Signature Complete Physical Address Email address Number In Date Household 7(44aq5i 1 s5c /E LTA-ye. ( ) under 18 1 . fe ► we / ��D ( over 18 IC' 15- 14 v 2 '4- n er) '4vc- ( ) under 18 . LI J CI Ct.. / laid l' ti ( 7w/4iL� 0 O St 1 / i Ad/it /Ice �r rw ci' �-' l'�Citz EZar�( over 18 / !,5- /.� � ICS c.vl 6A-5-q- 5— ��✓ '. ( ) under 18 3. e it4t L l Y e14)M1d `9?ZtUt/ 91-ea ilea-- f (� N m e ,G7 6 / z / Z. ( over 18 %G'l i 5 //S- 55015 C_PE3 ( ) under 18 4. ��c.hwvs Lisatt , , (0 1) a ( ) over 18 5 c*71 c c- 2 3 ( ) under 18 6 rU c''-,/1r4900 12, ( ) over 18 ,....-•'°--- i y / c // O ( ) under 18 -/ ex exy ?cleft, over 18 /C`// S7/5--- 4 1 ;� /�4 ( UOI ? ( C- I ` ' ( ) under 18 _ 7. cUtl( AM ( " Libi Al reinr - ( y ) over18 t0Sl� coU molt_ � 5' 8 `, l000 C 2-1I ( ) under 18 4Oi (O %=10 ( Z 9c) over18 (DiScS 9 �j c 7o L 0 C T )- t ( ) under 18 , 41, c.".. rikJ /M y 94.4e. ii C. ex err/ ca., 9over 18 10 S to v C C � (L—}trader 18 wain 7 lW 1 cm-rn, (19 �'`' f Cscvrr a c—d 6 / a ( ) over 18 a Petition to Stop USR 15-0035 , Sullivan , Docket #2015-95 10/ 14/2015 at 10 :00 a . m . Ap for Underground Septage Storage Facility .r �� '1 ) � ✓�.� ,�� ( ) under 18 11 . ) limrti J %.,ecieil CAQi2 (u V007 _4 ( mover 18 9s 71 G rc Avc. ( ) under 18 � ( t-) over 18 1 /nut_ inn SL r y ) Cm-r �r C..0x(01 ' c, VL S 'vV L 12. ) 1t4 ( ) under 18 13. t,\ZNL4.t �b id. o. L ( J.ever 18 r I4e, 41 wL 1 14. // �3 G� 2�Z� ( ) under 8 �2 1 � /1 e?‘ € Cite -C. , n P4/2 ( ) over 18 :� � under 18 ,_1,b/rViegae.. ., /747:v 740 / vis 18 / V- 3 CC- wd- A /1,G ( ) under 18 16.I<'er) nc MDR(i ? / ( 1° (1/ II:44c 6L 51)4/7 ( eleeover 18 /O- /4.-iJ 17 1 1235' d /LO C R_, `J.(c ( } under 18 , L e, 1 &- e 1st et_ r r-, CdV 80 6 i i ( ) over 18 J o h ).3-) Si1 ac IC_ lath ( ) under 18 18. n t e r u-q Q. �1 C r r 1 Co SOO ( v ) over 18 1 a I (o 1� 19. c ,GO& & 1C _ / 9. 3 - ( ) under 18 L �e�c'r�ca-- �u.�'� � ' �I �_ (31-cii LL CO 9o& l Z ( fiver 18 7511 fEE Q (2- 9a_ ( ) under 18 20. tnaabi-CMI_CLOAon BikWatn ` (lcuiS) CO , Q*1 Z---, ( L<over 18 Lo 0 E C.t.9t- ( ) under 18 21 .0}jAhvirlAtt4±,a711ri -hntFiCra.ic e r �o (� ( ) over 18 41,78;ati .:� e yj4(9 ( ) under 18 22. L -�4,y c..'' ch a .�.� w— C rli �A, C a c.e c ? ( ver 18 �� /�! ( ) under 18 23. to �� l� .70:di /^�/ irblo40, 9,14/ ( over 18 2 rP31S 4 � i(%) t � I ( Vover18 ) der18 l/ L 4 ,l� ` � R l5 C Luc cob; �AC `Ord b Vhi 11� it ,C 4sv Cs- v r y 9 Sad f�ik 0 ( } under 18 ` �{.�� alM C' � 51-14Ocreek., ( ) over 18 26. ;5 Y �i 7 ' C ik pit i ( ) under 18 � J G�� 1-� ,c.•�� ` �� rft �L :, c• v 0 to �° z i 1-- ( ) over 18 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 TIMELINE 2013 • Kevin and Cynthia Sullivan purchase parcel #020133400003 in Carr, CO 2014 June • Carr residents become aware of tanks . partially buried . • Mr. Sullivan informs residents of plan to store and spread septage on parcel # 020133400003. Exhibit 1 picture of tanks July • Carr resident. Willa Hintergardt sent an email to Weld County regarding her concerns about Mr. Sullivan 's proposed plan . and the quality and safety of water within the Carr community. Exhibit 2 copy of email communication 2015 September • Carr residents learn of the Sullivan's applying for a permit from Weld County for his three, 20,000 gallon tanks which he already buried on parcel #020133400003. Exhibit 3 : the current picture of the area where partially buried tanks were seen in June. RESEARCH State Department of Public Health and Environment — State Department of Public Health and Environment - Water Control Commission 22. 1 Scope and Purpose 2 .A. - Management Agency point b: "if the proposed facility is located in the unincorporated area of the county. The county through its commission or it designee. is requested to review and comment upon. the relationship of the treatment works to the local long range comprehensive area as it affects water quality: the proposed site location alternatives including the location with respect to the flood plain: and the capacity to serve the planned purpose. A recommendation of approval from the county is considered to be a statement that the proposal is consistent with the water quality considerations contained in its local comprehensive plan. " It is clear that under state statute the State of Colorado holds County Commissioners legally and morally responsible for maintaining water quality. The Dangers of Raw Untreated Septage on the Carr Ground and in the Colorado Water • Pathogens Page I 1 9378 County Road 124 , Carr. CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 • E-Coli • Bacteria • Hazardous Waste • NITRATES -According to a study done by the State of Alabama, " Nitrate contamination has caused the abandonment of more ground water supplies nationwide than toxic waste." Note that septage is used as fertilizer because of its nitrates and such nitrates may be good for crops but deadly to our water. ECS Monthly Bulletin April 2013 United States v. Hurley Enterprises. Inc. d/b/a Hurley's Oilfield Services, No. 4 : 13-CR-00001 ( D. N . D . ) . AUSA Cameron W. Hayden and ECS Senior Trial Attorney Christopher J . Costantini . On March 22 , 2013, Hurley Enterprises d/b/a Hurley's Oilfield Services (Hurley) pleaded guilty to a felony Clean Water Act violation ((33 U .S. C . §§ 1319 (c)(2)(A) . 1345(e) ) stemming from the dumping of sewage. The company was sentenced to pay a $50 , 000 fine and to implement an environmental compliance plan , which will be monitored over a two-year period by the North Dakota Department of Health . • Hurley is a sewage waste collection company that services oil well drilling sites in the u y g p Y Bakken/ Three Forks drilling operations in North Dakota. Hurley dumped domestic septage waste at various locations that resulted in the pooling of the waste as well as entry of the waste into waterways. At one dump site. toilet paper mixed with human waste was dumped down a steep embankment and into a ravine that led to Cottonwood Lake. At another site, domestic septage ran into an unnamed tributary that flowed into Epping in Spring Brook Darn. This case was investigated by the United States Environmental Protection Agency Criminal Investigation Division . Please note the applicant's property is very similar as he too has a steep embankment and a tributary that sits a mere 600 feet from his buried tanks. December 30 . 2014 , Preislerv. General Casualty Ins. CO 2014 WL 7373070 (Dec. 30. 2014 ) and Wilson State Ins.CO v. Falk. 2014 WL One case involved a septic service business that had a permit to apply septage as a fertilizer on their neighbors farmland . The neighbor's well became contaminated by runoff, killing some cattle. and they sued the septic business' insurers. The Supreme Court agreed with lower courts that the septage qualified as a pollutant, so the pollution exclusion applied and the insurance Page 12 9378 County Road 124 , Carr, CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 company did not have to cover the damage. "Onsite InStaller." "Wisconsin Supreme Court Finds Septage is a Pollutant in Well-Contamination ." Accessed 17.Oct. 1015 Please note in these instances water tributaries and famers were affected by the pollutant of septage. However, as you will read a tributary is on the applicants property and a large non - Tributary closed water basin sits below Carr Colorado so not only do risk the water of surrounding farmers we risk of 100 years of clean water siting below Carr if the applicants requests are approved . Waterways and water sources as they relate to parcel applicants proposed tanks and injection site. 4 - map of surrounding water ways Exhibit Y Exhibit 5 - map of the non-tributary, closed water basin Exhibit 6 - map of Carr Exhibit 7-Map of Wells Tributary on applicant's property is 600 feet from buried tanks • EPA - Under the Clean Water Act Considers Tributaries "Water Ways. " In May of 2015. the EPA amended the Clean Water Act to recognize the important roll tributaries play within our water systems. "On May 27. 2015 , the new definition expands regulation to all "tributaries to traditional navigable waters". The article continues: "Supporting the inclusion of all the tributaries under the New Rule, the agencies state the science, as summarized in the EPA's technical report concerning the ecological and physical connectivity of tributaries. has met the burden created by the Rapanos decision to show the significant nexus regardless of duration and magnitude of their flow." The article goes on to mention the EPA is able to regulate areas within 3/4 of a mile on either side of a tributary. "The significant nexus applies to any wetland that is not adjacent but within 100 year flood plain or within 4 , 000 feet or 3/4 of a mile of a tributary or tidal wave." "Environmental Consultants" "EPA and the Corps Issue New Definition of the "Waters of the U . S ." May 28. 2015. Accessed October 3 . 2015 Based on the New Rule of the Clean Water Act tributaries are now considered "water ways" and should be regulated . The applicant's tanks sit . 12 miles from the center of a tributary therefore considering the applicants testimony "all tanks leak" we ask the commissioners to decline USR15-0035. Page 13 9378 County Road 124 . Carr. CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 Spring Creek and Lone Tree Creek • Water resource for farmers. ranchers. and communities downstream. See exhibit 8 State of Colorado Determination of Non- Tributary Water See exhibit 9 Terrance Birdsall statement of Non -tributary water See exhibit 10 Statement of the Colorado Department of Health noted in the Quantum Water Quality Assessment See exhibit 11 NEP Letter to SEO Non- Tributary Aquifer • Weld County Planning Commission meeting . September 25 , 2015 summary: Commissioner stated ." He has some familiarity with the water system around Carr: he feels that compatibility with the land use citing Section 23-2-220.A. 3. the area is over the top of a huge non-tributary closed basin aquifer . He added that is also concerned with effluents to the Spring Creek and Lone Tree Creek. • The Dakota Cheyenne Aquifer according to Colorado geologicalsurvey.org does sit directly under Carr. Colorado. According to the Colorado Ground Water Commission . the Ogallala and the Dakota Cheyenne aquifers are now considered the Southern High Plains Designated Water Basin . "On June 30 , 2009 , The Colorado Ground Water Commission accepted amended Rule 5 .2 .3 for the Southern High Plains Designated Ground Water Basin so all the aquifers identified above can be administered as a single -hydraulic system." ("Water Level Measurements in the Southern High Plains Designated Water District 2014." 2014. Accessed 4. October. 2015. ) The South Platte River Basin water.state.co. us The Evidence the Dakota-Cheyenne and Upper Laramie Aquifers that Sit Beneath Carr Colorado is Non-Tributary • According to the Office of the State Engineer State of Colorado as of Dec.28th . 2012 state." Staffs Initial Determination is that the groundwater in the Upper Laramie aquifer underlying the Applicant's property in northern Weld County located in Section 19 of Township 11 North Range 66 West. 6th P. M . , is NON- TRIBUTARY . as defined in section 37-90-103 ( 10. 5), C . R . S" The State Engineer notes . " The Laramie -Fox Hills Aquifer (is) within the Cheyenne Basin can be up to 450 feet thick" • Evidence of the Depths and Bounds of the Aquifers that Lay Beneath Carr Colorado and ruling Aquifers are Non-Tributary • Please Note this determination from the State Engineer is on a property that is approximately 2. 5 miles from unincorporated town of Carr and the applicant's property. The Dakota- Cheyenne Aquifer stretches through a 7 , 000 square mile area . "The Office of the State Engineer State of Colorado also notes. "The Laramie-According to Page 14 9378 County Road 124. Carr. CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 The Geology Hydrology of the Deep Bedrock Aquifers in Eastern Colorado ( Water - Resource Investigations Report 85-4240) states . " . . Colorado and a zone of relatively fresh water extending Aquifer Fox Hills A uifer here is similar to the Laramie Fox Hills in the administrative Denver Basin . It is a confined aquifer at Niobrara Energy Park and within the Cheyenne Basin until its outcrop on the western mountain front and on the Greeley Arch just north of the Cache la Poudre River. "(Note this means that below that applicants property sits a wealth of clean untouched confined water) • The State Engineer notes that is a "confined aquifer". According to Terreance Birdsall of Quantum." Based on the remapping of these geological . it was determined that the Upper Laramie aquifer at the property is not in contact with the local surface water. which is part helped secure a non-tributary determination from the State of Colorado." (Meaning any bacteria, pathogens. and or pollutants that seep into the soil and then into the water will be damaged forever as the water sitting beneath Carr as a lake) • The Water found in the Dakota- Cheyenne aquifer and Upper Laramie Aquifer is Clean Drinkable Water that could last 100 years • One can conclude based on the State Engineers Report and the Geology Hydrology report that the "relatively fresh water" not only sits beneath the Niobrara Energy Park but if it extends 7 . 000 square feet that it too sits below the applicant's property. • According to the Colorado Department of Health ," The Laboratory analysis indicates that the constituents that were analyzed are within the Maximum Contaminant Levels for drinking water according to the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment. " • Quantum Water also notes the." aquifer life of 100 years. was used to calculate the total amount of ground water available." meaning beneath Carr there lies 100 years' worth of clean drinkable water. • Based on these finding we ask the commissioners to decline USR15-0035 in order to keep a major water source for Colorado Clean and DRINKABLE . Underground Storage Tanks See exhibit 12 Documentation of the type of tanks the applicant has buried See exhibit 13 Spec Sheet from dragon production tanks • Problems with Under Ground Storage Tanks There are many dangers when placing three 20 ,000 gallon 10 year old steel tanks underground. • According to the EPA, "The greatest potential threat from leaking USTs is the contamination of drinking water. "1015 Revised Underground Storage Tank Regulations". Underground Storage Tanks. (EPA, 1 July . 2015 . Accessed . September 28. 2015) . The EPA also recognizes. "Many mistakes can be made during installation . For example. the mishandling of the tank during installation can cause failure of fiberglass can cause structural failure of reinforced plastic tanks or damage to steel coatings and cathodic protection ." Beginning April of 2016 all Underground Storage Tanks , "must meet secondary containment requirements." The EPA is recognizing Page 15 9378 County Road 124. Carr. CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 Underground Storage tanks often leak and are proactively as of April 2016 requiring secondary containment on all new and existing tanks. • The EPA also requires the applicant certify the tanks he has already placed underground to be inspected . The EPA states." the installation has been inspected and approved by an implementing agency." As the tanks are underground they are unable to be inspected which violates the EPA regulations. The applicants steel tanks are buried and are unable to be inspected . This violates EPA regulation and puts our water safety at greater risk. • An operation and management plan for site under the State of Colorado Sec. 14-6-130 D. 3 require "Any provisions for the storage of domestic septage at the site. including type of storage and spill containment and clean up procedure. 'The above referenced Statue derived from the State of Colorado inherently implies UTS's leak and therefore such sites need to have a plan for spill containment and clean up. • Therefore not only does the EPA recognize spill containment is important but the State of Colorado also recognizes the need to have a plan for containment when UTS's leak. The EPA has such standards of secondary containment and inspection in order to minimize the risk of drinking water contamination . We merely ask the applicant to comply with such Federal and State safety measures . • Under normal circumstances we would ask the applicant for spill containment and or clean up procedures plan . According to the EPA any Underground Storage Tank is to have a secondary containment new or existing by April 2016. However, considering the applicants tanks are steel and their life expectancy is expired. They are faulty and are putting our water at risk. The tanks have not been inspected . There is no secondary containment system. They are near a water tributary. They are sitting above two aquifers that at their current state contain fresh water. We ask the Commissioners to decline the application to bury already buried tanks to hold septage with the end goal to spread such septage. This property has a tributary which is recognized as a waterway by the EPA and Clean Water Act. The risk of any buried tank holding septage that close to a tributary and laying on top of a closed fresh water basin is too great of risk not only to Carr but to the State of Colorado. Existing Land Uses Weld County Chapter 23 Zoning Division 4 Sec 23-2-220.A.3 states "USES which would be permitted will be compatible with the existing surrounding land USES". Environmentally Sensitive Land and Wildlife • The land surrounding the applicant's property is in CRP which is "removing environmentally sensitive land from agricultural production and planting species that will improve environmental quality." There are several parcels of land surrounding the applicant's land that are in CRP . As noted earlier land qualifies to be part of the CRP program because it is "environmentally sensitive" meaning that it is fragile land in Carr's case is being restored to mostly native grasses that will hold the ground and Page 16 9378 County Road 124 . Carr. CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 sustain our abundant antelope population , deer herds. and rabbits. • Considering that the applicant noted he is an expert in the septic industry for 21 years and also noted "all tanks leak" . It can be argued three 20. 000 gallon tanks of leaking septage is not compatible with "existing land uses" of the surrounding "environmentally sensitive land ." If the applicants permit is approved and when septage does leak from the applicants tank what effect will it have on the these "environmentally sensitive lands" and the wildlife that is sustained from the applicants property and surrounding properties. • Sec 14-6-1100 Operating Standards for Domestic Septage Permit K. Animals shall not be grazed on the land for thirty days after the application of domestic septage. As we antelope can be seen grazing on the applicants know the Carr area is very unique as p Pp q and surrounding properties on a daily basis. Carr is a prime hunting area and such native animals have the opportunity to graze the applicant's property at any time. Such grazing on contaminated ground could have devastating effects on the wildlife and or the hunters that consume the wildlife. Thereby the applicants proposed use of the land is not compatible with current use. Long Term Use of Land Under the State Department of Public Health and Environment from the Water Control Commission 22 . 1 Scope and Purpose 2. A. Under Managements Agency point b. States the following : • The county through its commission or its designee is requested to review and comment upon : the relationship of the treatment works to the local long range comprehensive area as it affects water quality: the prosed site location alternatives including the location with respect to the flood plain : and the capacity to serve the planned purpose. • The state delegates commissioners to evaluate the" local long range comprehensive area as it affects water quality." If the commissioners are considering water quality when reviewing septage storage facilities we surely can argue allowing the applicant to store three 20, 000 gallon tanks of septage a mere 600 feet from a "water way" (tributary) according to the Clean Water Act is " not compatible with existing land use". This tributary supplies water to Nunn and Peirce. If the commissioners deny the applicants permit they will be upholding the provision and thereby ensuring the health , 14 Se. 12-6-140 A. 9. States safety, and Weld County Department of Health PChapter the following : • "There is adequate provision for the health . safety. and welfare of the inhabitants and the county." The tributary on the applicants property connects to other water ways (Spring Creek and Lone Tree welfare of all those who use the water that flows from the applicants tributary. We urge the commissioners based on these matters to decline USR15-0035 . Weld County is a Right to Farm County that is why many residents in Carr have moved there and remained there. Weld County Right to Farm Act States the Following , 124 . Carr CO 80612 Page I 7 9378 County Road . Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 "Water has been . and continues to be. the lifeline for the agricultural community. It is unrealistic to assume that ditches and reservoirs may simply be moved "out of the way" of residential development. When moving to the Country. property owners and residents must realize they cannot take water from irrigation ditches, lakes or other structures, unless they have an adjudicated right to the water." The water siting beneath Carr is a life line to the following farmers: 1 . Mr. Brad and Mrs. Robin 2 . Mr. Scott and Mrs. Dee 3. Mr. Ross Mrs. Linda 4 . Mrs. Mosness 5 . Mr. Phil 6 . Mr. Chuck 7 . Mr. Eric 8. Mrs. Bev 9. Mr. Loren 10. Mrs. Vicky 11 . Mr. Bill and Mrs. Willa 12 . Mr. Buck 13. Mr. Shadrach 14 . Mr. Rusty 15. Mrs. Aubrey 16. Mr. Gallegoes 17. Mr. Arvin 18 . Mr. Harold 19 . Mrs. Arta 20 . Mrs. Charlene 21 . Mrs. Marilynn 22 . Mr. Mike 23 . Mr. Kenneth 24. Mr. Dana 25. Mr. John 26. Mr. Duane and Mrs. Lynn 27 . Mr. Loren 28. Mr. Troy 29. Mr. Brent 30. Mr. Steve 31 . Mr. Kelly 32 . Mr. Justin 33. Mrs. Marsha Page 18 9378 County Road 124 . Carr. CO 80612 Bree Lukens USR 15-0035 34 . Mrs. Gerturd 35 . Mrs. Shannon 36. Mr. Richard 37. Mrs. Melissa 38. Mrs. Donna 39, Mr. Kenneth 40 . Mrs. Brennda 41 . Mrs . Kristina 42 . Mr. Bill 43. Mr. Bo 44. Mrs. Allison 45. Mr. Harold Please note there are 207 households in Carr Colorado and of those households we gathered 174 signatures of those is opposition of the approval of USR15-0035. The above lists are of those actively farming and using water a "lifeline" to their livelihood and way of life. Those mentioned on this list and petition to have a RIGHT TO FARM . There are other options for the applicant the owner of a commercial business to dispose of untreated sepatge. The Plant located in Greeley Colorado and the plant located in Denver Colorado. There is no need to put the farmer's water in Carr at risk. We have RIGHT TO FARM please decline USR15-0035 . Page 19 9378 County Road 124 . Carr, CO 80612 Pt T It • !r` _ -• . . - - A r�.` r • i rY 1•'S... 1 . tr- . ./. . If*/ • . is • i *sr . .` 41; 0b ' • 4.4.-110% .°144i, II ' 1 4441Sop • 4. IN • .. -4. ..... It; • le •• • .4 a :1/4. • I` 1 '1 y �lli1F•Ms ! 'v a • I y , 'a .. . ; . �r r , ,}�' t •!Zr �y•" •r . - ' f , -�. } ✓ •` .IAj i t:i / :. ` ' . a M t wk- , ��' . . �J • r '! ;'.i 1t t ' � 7• a �:� a'Ie ! + _ w i •� ~ y, ,1 - -, ` • -1 ` w , : I '',', .ji4 �• i ALT . • ;mow •.- , ��t• •I.. ♦. ' Mr • . _ �• : ♦17 • �i� r t • i �111{� I a ° t'Pr �V M •ply"% �fF-! f{, `', -�{a. �y�y _ -1,:.,,,it ' .�< ; • ,• ♦•Y1 1 +'w / , "R• } yyf�� •,1. • \ ` lis L' \{`' ,.. { '].• \ e , , 'fit\S "ft'� t rl '' 'y }. NAN:1I S r..� ,l. j ., .. • I .I • •/ilir ♦♦ .i�' 1, �' r f J'� •,! '♦ 1 . i. I 117 ; �f " L a� r,1. ► • / .� ♦ .,a - I•.� It. .J;`` 1 , . •1• .. • t 1t .1 V.t .. -• . ( tell. It • 0^.`i , �Vr -, •/ C 1 l ; -pi. ,! : ( ' iR I ,• 1• : I 1. 1• .: ! �'•1`�• �i'•'+� - . 'I I4 '1. •'I•' 1}1 ' 44ill eIS I, 1 i ,'.fc "11� , lr °11 �• � •s I •'. • ' . 4 • 1 r • ' 4 I ' !. :71 M � . .l•r' • i •• '4 • Ti 'I•� ' r Y. '• �`•. •+ t• 1' �! �� /• �{ t 1 • '{ 7 •4'•s •1�' 1' •1 1 �• . f. . II I ,• 1 ' 1 ° t. .1 14 ill • • - • - _ • 1 ♦• . -1s tit )1. t 1 t ` „ t{,' Exhibit 1 4, _ ... -6‘e colts-_��•___ JI Vr N// �e- 1A { J � r Page 1 of 1 Exhibit 2 wbhintergardt@ezlink.com From: <webmasterOco.weld.co.us> Date: Wednesday. July 2. 2014 9: 12 AM To: <wbhintergardt( ezlink.com> Subject: Copy ol Online Code Complaint Name of Complainant: Willa Hintergardt Address of Complainant: 61183 County Road 19.5. Can CO 806 Email Address: \vhhinteruardt tezlink .com Complainant Phone: 970-897-2434 Address of Alleged Violation: PIIIINISQ002r and 0201334190 Nature of the Alleged Violation : Buried three 30.000 to 50.000 gal. tanks to fill with sewage to be spread on land. How are Your, Your Property Impacted by this Alleged Violation? illammisamtakesti* Where is Your Property in Relation to the Alleged Violation: Less than 1 mile. Have You Discussed Your Concerns With the Property Occupant? I haven't. If Not. Please Explain Why? There is no residence on property Are You in a Subdivision Which has Covenants that Prohibit the Activity? No Have You Contacted the Homeowners Association? Select 9/ 14/2015 rs Covered Tanks jpg Page 1 of 1 \-- Exhibit 3 l • r . _ . , , hitt_ _ , . .,, s. _ : .. .+: y a • • _' t . ';� _:. • tom/+`rf• ♦' �: r •. • •a. 9 s.� ,r - x / .• • . •,,,,,r '' •.� Via, : s - • ..`. -• . •� I r. t..1 • • ♦ - . F+ yam'•` . •• • K t .• � _. - • • Ali• • : • • �! - - - - -. ' - , ' ••1. •. • A - �.: • t •i hops://mail.google.com/_/scs/mail-static/_ljs/k=gmail.main.en.xfAJ2j 1 ormQ.O/m=mi.t.i ... 10/12/2015 ., i WELD COUNTY r eke.," ONLINE MAPI'INti Exhibit 4 , 1 , --f---7,---------.--- . y_ .7.:-J-1------7--- -, \_, -. - !1t 4.. r . . • 7- e � 61 . , 7 i _.--, �� ;� Lj it _ . iii .11 , Legend I E3 ! r: Parcels : - Highway ' IIS Road r • ratfll1I3R Road — Highway • 'N O County Boundary 101 • TotaC 6' - Al • Current_ 3631.25 It Total: 3631.25 ft r. I 1 cii 5?, y ! rr . R 't. ' i � _ , _ _ _ . : 1: 27,4590 1 120 Notes rgrx, Distances to tributaries leading to two 4,576.5 0 2,288.25 4,576.5 Feet This map is a user generated static output from an Internet mapping site and is for major creeks reference only Data layers that appear on this map may or may not be accurate, WGS_1984_Web_Mercator Auxiliary_Sphere current, or otherwise reliable © Weld County Colorado THIS MAP IS NOT TO BE USED FOR NAVIGATION �.♦ d , .t. ...-1, S Y-♦ •fir 'r4 f 4...."41• , ln 4 a a. 1 • • .) ti:‘, i 4.• _•'-Y. t1 . _. Exhibit 5 44 f l's . - . *. 'r I • *' .t r ` a r �' 10 .Ill lit , t ... :- - ?it- it' wiy 4tt • X-ti tiSALimitaliaiiirry-.%rn- 40044 ix .#p+ k . fai a 1 . 4 _ 0t { k 1 tot ilk . a • .r rwMrwul�+ „ R i . ,; I ` _ ... • .. _ •. a - 4. r. bri."141.1Priettal . ... _ . . - r ii 1 _ t. t � C - i. title - a i F 7 ':�"Y t�Ki3..- '1'fy i Vt.'. 't. -.:.r-- �sis.�. a • .., - I Y If 'VAN iffIfesihsw•I s. it Set 1. t 046 lfle 11 Ks: C ill • w r rib '0 ep i a I . I is ....w 1 I r -,fir- ..r' S .• It r�•Exhibit 6 a,_ a " # upon.--'- r �t•r—' _ 'mot , l ii II r a. I • ,II^ .' • ` •r .. C. •"• •� .� $ r w �' _• lir 5 1 tr Jk. i lir) ., Iv L. d _ � ' Lk'� .bir: . ! ! tr di M J e " A I 4, 1 , • is K ._ .7.. i! k. • OS A .mac' _ .. S 11 • t :°4 a ' ._ 411 '..• 'ICIIj < i f; / •� t a 1 ..• i • I Ai if .• , / e } I �T r� '• `.e"ssl • -i. en,... ... -yIF if_ , i 4 . . I . , . ft . t .. si itil . ‘ , --4 ,y I I Petition to Stop USR 15-0035, Sullivan , Docket # 2015-95 10/14/2015 10 : 00 am Exhibit 7 Approval for Underground Septage Storage Facility Toni' 159 RV „ . • • T 1.74 1 r c-71 tcy I/7 7,1111: rffil • ' :Vf: i eQ r • • • • 'fold'O lid R1i dot ass ai Tait 0.00 psi - • ,-j ^f , �- ,, ,n _. • Total: 0.63 mi fr 2 ; • G Total: 0.1? mi 'These are estimates as the submitted site plan did not offer exact coordinates: nor, appropriate measurements Weld County Online Mapping was used to generate this map- http //www co weld.co. us/maps/propertyinformation/ L (no subject) - breelukens@gmail.com - Gmail Page 1 of 2 Exhibit 8 Gmail COMPOSE (no subje I Inbox (19) BEFORE THE OFFICE OF THE STATE ENGINEER Starred Bros Lu STATE. OF COLORADO Important r,,c Sent Mail IN THE MATTER OF THE NIOBRARA ENERGY PARK LLC PETITION FOR ) Drafts (29) NONTRIBUTARY GROUND WATER IN THE LARAMIE FORMATION IN Circles NORTHERN WELD COUNTY, COLORADO; (UNDER ) PERMIT APPLICATION ) andcqee RECEIPT NO. 3655537) IN REFERENCE TO ISSUANCE OF WELL PERMITS ) kateet PURSUANT TO SECTION 3740-137(4), C.R.S. Moonwwwwwwwwww Notes Personal FINAL DECISION OF THE STATE ENGINEER Travel -More This matter involves a petition ("Petition") submitted by Niobrara Energy Park ("Applicant") on June 4, 2012 requesting a determination of nontributary ground water for an area as further ;.;;Ick described in the attached Initial Determination of the State Engineer's Office. The Applicant submitted the petition in accordance with the State Engineer's Policy 2010-4 and gave notice as required by the policy. 2,6 GB(17%)of The policy allows 30 days for and person to respond to the petition. The SEO received no Manage comments from any parties. The Applicant provided clarification on the petition in subsequent correspondence. As a result of the correspondence and further discussion between the Applicant and the staff of the Hydrogeological Services branch of the Division of Water Resources ("Staff'), the Staff completed an Initial Determination on December 28. 2012. FINAL DECISION OF THE STATE ENGINEER I. The State Engineer has reviewed the Petition submitted by the Applicant and the Initial Determination completed by the Staff. 2. The State Engineer has determined that Applicant and the Staff have acted in accordance with Policy 2010-4 and hereby adopts the Initial Determination (attached) and grants the Petition by finding that the subject ground water identified in the Initial Determination is nontributary, as that term is defined in Section 37-90-103(10.5). Dated this 281° day of December. 2012 ick Wolfe, Di r-State Engineer BEFORE THE OFFICE OF THE STATE ENGINEER STATE OF COLORADO INITIAL DETERMINATION OF THE NONTRIBUTARY NATURE OF GROUND WATER PURSUANT TO STATE ENGINEER'S POUCY 2010-4 IN THE MATTER OF THE NIOBRARA ENERGY PARK LLC PETITION FOR NONTRIBUTARY GROUND WATER IN THE LARAMIE FORMATION IN NORTHERN WELD COUNTY, COLORADO; (UNDER PERMIT APPUCATION RECEIPT NO. 3655537) IN REFERENCE TO ISSUANCE OF WELL PERMITS PURSUANT TO SECTION 37-90-137(4), C.R.S. tticksitiosi •u "L---- ' _ _._. 0 ._s. 1 , .. ... . __.. _._,.., ....L......_,+ .. nw,....._ A._ f\.....�.......:.... _� __......1.... https://mai l.google.com/mail/u/0/?tab=wm 10/ 14/2015 (no subject) - breelukens@gmail.com - Gmai1 Page 2 of 2 BEFORE THE OFFICE OF THE STATE ENGINEER STATE OF COLORADO IN THE MATTER OF THE NIOBRARA ENERGY PARK LLC PETITION FOR NONTRIBUTARY GROUND WATER IN THE LARAMIE FORMATION IN NORTHERN WELD COUNTY, COLORADO; (UNDER ) PERMIT APPLICATION RECEIPT NO. 3655537) IN REFERENCE TO ISSUANCE OF WELL PERMITS ) PURSUANT TO SECTION 37-90-137(4), C.R.S. FINAL DECISION OF TH E STATE ENGINEER This matter involves a petition ("Petition") submitted by Niobrara Energy Park ("Applicant") on June 4, 2012 requesting a determination of nontributary ground water for an area as further described in the attached Initial Determination of the State Engineer's Office. the Applicant submitted the petition in accordance with the State Engineer's Policy 2010-4 and gave notice as required by the policy. The policy allows 30 days for any person to respond to the petition. The SEO received no comments from any parties. The Applicant provided clarification on the petition in subsequent correspondence. As a result of the correspondence and further discussion between the Applicant and the staff of the Hydrogeological Services branch of the Division of Water Resources ("Staff'), the Staff completed an Initial Determination on December 28. 2012. FINAL DECISION OF THE STATE ENGINEER 1 . The State Engineer has reviewed the Petition submitted by the Applicant and the Initial Determination completed by the Staff. 2 The State Engineer has determined that Applicant and the Staff have acted in accordance with Policy 2010-4 and hereby adopts the Initial Determination (attached) and grants the Petition by finding that the subject ground water identified in the Initial Determination is nontributary, as that term is defined in Section 37-90-103(10.5) i I Dated this 2e day of December. 2012 ick Wolfe. Di r-State Engineer BEFORE THE OFFICE OF THE STATE ENGINEER STATE OF COLORADO INITIAL DETERMINATION OF THE NONTRIBUTARY NATURE OF GROUND WATER PURSUANT TO STATE ENGINEER'S POUCY 2010-4 IN THE MATTER OF THE NIOBRARA ENERGY PARK LLC PETITION FOR NONTRIBUTARY GROUND WATER IN THE LARAMIE FORMATION IN NORTHERN WELD COUNTY, COLORADO; (UNDER PERMIT APPLICATION RECEIPT NO. 3655537) IN REFERENCE TO ISSUANCE OF WELL PERMITS PURSUANT TO SECTION 37-90-137(4), C.R.S. N.I,kn'und https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?tab=wm 10/ 14/2015 Abstract: THE IMPORTANCE OF ACCURATE GEOLOGIC MAPPING FOR AQUIFE... Page 1 of 2 Exhibit 9 Annual J 1 J/ QrC-rJr., R. ) Expo .IWAIIIIMan,r. A l {n`{a l M� �l of { i g & Eltp`' .• ,: '.,. it : - 1:' j 0 tutwt !.13 „ ,,ei 'Afofado USA ll l s • Vicki OF /1MZ RIGS' � "° . i . . . - . . •i, . Start I Author Index I View UpiodieJ i-resentatwns I Meeiuny }niu'mation Paper No 9 Presentation Time: 10.30 AM THE IMPORTANCE OF ACCURATE GEOLOGIC MAPPING FOR AQUIFER DELINEATION AND CALCULATED SURFACE WATER DEPLETIONS, NORTHERN WELD COUNTY, COLORADO BIRDSALL, Terrance R., Quantum Water Consulting, Lakewood, CO 80235, terrance@quantumwaterco.com Based on geologic mapping circa 1978, it was determined that significant discrepancies existed between the geologic descriptions and known aquifer boundaries at a property located in north central Colorado. The geology of the area was refined using surface mapping, a review of more recent literature, analysis of subsurface geophysical logs, analysis of water well lithology logs, and discussions with regulatory geologists. Published geologic mapping of the area indicates Laramie Formation is located at the surface of the majority of the site. However. it was determined that the White River Group exists at the surface and extends several miles beyond the southern boundary of the Property, significantly further than the 1978 mapping suggested. A large paleo-stream channel deposit. the 'natural fort' often pondered by geologist passing between Wellington, Colorado and Cheyenne, Wyoming along Interstate 25, was also mapped through the area as the Chadron Formation. The remainder of the White River Group, predominately tuffaceous claystone and siltstone, is reinterpreted as the Brule Formation member. The White River Group formations have been determined to be regional aquicludes, and perched water from the Ogallala Formation is easily observed in outcrop. Based on the remapping of these geologic formations, it was determined that the Upper Laramie aquifer at the property is not in contact with the local surface water, which in part helped secure a nontributary groundwater determination from the State of Colorado. Session No 9 T42. Current Groundwater Challenges in the Rocky Mountain Region Sunday 27 October 2013 8 00 AM- 12 00 PM R:):'7? 20' (Colorado Convent,r,r Ctr;iu-•r i Geological Society of America Abstracts with Programs. Vol. 45. No. 7, p.45 © Copyright 2013 The Geological Society of America (GSA), all rights reserved. Permission is hereby granted to the author(s) of this abstract to reproduce and distribute it freely, for noncommercial purposes. Permission is hereby granted to any individual scientist to download a single copy of this electronic file and reproduce up to 20 paper copies for noncommercial purposes advancing science and education, including classroom use, providing all reproductions include the complete content shown here, including the author information. All other forms of reproduction and/or transmittal are prohibited without written permission from GSA Copyright Permissions. See more of: Current Groundwater Challenges in the Rocky Mountain Region See more of: Topical Sessions « Previous Abstract I Next Abstract >> 2013 The Geaogrcai Sooety of Amenca https://gsa.confex.com/gsa/2013AM/webprogram/Paper232207.html 10/ 14/2015 Abstract: THE IMPORTANCE OF ACCURATE GEOLOGIC MAPPING FOR AQUIFE... Page 2 of 2 https://gsa.confex.com/gsa/2013AM/webprogram/Paper232207.htm1 10/ 14/2015 Fwd: StorageTank - breelukens@gmail .com - Gmail Page 1 of 2 lExhibit 10 Gmair uuo Fwd• Stoi Quantum Water Consulting I Inbox (19, Jackie f 3500 S Wadsworth Blvd., Suite 408 Starred Lakewood, Colorado 80235 Important (720) 524-4294 UUMN Sent Man _ ,, . • Drafts (29) From E Circles Date it Subject andcqee To Jack kateel CC Wlk Moonwwwvnrwwwww July 2, 1012 Notes GoOcl Mr Craig Harrison Persona! Harrison Resources Travel AttaCM 2725 Rocky Mountain Avenue #400 More Which t Loveland. CO 80538 I hope RE• Water Quality Analysis, Niobrara Energy Park, Test Hole Water Sample Emily O ,wo. Dear Craig: m 3(P7' As requested, the following narrative discusses the results of the laboratory analytical analysts of the From: J. ground water collected during the test hole drilling The water sample was collected on May 12. 2012 Sent: T, and submitted to Accutest Analytical Laboratory in Wheat Ridge. Colorado. The analytical laboratory Subject results are attached and Table 1 is a summary of the results Hells The water sample was analyzed for inorganic parameters and general cnemistry The test hole was drilled using a polymer gel and a surfactant. both petroleum based distillates. These additives did not affect the analytical results since they are organic based constituents. The Material Safety Data Sheets I ihn. for these additives are also attached to this letter An analysis of the analytical laboratory results indicates that the sample is of water that is naturally occurring and is derived from silicate igneous rock minerals such as feldspars, micas and amphiboles The laboratory analysts indicates that the constituents that were analyzed are within the Maximum Contaminant Levels (MCLs) for drinking water according to the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment (CDPHE) as indicated on Table 1 Please let me know if you have any other questions Sencerely. QUANTUM WATER CONSULTING nica..� ,e r trli Theresa Jehn-Dellaport President attachments www.guardurni'solerco.CGrri Table 1 - Summary of Water Quality Analysis for MEP Test Hole Samea ore Sn 1/lot. Ellstals Analysis links Results Maximum Contaminant Level Mj nrrxr'. rngfl 0.631 - Antimony mg4 <0.03 0.006 Araarrc. m➢li <0.026 001 Barium mil 0.117 2 Hoyt" mQfl <0 01 0.004 Garsurri frail <0.01 0.006 Carew , mgfl 193 • Chromium mgfl <001 0 1 Copps mgfl <0.01 Laao (191 <0.06 • Mare" 'TI94 452 • https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?tab=win 10/ 14/2015 Fwd: Storage Tank - breelukens mai1.com - Gmail Page 2 of 2 g @g g • Quantum Water Consulting 3500 S Wadsworth Blvd.. Suite 408 Lakewood, Colorado 80235 (720) 524-4294 QUANTUM * A r ! . July 2, 1012 Mr Craig Harrison Harrison Resources 2725 Rocky Mountain Avenue 1$100 Loveland, CO 80538 RE Water Quality Analysis, Niobrara Energy Park, Test Hole Water Sample Dear Craig. As requested, the following narrative discusses the results of the laboratory analytical analysis of the ground water collected during the test hole drilling The water sample was collected on May 12. 2012 and submitted to Accutest Analytical Laboratory in Wheat Ridge. Colorado The analytical laboratory results are attached and Table 1 is a summary of the results_ Thewater sample was analyzed for inorganic parameters and general chemistry The test hole was drilled using a polymer gel and a surfactant. both petroleum based distillates These additives did not affect the analytical results since they are organic based constituents. The Material Safety Data Sheets for these additives are also attached to this letter An analysis of the analytical laboratory results indicates that the sample is of water that is naturally occurring and as derived from silicate igneous rock minerals such as feldspars, micas and amphiboles The laboratory analysis indicates that the constituents that were analyzed are within the Maximum Contaminant Levels (MCLs) for drinking water according to the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment (CDPHE) as indicated on Table 1 Please let me know if you have any other questions Sincerely. QUANTUM WATFR CONSULTING / 1 ` A dam". J M.. •• ,l et, t ern Theresa Jehn-Dellaport President attachments w►sw quanturnwaterro: !71 Table 1 - Summary of Water Quality Analysis for N?EP Test Hole Sample Dar Sit V2012 W1als Analysts thAb Raub Ilaxrnurrn Contaminant Land Maw' myl 0.631 Ammons mpl$ <0 03 0.006 Aran mpll <0025 0 01 Barium mpfl 0 117 2 Baryban mg$ <001 0.004 Cadmium mQA <0.01 0.005 Cane) mqA 19 3 - Chromium mgll <0 01 0 1 Copps mGA <0.01 • Lac rrg0 m 05 Magrasrm myn a 52 https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?tab=wm 10/ 14/20 1 5 Exhibit 11 Quantum Water Consulting igh 3500 S Wadsworth Blvd., Suite 408 Lakewood, Colorado 80235 (720) 524-4294 QUANTUM WATER September 18, 2012 Mr. Matt Sares Office of the State Engineer 1313 Sherman Street, Room 818 Denver, CO 80203 RE: Additional Information in Support of the Niobrara Energy Park, LLC Petition for Nontributary Ground Water in Northern Weld County, Colorado (Receipt No. 3655537) Dear Matt: This letter is a follow-up to the Professional Report submitted to the Office of the State Engineer (SEO) dated June 1, 2012, and a response to your comments dated August 22, 2012. In support of Division 1 Water Court Case 11CW275, Quantum Water prepared and submitted to the SEO on September 11, 2012 an Expert Report (Report), including a North-South hydrogeologic cross- section to determine the thickness and lateral extent of the aquifers beneath the Terry Grazing Property in northern Weld County. The Terry Grazing Property, generally located in the northern two-thirds of Township 11 North, Range 67 West and the southern half of Township 12 North, Range 67 West is immediately adjacent to the proposed Niobrara Energy Park (NEP), located at Section 19, Township 11 North, Range 66 West. The data complied to draft this hydrogeologic cross-section and the associated Report have been released to Harrison Resources, the developer of the Niobrara Energy Park, for the purpose of supporting the petition to the SEO for a nontributary ground water determination. In agreement with your August 22nd comments, the production interval from 1,400 to 1,800 feet below ground surface (bgs) has been reinterpreted as the Fox Hills Sandstone. This corresponds well with the geophysical logs of nearby oil and gas wells, and the completion reports of nearby water wells. The geophysical logs, as shown on Plate 1 in the Report, indicate that the thick (1,300+ feet) Laramie Formation and the Fox Hills sandstone are one contiguous, saturated interval. This interval has been identified as the Laramie-Fox Hills ( L-FH) aquifer. The static water level of the NEP Test Hole 50626-MH, 143 feet bgs (measured April 15, 2012), is 70 feet below the contact with the overlying White River Group, and shows the L-FH aquifer to be unconfined. The hydrogeologic cross-section (Report, Plate 1) was extended approximately 35 miles to the south, past the nearest perennial stream to NEP, the Cache la Poudre River. The data from oil and gas geophysical logs, water well completion reports, and surface geologic mapping show that the rocks of the L-FH aquifer crop out north of the axis of the Greeley Arch, are not in direct connection with the Cache la Poudre River, and are separated from the river by the Pierre Shale. The NEP Test Hole 50626- MH is also included on the cross-section (Report, Plate 1). After 100 years of continuous withdrawal, a well completed on the Property into the L-FH aquifer will not deplete the Cache la Poudre River, or any other natural stream, at an annual rate greater than one- - - - www.quantumwaterco. com Mr. Sores September 18, 2012 tenth of one percent of the annual rate of withdrawal. As defined by C.R.S. § 37-90-103(10.5), all ground water withdrawn from wells completed into the L-FH aquifer at the location of NEP is nontributary. As there are no connected stream segments to model to, aquifer modeling was deemed inappropriate. Sixteen-inch short normal resistivity values from three oil and gas geophysical logs (Amoco Champlain 279, Lone Tree State #1-14, and Solar Petroleum No. 2) and one water well (DWR Permit Number 96966) were used to estimate the saturated thickness of the L-FH aquifer. Using a conservative "shale line" value of 8 ohm-m2/m, as outlined in the Report, the estimated saturated thickness of the L-FH aquifer below NEP is 1,130 feet. This saturated thickness, along with a specific yield of 15% (based on the Denver Basin rules), the 644-acre NEP property, and an aquifer life of 100 years, was used to calculate the total amount of ground water available (Table 1, below): Table 1 - Estimate of amount of ground water availability beneath 644 acres Saturated Thickness Acres (ft) Specific Yield Acre Feet Acre Feet/Year 644 1,130 0.15 109,158 1,091.6 With these conditions, there are approximately 1,091.6 acre feet per year of nontributary ground water available from the L-FH aquifer beneath the Niobrara Energy Park. We would be happy to further discuss with you our findings if you like. In the meantime, please contact us with any questions at your convenience. Sincerely, QUANTUM WATER CONSULTING Liao. /AL ilealrgsvite Theresa JeM Dellaport President cc: Craig Harrison, Niobrara Energy Park, LLC Skip Kelly, Select Energy Page I2 Fwd: Storage Tank - breelukens@gmail.com - Gmail Page 1 of 2 < Exhibit 12 Gmail COMPOSE Fwd• Stor DRAGON Production Tanks I Inbox 1191 API 12F Jackie I Starred e Important Sent Mail -_._-_. - Drafts (29) From. E gQ - �,� Circles Date Ti 7. t • ^%S.. --• r t._ Sublea 't „liar i` • , w ..�: . andcgee To Jac*. Stp w '� •- .y,;'- i } kateet CC W lk � l. •—� - ? r - MoonNMnrwwwwwww : .fi ,y:: • Notes Y=.• - tare- Personal Good f r "`�' Travel Attach( More which c ., I hope _ Emily �; From: I. oESKar Sent: It MOM MAL oz PER 50.ft MOMS mew Peon- SubjeCt CAPACITY PRESS. VACUUM CAPACZttrttl. Ft.•IL F1 90 16 1/2 72 10 Hells 100 - 16 112 79 9-6 8 150 16 112 129 94 12 i' s - . IT . • - 200 16 1/2 166 12-0 10 - r• 210 16 112 200 10-0 15 - 250 16 112 224 11-0 15 s~ l, • 7 , 300 16 12 266 12-0 15 � � . . - "- 400 16 12 366 12-0 20 ' -. ate 500 16 1/2 466 12-0 25 `7j(�'; .. \ . - .4- 600 6 112 479 15-6 16 750 8 1/2 746 15-6 24 SPECIFICATIONS: ADD-ONS AVAILABLE • Built to API 12F specifications monogrammed - API Manways • Threaded Fittings and non-monogrammed • Stairs and Walkways • 3/16 or 1/4 inch steel plate construction • Gravel bands • Dike walks • Steel shot blasting prior to direct to metal • Decelerators • Cable Level Gauges industrial coating paint • Fill Lines • Thief Hatches • Internal lining available • Knuckle Boom Truck Delivery 0 '_ a in v You Tube ..mlt,o,.... a,. ;Z •3 :4 le • r " tie` sales@modernusa.com • www.dragonproductsltd.com • 800-231-8198 13 0 y • U.S. owned and operated tor over 50 year Production Tanks API 12F � � sa COaQT01 N• 1 It WOW �� Ra J[ C.1 a4 rp= 1 c•0 C-1 CD ® 1 1 ^ ir r - - I-7 Ovf1-n... C-• .K •CAaICDa 1 1 1 t \ I I ~WA Iir ngar � � l _ `� evol-stwe r--,,, av-nw I .ia , um https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?tab=wm 10/ 14/2015 Fwd: Storage Tank - breelukens@gmail.com - Gmai1 Page 2 of 2 4CDRAG0N Pro API 12F @ . . , .0. a 2 a ' • 7Zi 1 j +• �� 1 - 14. 1 1. i .. ,lip \ IC% itipina ..it dY - . , . _ L. _ ft 90 16 112 72 7-11 10 100 18 1/2 79 9-6 8 150 16 1/2 129 9-6 12 / 200 18 112 166 12-0 10 Z 210 16 112 200 100 15 siatrais. 250 16 112 224 11-0 15 -lat , 300 16 1R 266 t2-0 15 400 16 1R 366 12-0 20 • �,r- ��rne 500 16 1R 466 12-0 25 "i -- 500 8 112 479 15-6 18 750 8 1/2 746 15-6 24 SPECIFICATIONS: ADD-ONS AVAILABLE • Built to API 12F specifications monogrammed • API Manways • Threaded Fittings and non-monogrammed • Stairs and Walkways • 3/16 or 1/4 inch steel plate construction • Gravel bands • Dike walks • Steel shot blasting prior to direct to metal • Decelerators • CaWe Level Gauges industrial coating paint • Fill Lines • Thief Hatches • Internal lining available • Knuckle Boom Truck Delivery • ��M�1 ° II V You Tubemoccortcs.uses :ft.. ,, e f sales@modernusa.com • www.dragonproductsltd.com • 800-231-8198 • -" • U S. owned and operated for over 5Oyea•s Production Tanks API 12F ar Lai CPKCIO• H' • 7I' Ca4007 CDrR10 m CL J• C•7 LI tins, t C-) MT CO•[CIoi CI corn r ley r Ors re- tar rtt 1 ,..... OyO�L0V \V 1 I V/ pyp. • a , .K C�•CIO• CONCH). I https://mai l.google.com/mail/u/0/?tab=wm 1 0/ 1 4/20 1 5 a Page 1 of 2 Google Maps 1 •• ₹ 1 V • i f it i i, ..•= ,• .• - - ^ t - -, .' :•••‘'e' } '4' t•• r . ''' : _ .. _ X t• J 1 • t at 1 • • a y'*x•�Qw,..s 1' u K ` - 4. ( � h . * a• { v , i • ./ .. Y 4 N •,y,• Y •. e- Y 3 •. • 'y • ..I ti: F ..- 4? a •• •I'" ••• i 'r'' ••',N • `1241>J4 • 1, y x..: '•• m1••. ••,y''?{"+'': AI*. ' J •' xx + � „ '� t ,�. y£y,,-.► ( v - t1••Q ... s .•, —.,�i,:.`83W1'1!•.• ": A ' p' r w l� / »d "" ".y , ' s. t r. • V • ac • aw>+e►•i.+ ,.•r w a r i- r '.�� # - Y' (1 5 T �. •- r . .,.r r r °° �_.V-� ! e> ••• �,( --"* htl j - • 3 a:..' yi • - a • •. _ - O i _ +q•�t - t t - -'°& ,�. ". -+ - ' �... r'• s t ii, 4 µ. _ • r may' t .• 4 ,' } ..�I .M- r x. .'-' fir.�., a eV : } � 'b s 1.2:.- ', .i •t-JI'+1�, t •1. :.� � - RRaOe; i . •�i 40$44„.1... _^""• • RT'•, I r � • ..a:. v Y• ,., � ✓ '1f •err,..✓. yam, a Y • ?r: * .. . - . .�y .. . :. �K ,ice 4•,r:,:,;:. JY " : •' 7 .r.. ;;' '. +. 8'"'>7`fr �3se ?:,�; w_ • °- 9` $� _ - • • �1•,•P,y �. . . ( .:�j, •. :r • a•"�- ti r♦ ,t • :.• C + . Ir . .,• 41' •�r ` • .. t , tl •tk I. - ♦-' • - t _y.its , - ` • t, 1 - �. ... `• t s Sy`. ' } l • 1.5h • •Pr -4'� IL}!, ♦ : ad �..j�,r 4 ` f1 .f�l -e -.4,, . • - s • ilf Z. tice�•�• ••••••„:,•, 116\t„, " . r .4 lii �y ',4 ::-1 : . .. '- ,. • � A.56✓.t•- � • n. :..A}� v -�, 'F • w::: - E •� 4 4r-A`>.‘" s, 4„ �,. .4 `.,.- • 9 _ { i try �•..,w 1' '. uQ -'( - .. .a'><�.: •- T s;..C y, Tce„J`;4 .�. i s..,,, >8-'v>s.w:.. 4 ♦ ,i• ... , 044- t `s . - il arol ,-- _ir 1• •� { ''" Y ' ;.fly;., �• w, - 1:,2-1 • 7 °' ' .. 6 4 r .��J",,}, `in K�lii •rap og 're-: R �t y .did! T'�"!¢, •w:'�',w ' •4. ;;aq „ �f. x�' �,ry• �i f" • .. .' .. i /. � ........"4 "lailbilliMiala I'allirliallejniaaratrajill-r-. 4 • i - • . .4 ''' ,_ A. • .•- ' '' ,r i 1, ` _-♦ ' ,,... :: ' . - °?$� , TA.. . r ►f_• • IFi_I4 ''' _* •�.' +lid • tot? �• 6 t + y, ` sr it `� .•_ ` r Yf Y * _ - . + - t tT =•` _ , �r 1 4 At .-•► ., • #.✓ a►,.,?,. z `S,= T•w''�,.s ' , f1' '''ice•-r• 1 �C.?i. ` � t •J14• �? ,� .- r. • . ' [2 'e i '• ^1 }S �, i r r ,. « J • itt� 1 w,' ,rt e; ..�M • iy�-a ,airR ter}. ' , �.. - 4� �J r t*iriY . i •f � •. F � 4 ' �� • >p. ) . • .ti. ► T• '• rtlu.14+ a t•N• ,Y r•1 • C .4:23i:# Pt q,�.+ r r'•r• '4 ,•%i1'�/, : '• ' ;'4.,. yf1, —, `'4 t �- },+a �x� � _ • , ,k p31�,i•,T+ ..~.f • f � • S i. t .1. - ,'w • ii ' .�,a'i-•'"•1. .ypq a}'YR K .�• • ~ •rx4., •Al .. v f`y� •• <.'i}I.'' }Z '"F' .•« • r y r 1 •U•.l .J . • Ix b .�qr� < y• ,� ;'. 1 1 'J°- 1 •1 ]• - 1.'.� �.•� �jl':Y' ., �'•' A- 1�., E' • -416 Ta. S, r +• i- •, 111p� l- • wr i ryr �i 14 ' > t ` y�a' fL'� • 2,► w, L 3 •�::�' 1 apt* v • 1 . # t .. . * ' r • • '� �' -1 .J Al ' nar ,• 4 Ci- _ a-.Ti t •- *:faems_ "l k-' i v,� '4.4_ .)Ht*ft 1 , • 1 »•Y•r` d/ 42:J. ma✓. - i1 V 'i .• 4 • ! < 4,411.4„,6 f •}i..• a ,�_�"' F s rr 1 •1 • ,,.•. J .�,�_}• ' 'a1, r Z ems_ fit•.. ! 2,;:d„,'4.4_ :.4t_1 ♦ 2'4,t.r, 4 1F. • • ,f.: 4 w � 0.4" 7•f• "'-. s;-.* K'- • � .�2 � x'_•ta, Z=..•• 1 ,.Z'..3- .� . •}A ti �:rr. �t • - :a , r ..ty.• ,^♦ • i` 1-}M by f 4. •v - F' -. t- _. „;•;. - •` • .. ,{t e.,:-. , I is i-!�� ms'sr - -. i. _ t - "M.ny 44 Ys s4.n• 'ai Op.•ri '.. 1 �. • P•k h .. $ ;•m • f - �_ . .a v iR.-_,... ..,a_ . �..:• t:1/4. . 'V[ .^;�•r� �., , -• .+• fF r a - _ `._ _ • - '�i .o. N.. • -, • r , ,� i et c7 ar 1 � '+ •,. �_ 44 ! Wit': ^•" . • • • ° � ,-is � E� . a �. • • : � . . EXHIBIT . C4. . r' , ;,.,• �_! O .1 ,., , a• S i , r wIt e Of 1 `) 1 • . 1 ` . at • sulf to 'vLV • https://www. gle.com/maps/place/Carr,+CO/@40.893219,- 104.8783379, 1 data=l3m1 ! 1e3 !4m2 ! 3m1 ! 1s0x876ed71634987aef:0xf4aa9ea..• 10/19/2015 n • EXHIBIT Terrance R Birdsall, PG Jan 11O1w~ Tellus Geologic, LLC •m11010® --06 . '0010101 President 12kt1O1OO1O `L001010 ;0 2.021 West Custer Place Denver, CO 80223 USA Main: +1 866 TELLUSRocks Fax: +1 866 835 5877 Cell: +1 720 360 5262 Email: trbirdsall@tellusgeo.com Hydrogeologic Assessment Prepared for the Residents of Carr, Colorado Opposing Mr. Sullivan 's Septage Storage and Spreading Plans October 21, 2015 a,,-l ,„ Tellus Geologic, LLC (lift)) avatito2021 W Custer Place Tel lusGeo . vi.o ,y 866- TELLUS7 4 -, Art, -Ii.. •:_ r ....A.;.4. ..,irk --, _ $ -- -` 'Ji ;tY * ; t . .''`Ns .r "�_. ~1 ter. 'y-. .. . m..1-- _ . . -. ' ....1-. .... ,,,...c,IC 2 - yep. _ w _ — tTT:1. ,;r.a '1 sesiSTP414r -- 'ter '-+� t f .`' ...as ,. --ada' - - ..is.-r - i gyp 4. de ,� - Jct ;fit "� C t� t •l dim.. Y Hydrogeologic Assesment - Carr, CO October, 2015 Prepared for the Residents of Carr, Colorado Opposing Mr. Sullivan 's Septage Storage and Spreading Plans A VI aP /Prepared by: ' Tellus Geologic, LLC 2021 W Custer Place Terrance R. Birdsall, P.G . Denver, CO 80223 President 866- TELLUS7 Hydrogeological Assessment - Carr, CO Table of Contents Introduction 2 Hydrogeologic Background 2 Contamination Possibilities 6 Expert Opinion 8 Conclusion 8 Sele cted References 9 Project No. 100.1 October 21, 2015 .of Page 1 �o�1.�o0 "Aoo OiOll .,,sioa , Hydrogeological Assessment - Carr, CO Introduction In October, 201 5 , TellusGeo was asked to evaluate the geologic and hydraulic conditions of a parcel and it' s surrounding properties in Carr, CO as they pertain to the possibility of contamination due to the storage and field application of septage from a portable chemical toilet cleaning business . While not in a State legislated Designated Groundwater Basin , the residents of Carr are in a sensitive nontributary groundwater basin , containing nonrenewable water resources that need extra protections for continued successful livelihood and agricultural development for the residents . Hydrogeologic Background , I .` WYOMING The majority of Colorado ' s plains east fi + , of the Rocky Mountain Front Range are ;` ;° 1 \, underlain by a large structural basin , iqb the Denver-julesburg , or DJ basin , as • • • shown on Figure 1 . The basin formed 1 ; �, 1 1 asymmetrically , and two smaller sub- I Cheyenne 8asin basins were created . The structural = `"'°°"` NEBRASKA 1 \ centers of these sub basins are located • Carr COLORADO awryft/al r 1 approximately below the cities of :I -- idredly Cheyenne , Wyoming and Denver, and / . _ 1 1 .• Denver Basin are known as the Cheyenne and Denver •-;; , \ Basins , respectively . Carr, located so far jDcncr KANSAS north in Weld County , is outside of the . .; . e•-• :-',-.- , i te structural and legislated Denver Basin as ,_ ' defined in the Denver Basin Rules ( 2 CCR ;-• , ;, : Calends1 : ; 1 : .402 -6) , and is located just south of the '- \\Hr. ." ' 1 center of the Cheyenne Basin ( Figure 1 ) . ". . I\ w 1 • 1 .7 • 1 N The large space created by the depression '44%. ��: F (L_ 0 co1 Mho of the Di Basin was subsequently filled '�R ' with sediment , either by marine deposits Figure 1 - Structural contour map of the Denver- from the inland seas of the Upper julesburg Basin showing the bottom of the basin in feet above mean sea level ( msl) . Modified from Weimer ( 1996) Cretaceous , or by terrestrial sediments derived from the rapidly uplifting Rocky Project No. 100.1 October 21, 2015 �oia '` Page 2 Ik,ololoo° :po c;iioa Hydrogeo(ogical Assessment - Carr, CO Mountains during the early Eocene . Local geologic mapping suggests that there are three geologic formations in the vicinity of Carr, the Upper Cretacous Laramie Formation , and the Eocene Ogallala Formation and White River Group ( Figure 2 ) . Older geologic mapping shows Carr to be totally underlain by Laramie Formation at the surface . Recent geologic mapping and reinterpretation in support of Water Court Case 1 1 -CW- 275 and water well determination requests with the State Engineers Office (SEO) have found the area to be more complex . Carr and the surround area are totally underlain by the Brule Ash Member of the White River Group ( Figure 3 ) . The ash layers can be several feet thick or more , are made up of tiny particles of denitrified glass and clays , and becomes impermeable when wetted ( Figure 4) . The ash is Figure 2 - Geologic map of the Carr region . To = Ogallala Formation , Twr = White River Group, and KI = Laramie Formation . From Braddock and Cole ( 1978) . WYOMING NIMIIIIMS COLORADO 0 11- 1 R67: R66V i o ' ,. ‘-n . ni.ast°-4 ' 1 a t 4.,.(-_- 24 , i.5.1 :C . :..„. ,.. ._, ; , ._ i 23 a ' Ba, p twa ? s TTo __ c . / ' �� ._ 33 31 1 t o `• — ` . r y :nu �w , r . a mg : . I Imo - AP Fr -Taci rola . a , a Vta M t _t P . ` : --41111/4 -* NI - . - 1 • atir) ri‘ t i I ...' ,:f: Eir 4 126 RD _ter- -- ?.— -- .k _ Carr, . -.p • ae Colorado ) --- . i I_s _ 3C JO T11 T11N A t - - ; ' �t22uu t L 4 t#c . 1 fi M i 'a i, ' : • 73• 1 16 r r ail f. Project No. 100.1 October 21, 2015 .OS t Page 3 U01O111O9 0.A0o1o]i. , ' 1 Hydro geological Assessment - Carr, CO r -an \& Ci....-n-Sri , bef\Q? \VI--- ir..<4.-\<.....6O0____N0.nre.. , tS). CL, cnitny(0.0 .••%...1 --; S }% • Cif ., s terk..,... La,t, "Li? V ( ? - frj. "- L.,/ cl:::;:t-- . . ' k (<-1j \ /�st Lacji_To //7-1: 7\14i717-1:------::4‘ ,y) Etc (cr.A, , ,„.4 , \t. % t I 4i ' IP- -7,9® --,.. i ., ..4 11'14-- ---NN%\--3 it C. \C-, ,9Q0 `'` �, 0r ip ,,, ) 4 ) , ,.,. LN,_ ,, _ , 0 :?..,„__ _ .._. r r�! r r r r r S W l �r:� r�r r r r r is � �� 1 a'4"' iitI � � � (\l 7, e., Ae rk ax`re .1 1 '"- 1 N_ \\\) (‘Cirm)ii> t . .1 V\I ' C: \ tiftriy -\?.; A sh.n, NCtil ' 61 3 I e.i.ij' Ye:MD I Le) i ca ___,—\\\- -\.ThL__ ir - - 14 :._ • - . eti .7,----N . k\ • I Figure 3 - Reinterpreted geologic map of the Carr vicinity in support of 1 1 -CW-275 (Modified from Quantum , 201 3) . Blue dots represent Chadron Member outcrops of interpreted sand channel . not uniform in thickness or in aerial Figure 4 - Typical Brule Ash outcrop near Carr. distribution , and large channels of i - " ' • Chadron Member sand have been O: zy :-'-♦ .: .' identified cutting through the layers -- :-o` -• - . - ` .- ., -: .Y � - > making conduits for fluid . These • ` � " > ` + 4 ' - tai_� � -A r • � _ ._ .y.'' fine-grained deposits are in sharp . contrast to the younger Ogallala o'er , .Formation that overlies these ash . r '�'r. 4::_ _-, . r&lrt t • beds . The Ogallala is a massive • conglomerate in this region , where - large rock clasts of over one foot are `. common ( Figure 5 ) . The Ogallala is •",' - generally well saturated , and makes 1 - • Project No. 100.1 October 21, 2015 .111103 Page 4 oinno.o0 h1 01010 of boo�Q 1k Hydrogeologtcal Assessment - Carr, CO t:: 44 e , _ 4,.0 • •� •_ 'Jar r :Pr* • A,- . r� . . " \W2!•••A .., _ } _ ♦ , ` . .7 r r _ „j,,, Figure S - Typical conglomeratic Ogallala Formation Figure 6 - Water ponding on Brule Ash under a outcrop (top) with Brule contact (at same hight as perched Ogallala aquifer seep. regulators). r - . . 4.40 • � >> +_ ._ .. ' r • I • 1 v • er r I .0' .... e. r _ sr— _4 va • r • y 'Ira' r. A •;.. , ilk �. .k ' I .Is rig .y, J '- ti., - • r • tf.,A •• of .��" {`" a 1isik 8 , - „ \ . - Si s ill • r ay .. #1 . - WO"' -• ' . . • er a ,J.rr d f .°d. iS . as rii1•: arr Figure 7 - Shale and coal-rich Laramie Formation Figure 8 - Porous, sandy Upper Laramie aquifer sand drill cuttings. drill cuttings. Project No. 100.1 October 21, 2015 oo Page So vivo- Hydrogeological Assessment - Carr, CO small disconnected unconfined aquifers where water ponds up on the Brule Ash , as seen on Figure 6 . Below the Paleogene deposits are the sands , shales and coals of the Laramie Formation (see Figures 7 and 8) . The Laramie Formation formed at the margin of the Cretaceous Interior Seaway . Much like the coastal mangrove swamps of today , sand mixed with significant organic material is common in the sediments . Small river channels cut through , leaving clean , poorly cemented arkosic sands . Where saturated , the Laramie Formation can produce significant water, in excess of 300 gallons per minute . The Laramie Formation thickens towards the Wyoming border, and contains significantly more sandstone than it does in the Denver Basin . Below Carr, the Laramie Formation supports two separate aquifers : the Laramie - Fox Hills and the Upper Laramie aquifers . The Laramie- Fox Hills aquifer is deeper, confined , and separated from the Upper Laramie through a thick shale sequence . The Upper Laramie aquifer is unconfined , near the surface , nontributary , and the aquifer of main concern in the Carr area. It is this nontributary water with an expected 100-year aquifer lifespan that Carr residents are most concerned with , as all domestic and stock watering wells in the area are supplied by the Upper Laramie aquifer, or surface (alluvial ) water. The regional groundwater flow of the aquifer appears to be to the north and east , towards Cheyenne the structural center of the sub- basin . The parcel where Mr. Sullivan has buried his tanks (Parcel ) is located on a small rise , underlain by the highly porous Ogalalla Formation ( Figure 9) . Large rocks and fossils are common on the ground . Local water well driller logs ( Permit Nos . 260808 , 93419 , and 292670) show that it is likely that the conglomerate is not more than 10-40 feet thick . The surface is covered with Ogallala Formation float and outcrop throughout the Parcel , including into an ephemeral drainage approximately 60 feet away and downhill from the tank location , as depicted on Figure 9 . Outcrop and driller logs show that immediately below the surface is the Brule Ash . Contamination Possibilities With the large proposed storage volumes and application rates of septage proposed for this Parcel , there are significant potential risks for the local ephemeral surface waters and bedrock aquifers . The Ogallala Formation , while highly porous , is disjointed and likely has small to larger zones of perched water on top of the Brule Ash . Ephemeral seeps and steams can been seen where this interface outcrops at the surface . These are present on this Parcel ( Figure Project No. 100.1 October 21, 2015 uoo�o Page 6o o�oo� Hydro geological Assessment - Carr, CO 4 0'l '' 411F1 - ' ittliiiip "% -. ..r kitab liee. 'V.I.:1-;;; Illpbpr- • ,.• • , -i4^.+y•` : e . I 'wl Cie: : r ` ' ' ' v _ �. - • T k ' : • • - 1:-- % I, 1 - . l' j r Figure 9 - Mr. Sullivan ' s Parcel looking north ; yellow arrow is location of tanks , approximately 60 feet and uphill from an ephemeral drainage (red arrow) . 9) This water is usually rapidly evaporated , or lost back into the perched aquifers through percolation . Where the Brule is discontinuous or eroded under or near the Parcel , the sands of the nontributary Upper Laramie are exposed . Should a storage tank have a catastrophic leak , the complexity of the interconnected and perched aquifers would make in - situ cleaning highly improbable , likely requiring costly pump and treat systems for water users hydraulically down -gradient from the contamination leak (which is north -east , towards the more densely populated downtown Carr) . It might also contaminate nearby ephemeral streams and ponds , perched on the Brule Ash . The proposed application rates for the parcel are also potentially a source for long term geochemical contamination of the nontributary aquifers . The Environmental Protection Agency ( EPA) data shows that on average , domestic septage has almost 40 times the concentration of metals and other contaminants as domestic wastewater ( EPA, 1999) . Carr, located in an extremely arid region , only receives 10 - 12 inches of precipitation per year. An application rate of 25 , 000 gallons per acre per year is the equivalent of adding an additional 0 . 8 inches of precipitation . The ability of a hydrologic system to flush or dilute these concentrations is poor, and it is unlikely that the fragile prairie biologic system can naturally attenuate these high of Project No. 100.1 October 21, 2015 1 d;; Page 7o oiogg Hydrogeological Assessment - Carr, CO concentrations ( NMGS , 2003 ) . Septage concentrations of this magnitude could quickly make an entire communities water supply unusable . The EPA also notes that there are additional complexities for disposing of septage from chemical toilets because of the antibacterial and disinfecting agents used in the chemical toilet cleaning process ( EPA, 1999) . Expert Opinion It is the opinion of this author that sufficient surface and groundwater protections have not been put into place at the Parcel that could prevent the catastrophic contamination of a pristine nontributary aquifer. Further groundwater and geochemical studies should be required to ensure that both : any leaks can be contained , and that application rates are reasonably low enough to prevent groundwater contamination . Conclusion Mr. Sullivan ' s buried tanks are in a highly porous aquifer- bearing rock that is complexly connected to a large , regional nontributary aquifer that is crucial to the successful livelihood and agricultural development for the local residents of Carr. TellusGeo ' s investigation into the hydrogeologic conditions of Mr . Sullivan ' s parcel , and the surrounding properties of the residents of Carr has shown that not enough work has been done to ensure that there will be no contamination due to the storage and field application of septage from his portable chemical toilet cleaning business . Project No. 100.1 October 21, 2015 nags- .003.0101.0- Page 8 ow:alt „oioill � 810101002 • Hydrogeological Assessment - Carr, CO Selected References Boyd , D .W. , & Lillegraven , J .A. , ( 201 1 ) . Persistence of the Western Interior Seaway : Historical Background and Significance of lichnogenus Rhizocorallium in Paleocene Strata, South -central Wyoming . Rocky Mountain Geology , V 46 , p . 43 -69 . Braddock , W.A. , & Cole , J . C . , ( 1 978) . Preliminary Geologic Map of the Greeley 1 ° x 2 Quadrangle , Colorado and Wyoming : U . S . Geological Survey Open - File Report : 78 - 532 . 1 : 250000 . Bredehoft , J . D . , Neuzil , C . E. , & Milly , P. C . D . , ( 1983 ) . Regional Flow in the Dakota Aquifer : A Study of the Role of Confining Layers . U . S . Geological Survey , Water Supply Paper 2237 , 45 pp . Dahlgren Consulting , (2005 ) . Final Report , Pine Bluffs Lance Fox Hills Well , Wyoming Water Development Commission , Level II Study . Cheyenne , Wyoming : Dahlgren Consulting . pY Y Y 9 9 Dechesne , M . , et . al . , ( 201 1 ) . Notes on the Denver Basin Geologic Maps : Bedrock Geology , Structure , and Isopach Maps of the Upper Cretaceous to Paleogene Strata between Greeley and Colorado Springs , Colorado . Denver, Colorado : Colorado Geological Survey . Denney , K . F. , et . al . , ( 1 995 ) . Water Quality in the South Platte River Basin , Colorado , Nebraska, and Wyoming 1 992 -95 . U . S . Geological Survey Circular: 1167 . Driscoll , F . G . , ( 1986) . Groundwater and Wells . Second Edition . Johnson Division , St . Paul , Minnesota. Environmental Protection Agency, ( 1999) . Guidance Manual for the Control of Wastes Hauled to Publicly Owned Treatment Works . U . S . Environmental Protection Agency Manual EPA- 833 - B- 98 -003 Fetter Jr. C .W. , ( 1980) . Applied Hydrogeology . Charles E . Merrill Publishing Company , Columbus , Ohio . Freeze , R.A. , & Cherry , J . A. , ( 1979) . Groundwater. Prentice- Hall Inc . , Englewood Cliffs , New Jersey . Project No. 100.1 October 21, 2015 „ 01- Page 9 }wi011�no03.0.0 o < „ts4' Hydrogeological Assessment - Carr, CO Green , G . N . , ( 1992 ) . The Digital Geologic Map of Colorado in ARC/ INFO Format : U . S . Geological Survey Open - File Report 92 - 0507 , p . 9 . Kirkham , R . , O ' Leary , W. , & Warner, J . , ( 1 980) . Hydrogeologic and Stratigraphic Data Pertinent to Uranium Mining , Cheyenne Basin , CO . Colorado Geological Survey , Information Series 1 2 . Kirkham , R . & Rold , J . , ( 1986) . Water Resources of Upper Crow Creek , Colorado . Colorado Geological Survey Special Publication 29 . National Climate Data Center, ( 2014 ) . Fort Morgan , CO US , COOP : 053038 . National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration . Downloaded from Website . Paschke , S . S . et . al . , ( 201 1 ) . Groundwater Availability of the Denver Basin Aquifer System , Colorado . U . S . Geological Survey Professional Paper 1 770 , p . 274 . Raynolds , R . G . , ( 2002 ) . Upper Cretaceous and Tertiary Stratigraphy of the Denver Basin , Colorado . Rocky Mountain Geology , 37( 2 ) , p . 1 1 1 - 1 34 . Raynolds , R . G . , & Johnson , K . , (2002 ) . Drilling of the Kiowa Core , Elbert County , Colorado . Rocky Mountain Geology , 37( 2 ) , p . 105 - 109 . Raynolds , R . G . , & Johnson , K . , ( 2003 ) . Synopsis of the Stratigraphy and Paleontology of the Uppermost Cretaceous and Lower Tertiary Strata in the Denver Basin , Colorado . Rocky Mountain Geology , 38 ( 1 ) , p . 1 71 - 1 81 . Robson , S . G , & Banta, E. R . , ( 1 993 ) . Data from Core Analyses , Aquifer Testing , and Geophysical Logging of Denver Basin Bedrock Aquifers at Castle Pines , Colorado . Denver, Colorado : U . S . Department of the Interior, U . S . Geological Survey Open - File Report p . 93 -442 . Rocky Mountain Association of Geologists ( RMAG ) , ( 1972 ) . Geologic Atlas of the Rocky Mountain Region , United States of America : RMAG , Denver, Colorado . Rocky Mountain Association of Geologists ( RMAG ) , ( 1 977) . Special Publication No . 2 , Subsurface Cross -Section of Colorado . RMAG , Denver, Colorado . QE651 R6 . Project No. 100.1 October 21, 2015 i�'Ut4 V13 0100 t Page 10 0001°l�°° a�oloii1oc 810101011 Sao�0iO - Hydrogeological Assessment - Carr, CO Topper, R . , Spray , K . L. , Bellis , W. H . , Hamilton , J . L. , & Barkmann , P. E. , ( 2003 ) . Ground Water Atlas of Colorado . Colorado Geological Survey Special Publication 53 . U . S . Geological Survey , ( 1 978 ) . Northern Colorado [ map] . Biostratigraphic Maps Series 1 - 7000 . Reston , VA : U . S . Department of the Interior, USGS . 1 : 24 , 000 . Weimer, R ._J . , ( 1996 ) . Guide to the Petroleum Geology and Laramide Orogeny , Denver Basin and Front Range , Colorado : Colorado Geological Survey Bulletin 51 , p . 1 27 . Weist , W. G . , Jr. , ( 1965 ) . Reconnaissance of the Ground -Water Resources in Parts of Larimer, Logan , Morgan , Sedgwick , and Weld Counties , Colorado , with a Section on the Chemical Quality of the Water, by R . Brennan . U . S . Geological Survey Water-Supply Paper 1 809 - L, p . 24 . Woodard , L. , Sanford , W. , & Raynolds , R. , (2002 ) . Stratigraphic Variability of Specific Yield within Bedrock Aquifers of the Denver Basin , Colorado . Rocky Mountain Geology , 37( 2 ) , p . 229- 236 . Project No. 100.1 October 21, 2015 ti I% o Page 11 oo3.100. wM 1�OLOT.• File contains Thumb drive - Birdsall Presentation Please See Original File EXHIBIT I 'R �oo Hello